7 ms·
Socialism is worse for your health and well-being than the "evil rich" can ever be. I live in the UK where we have a national health service paid for by direct
by onion2k 9y ago
Socialism is worse for your health and well-being than the "evil rich" can ever be.
I live in the UK where we have a national health service paid for by direct taxation. If I get ill I will be taken care of, by a government provided service, at no cost to me. If I don't get ill then I'll end up with a bit less money, but all the people around me who do get ill will be cared for free of any direct charge whether they're rich or poor. I literally cannot understand how you can think that's worse than any alternative for healthcare provision.
- FussyZeus 9y agoBecause for fifty-ish years the narrative in the US has been Communism is the enemy, and Socialism is the path to Communism, therefore Socialism is the enemy too. We're going to have to wait until the baby boomers die off to have any reasonable chance of getting a proper safety net in place.
- fivestar 9y agoI don't think the Boomers are the major impediment there--for decades it's been all about one generation and they have done nothing but suck the life out of everyone else while at the same time pulling up all the ladders. Why do you think high taxes and "safety nets" are the way to go? Why can't we just be free? How many times must collectivism be exposed for the fraud that it is before we stop re-visiting that waste of time?
- FussyZeus 9y agoThe problem is when we were totally and completely free within a few decades the entire means of production was owned by a few insanely large companies, and due to the relative laxness of their regulations, they operated with near total impunity. It was only after the uprising of labor and organization into unions that the real "golden age" of America arrived for someone besides the ultra-rich. Since then the media narratives and corporate propaganda have steadily demonized all collective bargaining entities, brought forth the scourge of the "gig economy" where businesses get to have multitudes of low-skill workers competing for a small fixed pool of work, all of whom jump at the chance to earn $20 because they'll starve otherwise, and carry none of the expenses of real employees (those annoyances like "a living wage" and "healthcare" and "retirement savings." And that's just the actual jobs, with automation eating more jobs ever faster, fewer workers are now producing more than ever meaning there are fewer salaries doled out and even less money making it away from the wealthy. Communism did fail, but I think it arrived too early. I really think there's some merit to the idea that once the machines have eaten all the jobs, and once we're free to our own time, that there's no reason to keep up the illusion that we must remain employed for seemingly little reason other than "that's the way it's always been done."
- thatwebdude 9y agoI don't know. We've been doing a 40 hour workweek because that's the way it's always been. We're more efficient now, but still cling to this idea. I mean, look at how many people are on this thread instead of work...
- fivestar 9y agoWhen was that? And how much do we know about it outside of a narrative that was written by people with statist tendencies?
- sidlls 9y agoI've got some bad news for you. My generation (gen-X) seem to have a strong affinity for Gordon Gekko types. It might actually get worse once people in my cohort start assuming more positions of power.
- ekianjo 9y ago> I live in the UK where we have a national health service paid for by direct taxation. If I get ill I will be taken care of, by a government provided service, at no cost to me The waiting lines in the UK for surgeries make it more likely you die before you get it in time if you have anything remotely serious. Yeah, socialist health care works really, really well.
- sgift 9y agoGerman socialist health care saved my life without bankrupting me (I've seen the bills) - so: I take my chances.
- fivestar 9y agoAnd US health insurance does the same without the high taxes. What is your point?
- delazeur 9y ago1. Good insurance is unavailable to many, many people in the US. 2. Good insurance is extremely expensive. If your premiums for good insurance are low, that just means your employer is paying a lot. I don't see much substantive difference between paying high premiums and paying high taxes.
- miguelrochefort 9y agoHow much does good insurance cost?
- delazeur 9y agoAnecdata: most of my employers have offered good (but not the best) insurance. If you didn't use it, the employer and employee contributions together were probably something like $10k-$15k. If you did use it, the employee contribution would be capped at something like $20k-$30k, but the employer contribution would be uncapped. Somewhat famously, the CEO of AOL (?) talked about spending $1,000,000+ on an employee's neonatal care.
- someSven 9y agoNot everyone equals public healthcare with socialism.
- TuringTest 9y ago> Not everyone equals public healthcare with socialism. I don't understand your assertion. Why would anyone do that, and what would they call public healthcare instead? Even social-democracy has socialism as one of its components.
- someSven 9y agoSocialism is about distribution of wealth. This is mainly about distribution of risk. It is also a more fundamental thing than creating a more equal society. It is also simply a fact that many people outside US don't call their country socialist just because they have a public healthcare system. So this might cause confusion.
- fivestar 9y agoFrom the outside looking in, your social welfare system seems ludicrous to me.
- VMG 9y agoSocialized health care is not socialism, and US health care is not free market health care.
- TuringTest 9y ago> Socialized health care is not socialism Then how do you define socialism, if it is not government-provided public services?
- jhbadger 9y agoThe term has several meanings. Scandinavian countries consider themselves socialist for their high levels of government support of education and healthcare, but so did the Soviet Union and similar countries with a state-run centralized command economy. When people in the US rally against "socialism" they are either thinking that what people in favor of socialism want is a centralized command economy or think that it is a slippery slope and that government support of health care will eventually lead to a Bolshevik insurrection or something.
- TuringTest 9y agoThanks, that explanation is helpful. In the future when I discuss about socialism with US people, I'll take into account the likeliness that they're attacking a boogeyman, and that a precise definition of the term will be needed to advance the discussion.
- ulucs 9y agoyou might be interested in this http://lesswrong.com/lw/nu/taboo_your_words/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/nu/taboo_your_words/
- TuringTest 9y agoThanks for the read. I intuitively try to avoid loaded words and think in terms of the properties they define; though this thread was about the term "socialism" in particular, not just the general concepts covered by it.