3 ms·
Thanks for this comment, and especially the example, which appears to get to the crux of the matter (though I am not in a position to be sure.) In that example
by mannykannot 9y ago
Thanks for this comment, and especially the example, which appears to get to the crux of the matter (though I am not in a position to be sure.)
In that example, does not the different result come, in an unsurprising way, from the fact that a uniform distribution over the 8 microstates is not the same as a uniform distribution over the two macrostates?
In a separate note[1], Hoel seems to be claiming that the issue is the definition of 'black-boxing', and if I am following the small example there, his definition allegedly allows him to use a uniform distribution over four states, or a uniform distribution over three states, depending on whether the S1 microstate is declared as being 'black-boxed'. Furthermore, this seems to differ from your example in that here, S1 does not become a macrostate, it is completely ignored once it is declared to be black-boxed. I do not see how Hoel is comparing apples to apples.
[1] http://www.erikphoel.com/uploads/1/7/8/8/17883727/black-boxing-mistake.pdf http://www.erikphoel.com/uploads/1/7/8/8/17883727/black-boxi...