7 ms·
How is STEM gender-biased? Are you arguing for innate gender differences in abstract thought? Or is it just that boys tend to intimidate and shut down girls?
by mirimir 9y ago
How is STEM gender-biased?
Are you arguing for innate gender differences in abstract thought?
Or is it just that boys tend to intimidate and shut down girls?
Would gender segregation be better? My wife thinks so.
- anothercomment 9y agoThere is data on gender segregated education. So that question should be easy to decide.
- mirimir 9y agoIt seems controversial. It's an efficient way to teach girls and boys differently. But it also facilitates gender bias.
- anothercomment 9y agoI don't know what the data says, but I think this should be answered with data. If results are better with segregated education, go for it. However, I think it has mostly been abandoned because results weren't actually better. I think I have read about issues with girls only classes, but I don't have the time to google for it now. Especially with respect to STEM it seems easy to check how many girls from segregated schools go into STEM vs girls from coed schools.
- crawfordcomeaux 9y agoSTEM is gender-biased because we live in a world where societies are gender-biased. Systems theory says the bias will be visible in lower levels, so it's safe to assume it's in teaching. That's how you can logic it out. If you want data, go find it. Failure to do so is work ignorance and that's OK because changing beliefs is scary and hard. I'm arguing for humans to learn how to observe themselves and be open to seeing the impact they have on others. And for passing special attention where bias is present in order to properly apply whatever the appropriate anti-bias is. You seem to really like problems with singular problems and solutions. Maybe looking into systems theory will help you recognize complex systems work a bit differently? Personally, I think the ultimate solution is for humans to learn they can largely abandon judgment. I have some ideas on how to pull it off, so I'm gonna go back to writing about them.
- mirimir 9y agoThat's a rather judgmental response, for someone who talks about learning to "largely abandon judgment". > STEM is gender-biased because we live in a world where societies are gender-biased. Really? STEM in practice is of course gender-biased. Because, as you say, "societies are gender-biased". But what about the subjects themselves? It seems unlikely that science, technology, engineering and mathematics are inherently incomprehensible to women.
- crawfordcomeaux 9y agoWhat did you hear as judgment? I don't think the subjects themselves are gender-biased, no. I'm referring to STEM in practice.
- mirimir 9y agoOK, thanks. It was the comment about not getting complex systems that offended me.
- crawfordcomeaux 9y agoI only skimmed my comment, instead of closely examining it & just breezed over that whole line! I'm going to make more of an effort of examining myself now. That was definitely condescending of me. Sorry about that. It's not how I want to roll.
- mirimir 9y agoHey, thanks :)
- mpweiher 9y ago> STEM in practice is of course gender-biased Really? Do you really mean biased[1], or do you mean there are gender differences in STEM fields, particularly as to the representation of genders in those fields (as there are in other fields)? Or are these two the same for you? [1] http://www.dictionary.com/browse/bias http://www.dictionary.com/browse/bias