3 ms·
There is a way of looking at this phenomenon in terms of an optimal path problem, Fermat's Principal of Least Time. Suppose you have the following situation
by archgoon 9y ago
There is a way of looking at this phenomenon in terms of an optimal path problem, Fermat's Principal of Least Time.
Suppose you have the following situation
x1 | n2
|
|
n1 | x2
We have two different materials, with index of refraction n1 and n2. Now suppose that light has traveled between points x1 and x2, we can ask the question, what path did it take? (Note here, we are asking about classical rays of light, so we're thinking in terms of geometrical optics, not quantum :) )
When light travels through the left hand side, it's traveling at a velocity, c/n1, but in the right, it will travel at c/n2.
It turns out that we can answer the question of which path the light takes by asking "Which path takes the shortest amount of time?". From that assumption you can actually re-derive Snell's Law.
An example when n2 is very large (and thus moves slower on the right hand side):
x1 | n2
\ |
\|
n1 |--x2
the light will travel more distance on the left hand side because it can move faster there, and thus get close as possible to the destination. It will then make the last bit of distance in the right hand side.
Now Snell's law says
n1 sin θ_input = n2 sin θ_output
Since n2 is very large, the only way to make this work is to make sin θ_output very small. So we see in this case at least, both approaches agree as to what will happen.
So it turns out this principal works even in the case of gravitational spacetime distortion, and can be applied there as well.
- bcherny 9y agoHeh, I just saw this in Chiang's Stories of Your Life and Others.
- terryf 9y agowow! Very cool explanation! I wonder what happens at the point that it changes direction - is the change instant or is there a curve? I suppose that because photons/waves don't have mass it can be instant, but that still sounds weird.
- ge96 9y agoThis somewhat reminds me of the swimmer swimming across the river vs. up/down (disproving ether interferometer). I was a physics student (did not end well ha no focus). 4-5 years ago I was in school. Lucite and calculating the speed of light, some cool labs. The bending of an electron beam into a circle due to an orthogonal magnetic field was a good one. Thanks for explaining. Funny making images with ASCII (is that right?) I might be misconnecting dots. Damn... I can't read/pay attention right now at this time (just woke up trying to read this). I appreciate your time writing this out though/accompanied with diagrams.