4 ms·
So they will ban all virtual machines which sometimes have to go for emulation, e.g. to handle XSAVE? Scorched earth policy will likely not be defensible under
by AstralStorm 9y ago
So they will ban all virtual machines which sometimes have to go for emulation, e.g. to handle XSAVE?
Scorched earth policy will likely not be defensible under fair use law. Reverse engineering for compatibility has a few precedents.
- yuhong 9y agoWe are talking about patents.
- pgeorgi 9y agoPatents may be selectively enforced, there's no forfeiture as there is with trademarks. Intel had (and has) no issue with qemu or bochs emulating everything, as long as they were niche and/or promoting the Intel platform (and grudgingly accepting compatibles). However a move to rid Microsoft's platform from Intel altogether without compromising compatibility is something worth fighting for. I heard that ARM is rather similar in that aspect: emulators for development are a-ok, but trying to run ARM emulation on a consumer product with no ARM components inside will drive up the legal fees until some licensing agreement is set up.
- my123 9y agoIntel uses that for their x86 Android devices - and as far as I know, ARM did not sue.
- throwaway91111 9y agoIntel also makes arm processors (a cortex a5 i think?); perhaps they do license it.
- AstralStorm 9y agoLicenses can be revoked, patents cannot other than by analysis and finding them invalid.
- pgeorgi 9y agoAs soon as Intel licenses the ARM ISA for each device, ARM Ltd. probably doesn't care if it's implemented in silicon, software or expressive dance.