4 ms·
I think the general reputation among the, say, postdocs (generally intelligent and creative but cynical and past the naivete of the grad student) in synthetic b
by dnautics 9y ago
I think the general reputation among the, say, postdocs (generally intelligent and creative but cynical and past the naivete of the grad student) in synthetic biology whenever Professor Church makes an announcement, is that yes, that was something we had mused about but we know already culled it as a bad idea or an idea not worth pursuing at the moment ("I can't believe he actually had the audacity to propose doing that"), and a generally feeling of pity for the grad students and postdocs who are obligated to work on it. Of course that limits the pity to the seen; think of all the poor souls tirelessly working on the project that either totally failed or were a just a cog in the machine on a giant effort that would probably have taken less time and less effort if only the community had waited for the tools to become marginally more sophisticated.
Of course when you are as politically connected and as well known as Professor Church, you can afford to burn people on these impractical efforts, which of course cements your reputation as being successful at doing the marginally possible (or unuseful but with a wowworthy headline), which attracts grad students and postdocs who either blindly or cynically chase working for someone who will improve their reputation, and also makes it possible to further secure funding for crazy projects that anyone else would be laughed at for pursuing (if they were unsensible enough to do in the first place).
- skosuri 9y agoI worked in George's lab as a postdoc and have helped start a couple of companies with him. This is a ridiculous and slanderous characterization of the Church lab. I'd recommend talking with folks in the lab before spreading stories like this.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jaggederest 9y agoTo drop back to epistemology, how do you think people learn new things without trying things that are expected to fail?
- dnautics 9y agoIt's perfectly fine to try things that are expected to fail, that is not the argument in the comment. To give a hyperbolic example of what I'm talking about: Let's say you propose to build a giant hadron collider that rings the moon. This is, in the grand scheme of things, a reasonable proposal, within the realm of possibility, and probably something we should get around to doing. Would it be reasonable to pitch starting the construction project today? Or should we maybe wait a little bit? Should a person that jumps the gun maybe by about 20 years, and completes it, say at mabye 100x the expected cost be called a visionary?
- tlb 9y agoYes. Someone who waits until things are easy before trying them is not pushing the world forward.
- dnautics 9y agoA false dichotomy. Nobody is saying "wait till things are easy". Moreover there is always plenty of low hanging fruit that goes unseen for some reason or another, and I have seen and celebrate the many people go after those things and be wildly successful and world-changing.
- neuromantik8086 9y agoYou're acting like progress in science is inevitable just by sheer effort alone. If impractical efforts are self-funded I have no problem with them, but when they are sponsored by the taxpayer coffers I balk a little bit. Henry Markram's Human Brain Project is one effort where the technology clearly isn't there and EU money could be better spent on experiments using less sexy/flashy, but better established methods. This is not progress- this is regression.
- dnautics 9y agoYes! A great contrapositive example is Peter Mitchell who believed so hard in the chemiosmotic effect and couldn't find public funding because nobody else could bring themselves to believe it. He had to find independent funding to start a lab and proved it using decidedly non-sexy/flashy methods. Eventually won a very well-deserved nobel prize.
- comstock 9y agoRight... I don't know if he's even the worst though (personally I think Craig Ventor is way worse the Chruch). I don't think he's all that bad overall. I think he helps direct effort to interesting problems. Much academic work is something of a moonshot these days, and your job is to also carve out some useful incremental advances. People who put too much stock in what he says are likely to be more to blame. For example, if you see him on the board of a company or as a scientific advisor I wouldn't think much of it. That's because he's on the board of practically everything. But personally, and from people I've spoken to, I've found him to be friendly and helpful and basically a good guy. That's about as much as you can ask.
- thingification 9y agoCan you expand on "Much academic work is something of a moonshot these days, and your job is to also carve out some useful incremental advances."? My own assessment is that there is too much low-risk low-reward work in medicine (and its intersection with biology), and I want to hear/read about how I'm wrong.
- comstock 9y agoYou need to make grand claims, state grand objectives to get funding. The easiest route to publication is then incremental advances. Ideally with a story around them that makes them sound like part of a grand plan.