6 ms·
Discouraging smokers from moving to e-cigs is a bad idea, but discouraging non-smokers is a great idea. It's a tough tradeoff, and I don't think the analogy to
by mikeash 9y ago
Discouraging smokers from moving to e-cigs is a bad idea, but discouraging non-smokers is a great idea. It's a tough tradeoff, and I don't think the analogy to sex ed is really a good one. Virtually everyone has sex, so teaching abstinence is foolish. But most people don't smoke, so saying "don't smoke, not even e-cigs" is a good thing for that segment of the population.
Ideally, you'd get all the addicts to move to e-cigs, and everybody else to not use either one. Not that I have any brilliant ideas how to accomplish that.
- iaw 9y ago> discouraging non-smokers is a great idea Thank you, I hadn't thought about that before and you're completely right. If the risk profile for cigarettes is just barely too high for a non-smoker then e-cigarettes may be the last 'push' Although this does require some assumptions about why individuals start smoking cigarettes in the first place.
- mikeash 9y agoIt's sort of like the classic market segmentation problem. Ideally you want to charge each customer the maximum price they're willing to pay, but it's hard to give different prices to different people. Likewise, you want to push each person towards the least harmful version of smoking or non-smoking they'll accept, but you can't tailor general advice like that. In any case, it seems like much of the e-cig debate comes down to this. Those in favor see it as an alternative to cigarettes for smokers. Those against see it as a way to get non-smokers to consume tobacco.
- WorldMaker 9y agoOr even: get non-smokers to consume over-priced perfumes that have a good profit margin whether or not they contain tobacco/nicotine.
- majewsky 9y agoJust this weekend, I saw a friend of mine vape who'd never touched a cigarette. His arguments were "Relax, it ain't a cigarette." and "I only vape for the taste of the liquid." I expressed skepticism that burning random chemicals and inhaling the resulting smoke is healthy. Good to have some evidence to back that up.
- dgfgfdagasdfgfa 9y ago> discouraging non-smokers is a great idea. Why? If it doesn't have health costs, there's not much reason you should care. This study isn't even on the same planet as measuring health costs.
- mikeash 9y agoYes, if e-cigs are harmless then I don't care. I don't think that's very likely. Nicotine is not good for you. It doesn't look like there's any question as to whether or not e-cigs cause harm, only a question of how much harm.
- Udik 9y ago> It doesn't look like there's any question as to whether or not e-cigs cause harm, only a question of how much harm Same goes for almost everything.
- PeterisP 9y ago"Nicotine is not good for you" is slightly misleading - smoking tobacco is really bad for you, and the reasons for that have nothing to do with nicotine; smoking nicotine free tobacco would be pretty much as bad health-wise. To the first order of approximation, nicotine addiction is bad for your health because it causes you to burn and inhale plant matter, the common delivery methods of nicotine are horribly unhealthy but if you're talking about nicotine as such (for example, through a transdermal patch) then it doesn't really have significant adverse health effects.
- xigency 9y agoWhat about chewing tobacco? All smokeless tobacco has risks of cancer. I would not say that nicotine is harmless without a large amount of proof, and it should take about as much proof to say that it is not a carcinogen.
- mistercow 9y agoThere's actually been a lot of research on nicotine, and the conclusion is that it's _slightly_ carcinogenic. But more to the point, there was little reason to believe it would cause cancer in the first place, compared to any other random compound. Its association with tobacco is a wash, because other compounds, like aldehydes, are completely sufficient to explain the carcinogenicity of smoking tobacco.
- baddox 9y agoTo be fair, while I don't support it, abstinence only sex ed is usually in the context of high school, where it's probably not true that "virtually everyone has sex."
- mikeash 9y agoThe abstinence part is (almost?) always in the context of "until marriage" which can extend well beyond high school and remains highly mismatched with people's behavior. It should also be noted that abstinence only sex ed usually involves many outright lies, such as that sex outside of marriage is objectively immoral, that waiting until marriage prevents STIs, vastly exaggerated figures for the risk of disease and failure rates of birth control, etc. Whereas smoking is actually dangerous, and "don't smoke, it'll greatly increase your chances of getting these various horrible diseases" is actually truthful.
- baddox 9y agoThe "until marriage" part is usually part of the moral beliefs of the people who push for abstinence only sex ed in public schools, but I wasn't aware that public schools generally taught that part.
- ChristianBundy 9y agoI can't speak for others, but I was never taught the "until marriage" clause, and I graduated high school in 2011. We were taught that abstinence was the only way to completely remove the risk of pregnancy or STD/STI, which really doesn't change once you're married or whatever.
- mikeash 9y agoAre they teaching abstinence "until you're out of high school"? Otherwise it's either "until marriage" or "until death." I think most kids understand that marriage usually involves sex, even with bad sex ed.
- 9y ago
- wickawic 9y agoAnecdotally, my younger friends seem to be much more ok with someone vaping than smoking cigarettes, to the point that mentioning it is harmful is brushed off. This is among people that are not habitual tobacco users; it seems the advertising must be working...
- _Tev 9y agoIsn't it because people naturally assume e-cig smokers are actually ordinary smokers trying to quit? Most e-cig smokers I know fall in this category so I view all vaping people through that lens. And in that cotext such dismissive reaction makes sense to me.
- DanBC 9y agoIn the UK e-cig sellers have signed up to a voluntary code of practice where they don't sell product (e-cig devices or juice) to people who haven't ever smoked. That agreement isn't working very well, lots of sellers will sell to people who say "I've never smoked". It's a shame, because that's the kind of thing that could force more regulation. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-39523857 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-39523857 > The Royal Society for Public Health (RSPH) said 87% of shops were knowingly or unwittingly prepared to sell e-cigarettes to people who have never smoked or vaped.
- collyw 9y agoSo assuming you have never smoked and want to vape, go buy a pack of cigarettes first. Smoke one outside the vape shop. Job done. The whole idea seems kind of pointless. If someone want to vape, let them.
- DanBC 9y agoThere's some concern that people who vape move to cigarettes. I think there's been a little bit of research showing some young people moving to smoking from vaping.