8 ms·
That's exactly why I take homeopathy medicine. I know that the science behind it is pseudo; but I also know that placebo effect works regardless. At least, on m
by golergka 9y ago
That's exactly why I take homeopathy medicine. I know that the science behind it is pseudo; but I also know that placebo effect works regardless. At least, on my particular sample size of one it definitely does.
- michaelmrose 9y agoThis is truly terrible advice and you ought to feel bad for promoting it here. http://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html http://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html
- vhhhggv 9y ago> you ought to feel bad for promoting it here. But see, he doesn't, he's taking homeopathic medicines for that.
- lisper 9y agoBut he's not offering advice. He's offering a data point. There's nothing wrong with that.
- michaelmrose 9y agohttp://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html http://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- qb45 9y agoI could swear I have already seen this link somewhere /s Plus this article is a fraud. The people it lists were killed by ignorance, neglect or their own informed choice, not by homeopathy. I don't think anybody has yet died of drinking a small amount of water and the guy you are harassing said nothing about giving up other treatments, just using homeopathy as placebo.
- michaelmrose 9y agoAs controls are not as tight as you know real medicine several have in fact died of homeopathic meds that contained far too much of the active ingredients
- lisper 9y agoBut then those homeopathic meds were defective. Being harmed by a defective product is hardly unique to homeopathy.
- michaelmrose 9y agoWhy are you defending a sham industry designed to separate fools from their money that discourages people from seeking real medical attention.
- lisper 9y agoI'm not defending the industry. I think the industry is shameful. But the industry is distinct from the practice, and I think the practice can be beneficial to some people because placebos can be beneficial.
- michaelmrose 9y agoNot even being aware of how to determine what constitutes valid medical advice is detrmimental to people's long term health.
- qb45 9y agoDude, it's HN, barely anyone here seriously supports homeopathy. The problem is that you are trying too hard to convince everyone. For me, if I knew nothing about the topic, this in itself would be a huge red flag to distrust you. Slow down and make sure to attack the right people for the right reasons. It's not true that all of this shit is low quality, I presume mainstream stuff advertised on TV like Oscillococcinum might be safe. It's not obvious that all of that is cynically designed to separate fools from their money, some of the vendors may be cranky enough to believe it or at the very least they may see it helping in some cases due to the placebo effect and conclude it must be good then. And every time you say something others know for sure to be false, you are undermining you own credibility.
- xherberta 9y agoI am skeptical of the headlines touting medical mistakes as the No. 3 cause of death in the US. But to be fair, someone could put up a similar site listing thousands of people who have been harmed under conventional medical care. Your site doesn't provide enough info to compare the rate of harm. For mild ailments, which is what I assumed OP was speaking of, homeopathic treatments might have a lower rate of harm. Iatrogenesis is a possibility with any health care. And, to give your link credit, homeopathy certainly sounds like a dangerous route for serious conditions.
- mamon 9y agoEven if all you care about is placebo effect homeopathy is still a bad choice: Skittles are cheaper than most of the homeopathic drugs and they taste better.
- lisper 9y agoIt's possible that the fact that you have to pay more for it is actually what produces the beneficial effect.
- golergka 9y agoPrice is a part of the ritual.
- qb45 9y agoWait, are you serious about this working for you while you are aware of price being a part of the deal or are you fucking trolling us? I was under impression that people to whom price matters as such usually are in denial of it.
- golergka 9y ago100% serious. I know that it's as good as an expensive placebo chemically, but I also know that this knowledge doesn't stop placebo effect from working. And the fact that I'm paying for it and going through all the motions does help.
- dragonwriter 9y agoPlacebo effect is stronger when you break the skin, so you'd be better off, given your purpose, sticking yourself with (sterile!) needles than using homeopathic meds. (To the extent that paying for it is relevant to the placebo effect, which I've seen speculated on but not studied, you could find an acupuncturist.) Also, real products claiming to be homeopathic medicines are very often provably not the homeopathic dilutions that they claim to be, which increases the risk factor of that approach.