3 ms·
It's both beautiful and meticulous. Its aesthetic merits aside, I am fairly skeptical the presentation actually offers any improved elucidation of or insight in
by pvg 16y ago
It's both beautiful and meticulous. Its aesthetic merits aside, I am fairly skeptical the presentation actually offers any improved elucidation of or insight into The Elements
- zb 16y agoIf you compare Byrne's version side-by-side with another (as Tufte does in Envisioning Information) then I think you'll agree that it's much easier to follow.
- pvg 16y agoI don't have Tufte's example in front of me, but I really don't find it any easier to follow. Compare, side by site http://sunsite.ubc.ca/DigitalMathArchive/Euclid/bookI/images/bookI-1.html http://sunsite.ubc.ca/DigitalMathArchive/Euclid/bookI/images... and the drab http://aleph0.clarku.edu/~djoyce/java/elements/bookI/propI1.html http://aleph0.clarku.edu/~djoyce/java/elements/bookI/propI1....
- Adaptive 16y agoAgreed. Having worked through Euclid with letters (in class, often out loud, mind you, so that may skew my imagination here) I really cannot imagine that colors enhance the process at all. I wouldn't be against colors in addition to letters, but colors alone, despite the superficial aesthetic appeal, seems nutty.
- ppereira 16y agoI've been tutoring Euclid to a Gr. 6 student. I gave him both the Heath and Byrne editions to work from but he has a much easier time with the Byrne, primarily because the proofs appear much shorter. The coloured pictures strip out an entire layer of pointer dereferencing.