4 ms·

what is this right-swipe business? You swipe and it, what, just takes you to a page that the makers of the current page think you should read next in your infin

what is this right-swipe business? You swipe and it, what, just takes you to a page that the makers of the current page think you should read next in your infinite time-sink staring at your phone‽

tyingq 9y ago
Well, in this case the makers of the previous page (Google) are deciding what right swipe on the current page (Washington Post) does. It certainly makes it clear that the content owner of an AMP page is not the page owner.
- quadrangle 9y ago
  I get that, but what is right-swipe supposed to or expected to do? Why would people be right-swiping ever?
  - tyingq 9y ago
    Many reasons. A popular one would be to flip through a gallery of photos related to the story. That one's VERY common. Also, I missed mentioning the [X] button on the AMP header banner. I bet that most end users think that [X] button should make the AMP banner disappear, while leaving the page content there. Pretty common pattern, like for the EU cookie warning. That's not what it does, though. Back to the "right swipe", at the very least, it should do nothing, assuming that an AMP page belongs to the publisher.
    - quadrangle 9y ago
      Ok, sure. Going through a slide-show makes total sense. So, you're saying that there's no normal behavior on a plain website for swiping right (yes? I don't use mobile much myself), but AMP adds a Google-centric swipe-right function regardless of whether there would otherwise be no swipe-right function or some other expected one. Am I understanding now?
      - tyingq 9y ago
        Yes, that's it. Google hijacks the back button, swipes, and the [X] button on the AMP banner...in favor of Google, and to the detriment of the publisher.
        quadrangle 9y ago
        That is indeed horrible. I am glad to learn that there isn't otherwise some new trend of people constantly right-swiping for no apparent reason though.
    - type0 9y ago
      > I bet that most end users think that [X] button should make the AMP banner disappear, while leaving the page content there. Pretty common pattern, Dark petterns, MS, google, facebook etc. It's becoming the norm for the behemoth corporations to do this.

what is this right-swipe business? You swipe and it, what, just takes you to a page that the makers of the current page think you should read next in your infinite time-sink staring at your phone‽

tyingq 9y ago

Well, in this case the makers of the previous page (Google) are deciding what right swipe on the current page (Washington Post) does. It certainly makes it clear that the content owner of an AMP page is not the page owner.

quadrangle 9y ago
I get that, but what is right-swipe supposed to or expected to do? Why would people be right-swiping ever?
- tyingq 9y ago
  Many reasons. A popular one would be to flip through a gallery of photos related to the story. That one's VERY common. Also, I missed mentioning the [X] button on the AMP header banner. I bet that most end users think that [X] button should make the AMP banner disappear, while leaving the page content there. Pretty common pattern, like for the EU cookie warning. That's not what it does, though. Back to the "right swipe", at the very least, it should do nothing, assuming that an AMP page belongs to the publisher.
  - quadrangle 9y ago
    Ok, sure. Going through a slide-show makes total sense. So, you're saying that there's no normal behavior on a plain website for swiping right (yes? I don't use mobile much myself), but AMP adds a Google-centric swipe-right function regardless of whether there would otherwise be no swipe-right function or some other expected one. Am I understanding now?
    - tyingq 9y ago
      Yes, that's it. Google hijacks the back button, swipes, and the [X] button on the AMP banner...in favor of Google, and to the detriment of the publisher.
      - quadrangle 9y ago
        That is indeed horrible. I am glad to learn that there isn't otherwise some new trend of people constantly right-swiping for no apparent reason though.
  - type0 9y ago
    > I bet that most end users think that [X] button should make the AMP banner disappear, while leaving the page content there. Pretty common pattern, Dark petterns, MS, google, facebook etc. It's becoming the norm for the behemoth corporations to do this.