2 ms·
"He's not supposed to be ruling on policy, just on legality." Not exactly. As a court of first instance (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_courts http://en.w
by hga 16y ago
"He's not supposed to be ruling on policy, just on legality."
Not exactly. As a court of first instance (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_courts http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_courts) "[...] evidence and testimony are admitted under the rules of evidence established by applicable procedural law and determinations called findings of fact are made based on the evidence. The court, presided over by one or more judges, makes findings of law based upon the applicable law."
Also note that the domain of the ruling is not the engineering per se but how the executive came to its moratorium decision.
In the case of a preliminary injunction he's supposed to assume that all the questions of facts go in the favor of the defendant (the government) and to then decide if as a matter of law the plaintiff would likely win anyway. Hence the closing paragraph I included above.