4 ms·
I think it's worth noting that there's a big gap in the perception of NAFTA (and its ilk) and their actual consequences. In terms of actual consequences NAFTA
by woodruffw 9y ago
I think it's worth noting that there's a big gap in the perception of NAFTA (and its ilk) and their actual consequences.
In terms of actual consequences NAFTA has had almost no effect on the US economy, either positive or negative: a 2003 CBO report found that it had increased the US's GDP by only a few billion dollars[1].
Different sides have presented job loss and gain in different industries over the last 20 years as evidence of enormous failure or success, but the reality is that the 20+ million growth in overall employment since NAFTA has probably been normal economic growth.
The real benefits of agreements like NAFTA for the US are geopolitical stability and economic dominance - Mexico is asymmetrically dependent upon us for trade, and that dependency has been central to their willingness to cooperate in border migration and drug policing efforts (which are arguably terrible uses of power, but are good examples of the influence brought by trade). The TPP presents (or presented) similar opportunities in Asia.
I don't reject the claim that people feel disenfranchised by trade agreements, or that the industrial-service shift has harmed millions of previously middle-class Americans. However, trade agreements can't be blamed for either of those: the first is a political talking point, and the second is unavoidable in a developed country with a chronic aversion to new job training and safety nets for workers.
[1]: https://www.cbo.gov/publication/14461 https://www.cbo.gov/publication/14461
- mistermann 9y ago> In terms of actual consequences NAFTA has had almost no effect on the US economy, either positive or negative: a 2003 CBO report found that it had increased the US's GDP by only a few billion dollars[1]. Compared to speculation as to what the economy would have been without NAFTA. > The real benefits of agreements like NAFTA for the US are geopolitical stability and economic dominance Which the US didn't have before? If anything, the US is far less dominant now. > The TPP presents (or presented) similar opportunities in Asia. Asia is eating the US's lunch without China even being competitive at the top of the value chain, which isn't too far away. When they achieve that, things will start to deteriorate even more rapidly.
- woodruffw 9y ago> Compared to speculation as to what the economy would have been without NAFTA. Sure, but it's just that: speculation. The reality is that the economy and jobs market have both grown, with no aid or detriment from NAFTA. > Which the US didn't have before? If anything, the US is far less dominant now. In terms of our relationships with Mexico and Canada? We're 50% of Mexico's imports [1], and 54% of Canada's [2]. I can't really dispute the feeling that we're less dominant. All I can say is that agreements like NAFTA and TPP are designed and refined with US economic interests in mind. When we leave the negotiating table, we lose our primary chance at advantageous trade agreements. > Asia is eating the US's lunch without China even being competitive at the top of the value chain, which isn't too far away. When they achieve that, things will start to deteriorate even more rapidly. If this is true, then trade agreements are especially vital. Developing economies need investment, and they're going to get it one way or another. [1]: http://atlas.media.mit.edu/en/profile/country/mex/ http://atlas.media.mit.edu/en/profile/country/mex/ [2]: http://atlas.media.mit.edu/en/profile/country/can/ http://atlas.media.mit.edu/en/profile/country/can/
- mistermann 9y ago> Sure, but it's just that: speculation. The reality is that the economy and jobs market have both grown, with no aid or detriment from NAFTA. No effect whatsoever, the outcome with or without NAFTA would have been identical, to the penny? How might you know this? > If this is true, then trade agreements are especially vital. Before China entered the WTO it was a 3rd world country, now it is challenging for #1 position economically and before too long technologically. They are eating everyone's lunch because of trade agreements. This isn't to say they don't deserve this position, in many ways they do (hard work), but they also got decades of free technology research gifted to them.
- woodruffw 9y ago> No effect whatsoever, the outcome with or without NAFTA would have been identical, to the penny? How might you know this? I'm saying that there's consensus that NAFTA's economic impact on the US has been minor. It might be the case that the US's GDP would have risen by 0.1% per year without NAFTA. However, at that scale, it's just a spending game. From a purely political perspective, what's more valuable: a 0.1% annual increase in GDP, or economic control over the only two countries that share your border?
- mywittyname 9y ago> Mexico is asymmetrically dependent upon us for trade Bingo. All other Latin American countries grew at a decent clip in the past 20 years (5-15% per annum) versus Mexico's 1-3% over the same period of time. Mexican wheat and corn industries have been decimated by American products so they've turned to high-price exports instead. At least we get cheap Mexican avocados for our toast.
- woodruffw 9y agoYes. Maybe I should say that these are positive statements about trade agreements, not claims that trade agreements produce good outcomes for all parties. The War on Drugs is a perfect example of how we've used our trade dominance to shape Mexico's domestic policy to the detriment of tens of thousands of their citizens (not to mention our own).