7 ms·
Disclaimer: I work at Google > The world is a better place with lots of smaller companies. [citation needed] A lot of things Google does -- a lot of the thin
by TulliusCicero 9y ago
Disclaimer: I work at Google
> The world is a better place with lots of smaller companies.
[citation needed]
A lot of things Google does -- a lot of the things people actually like about Google -- are possible only because it's a huge monolith. Divorce the ad-making money machine, and say goodbye to all the services consumers like that are nowhere near as profitable: gmail, maps, photos, chrome, android, translate, youtube, drive, waze, where do you think the money for this stuff all comes from?
Of course, if you're one of the uber technerds that thinks that Google is unabashedly evil and Linux is going to take over the desktop any day now, that probably sounds great to you. I just think the average consumer would have a different take on it.
- weirdstuff 9y ago> Divorce the ad-making money machine, and say goodbye to all the services consumers like that are nowhere near as profitable: gmail, maps, photos, chrome, android, translate, youtube, drive, waze, where do you think the money for this stuff all comes from? This needs a citation, as well. This is assuming Google hasn't starved out potential competitors who would have provided the same service, or better service, had the playing field been more level. My unsubstantiated opinion is that many talented folks are/have been dissuaded from trying their hand at anything that may go up against Google, et. al., unless their looking for an aquihire. (And we know how Google treats those after a few years.) And there's another argument to be made: that Google's habit of purchasing competition stifles the innovation since it's nipping it in the bud. (I majored in Econ in uni.)
- friedman23 9y agoCongrats on your degree in econ. You would think that someone with a degree in econ would believe it wise to first establish what the negative externalities are and what externalities regulating away the existence of large business would produce before defending the idea of doing so. We already know that with the existence of Google we get free products like search, mail, video, etc. Do you have evidence that when we destroy google that we will still retain all of these benefits?
- 0x737368 9y agoEven if we assume that allowing Google to exist as a monopoly does bring better services, that's a small price to pay for not having to be subjugated by a conglomerate. Countries can already barely withstand pressure from big companies, by allowing them grow even further everything would just turn in a way that would allow such companies to make even more money, whilst increasing the gap between the rich and the poor. And with regards to better services, I think the open source community has shown us that it's possible to make great services without having to work for a company. In many cases even better services because the prime objective is to make a program that would help the user, not make money for the company.
- friedman23 9y ago> Even if we assume that allowing Google to exist as a monopoly does bring better services How is google even a monopoly? Bing exists, yahoo still exists. In Asia Google isn't even the most popular search engine. Want me to show you how google is not a monopoly? A company with monopoly power would be able to raise the price of its service to the price the market can bear. If google put search behind a pay wall, Bing would destroy it in market share. > that's a small price to pay for not having to be subjugated by a conglomerate. So now you are not using economic arguments but appealing to emotion. I just need to point this out First you felt the need to off hand mention your (clearly undergraduate) degree in economics which had absolutely zero relevance to the discussion. Secondly, you are using appeals to emotion without any basis in fact. "Google is an extremely successful company and we use them in so many things! They must be evil!" Try using evidence. I'm not going to argue against your fear mongering only point out that like almost all fear mongering, it is not based on fact. > Countries can already barely withstand pressure from big companies There is absolutely zero evidence of this. None of your arguments are based on evidence. The US just fined Volkswagen billions of dollars. The EU is ready to fine Google billions of dollars. Apple paid japan hundreds millions of dollars in fines. All the banks responsible for the financial crisis in America and the EU paid hundreds of billions > In many cases even better services because the prime objective is to make a program that would help the user, not make money for the company. Again you have no evidence of this. If smaller businesses were able to provide better services people would be using dedicated email providers, not gmail. They would be using flickr instead of google and apple photos.
- tajen 9y agoSkyrocketing acquisitions by big companies also justify half VC economy (the other half being AirBnb-style dominance over a sector). It would be interesting to know, if the exit events were smaller, whether the seed/VC capital eould redirect to more conservative positions like old industries or emerging markets.
- anth1988 9y agoOr you could see a bunch more smaller companies that still make acquisitions, and a whole lot of smaller IPOs that return a decent profit.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"This is assuming Google hasn't starved out potential competitors who would have provided the same service, or better service, had the playing field been more level." There are alternatives to many of these already. Firefox (and other browsers) for Chrome, Openstreetmap for maps. Vimeo for youtube. Flickr for photos. Dropbox for drive. Never heard of waze, so don't know what's an alternative for that, but I would be surprised if there wasn't one. I'm also of a rare breed who thinks Android is total an utter garbage compared to Palm OS, and much prefer the latter. I wish Google and Apple had never gotten in to the phone business. It's been an utter nightmare of spyware and bloatware ever since. I personally would not miss any of these products execept for youtube, and that only because of the content which is provided by users, not by Google. That content could be moved to another platform, and I'm sure if Google disappeared entirely and permanently tomorrow, just as good or better a storehouse of video content would be rebuilt to replace it.
- zanny 9y agoWaze is basically Google maps with a Skinner Box on top to make you contribute data to it for points and gold stars. Since Google bought them, they canibalized the crowdsourced data for Maps anyway, and have never updated the Waze UI so it looks like a Fisher Price toy today. There is really no reason to use it over Google Maps.
- johnchristopher 9y agoI don't know about Google maps in the US but in Europe it doesn't warn of dangers on the road (cars on the side of the road, blocked roads, etc.). Waze do.
- enraged_camel 9y agoIt warns about police checkpoints as well.
- seanp2k2 9y agoIt also has better community mapping as of a few years ago. Everyone in Costa Rica uses it because some of the roads just aren't on GMaps. Also works better with e.g. Road closures due to trees falling in the jungle (and because everyone uses it).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mothers 9y agoSuppose there was an organization, "Creation", that did mass surveillance on everyone on the planet. They don't disclose what they do with this data. Let's say as a result of Creation's sharing of this data with local governments, crime is nonexistent. Based on only what we've said is that a good or bad deal? Also, all of your examples were either purchased or have alternatives, so, yeah.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoI wouldn't evaluate it on those terms. Whether the ends justify the means depends on the specifics of the means. Not all bad means are equally bad. E.g. Taxes are a necessary evil that we accept, but we don't, as a general rule, let agents of the government just take whatever they want (hence the recent controversy over civil forfeiture).
- openfuture 9y agoHow do you know that Creation has the right definition of "crime" or that such a definition even exists.
- Navarr 9y agoTo be fair that's all based on morality which is subject to vastly differing viewpoints depending on circumstance, time period, etc. I think most of the people here would say that's a bad deal - but I don't think there's any way to say definitively that such is the case. It's possible a more open society with less secrets is a better society - but I don't know that, and I don't know that the opposite is true.
- xg15 9y agoYes and suppose I have a magic spell, the incantation of which just requires sacrificing a few children, then it will get rid of all the evil in the world. Good or bad? Your scenario is way too terse to yield some actual insights and honestly seems aimed for a particular outcome. Questions that remail open, e.g.: What kind of crime? How can the governments get rid of crime using data alone? What side-effects does the data-sharing have? Are those side-effects less or more severe than the crime used to be? Can you know all potential side-effects for the future? there other approaches to solve the crime problem?
- 43224gg252 9y ago>gmail, maps, photos, chrome, android, translate, youtube, drive, waze I think there are alternatives for all of those, many open source.
- friedman23 9y ago> many open source please. Name the open source alternatives that don't require my grandma to set up her own VPS.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoActually, many open source app platforms like Sandstorm and Cloudron offer managed hosting as well!
- dandelion_lover 9y agoEmail provider: https://posteo.de; https://posteo.de; online maps: https://openstreetmap.org https://openstreetmap.org. More on https://prism-break.org https://prism-break.org (no affilation with those).
- h1d 9y agoIt's not even funny to compare the quality of Google maps to anything else.
- dandelion_lover 9y agoI disagree. I am using openstreetmap for everything and did not have any problems whatsoever. Of course, it depends on the location. In Europe the coverage is almost perfect.
- h1d 9y agoCoverage is one but it's missing street view, fly-by view, satellite view, navigator and floor by floor building map. In my Japanese urban region, the building where I live which has been there for 8 years is a flat land in openstreetmap including other neighboring buildings. Apple's map is better but it's still far behind Google's.
- johnchristopher 9y ago> Divorce the ad-making money machine, and say goodbye to all the services consumers like that are nowhere near as profitable: gmail, maps, photos, chrome, android, translate, youtube, drive, waze, where do you think the money for this stuff all comes from? Hey. I'd be happy to pay for a gmail, photos, maps if that removes the creepy ad-business.
- mark_l_watson 9y ago+1 I agree! Usually (when not traveling) I try to avoid Google's free services like search, the excellent Google Assistant, Maps, etc. That said, I use Google constantly for stuff I pay for: Google Cloud Platform, buying movies and TV shows on Google Play, pay for a YouTube Red + Play Music family plan, and use their One a Day charity site. I would be delighted to pay $10/month for the current 'free' Google services if they strongly protected privacy.
- quadrangle 9y agoBut I don't want anyone doing this just for themselves. We need the creepy ad-business removed for everyone because it affects society overall. Google wants to have it both ways: pay them and they won't advertise at you (maybe eventually agree not to track you as much even), or for that matter, you can use an adblocker etc. as long as you keep using Google so they retain their dominance and can then track and advertise at others.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- l5870uoo9y 9y agoIf you look at China, they have because of their protectionist policies practically thriving clones of many big US tech company. It seems likely that the same would happened in other regions if some of Google services were blocked.
- jedmeyers 9y agoYeah, USSR also had clones of European and US cars produced. Ask anyone who lived there whether they would prefer Lada to a Mercedes.
- l5870uoo9y 9y agoHow about comparing Baidu and Google, Twitter and Sina Weibo or Didi Chuxing and Uber? Don't think the Chinese are underserved in this area. Besides some geopolitical considerations, why not have make it "locally" or nationally? I am not arguing for protectionism per-se, but more out of a shared concern that wealth (including opportunity, work and power) in the broadest sense should distributed. A few companies dominating prohibit this – Apple has over $260 billions in the bank. Or Amazon having more than half of all online sales.
- narrowrail 9y agoWal-Mart's Q1 revenue was $117.5B vs. Amazon's $35.7B ought to put that into perspective.
- gus2 9y agoPlease Google what the top selling cars in India and China are. They are not American or US companies. Once you do that go look into how that happened.
- omegaham 9y agoEven in the uber technerd sphere, a huge amount of the services that we take for granted are done by large companies. For example, Steam is the entire reason why gaming is becoming viable on Linux. Sure, a lot of work (by large companies) has gone into the backend to make it easier to write games for more libraries, but that work wouldn't have happened if there wasn't an enormous distribution platform that sells games for Linux.
- 0x737368 9y agoYou're right. And I agree with you on the point that some features that even someone who doesn't like corporations uses and loves were made possible by said corporations. What I'm worried about is corporations becoming so powerful that they can just change the whole economic landscape in their favour. For example, I'm a HUGE fan of Steam, but if Valve grew large enough that you can only buy games from Valve, the only programming jobs available were at Valve for 20k$ pa whilst "Lord Gaben" was close to becoming a trillionaire along with his shareholders I'd definitely stop using their platform, even if that meant I can't play games as conveniently or not have access to them at all. Bottom line, companies can do good, but governments need to keep them in check if they become too powerful.
- jlarocco 9y ago> A lot of things Google does -- a lot of the things people actually like about Google -- are possible only because it's a huge monolith. Divorce the ad-making money machine, and say goodbye to all the services consumers like that are nowhere near as profitable: gmail, maps, photos, chrome, android, translate, youtube, drive, waze, where do you think the money for this stuff all comes from? That's not true. Google is using their ad money to subsidize those services and kill off competition. If Google weren't offering ad-supported, "good enough" services then even more people would pay for the alternatives. Even with Google's anti-competitive behavior, people still pay for Dropbox, Fastmail, SmugMug, etc. You're also assuming people understand and accept the level of privacy invasion that goes on when they use Google services. If people knew just how much information Google collects about them, and how they use it, I don't think they would be okay with it. Of course only Google can disclose that information, and you won't. > Of course, if you're one of the uber technerds that thinks that Google is unabashedly evil and Linux is going to take over the desktop any day now, that probably sounds great to you. I just think the average consumer would have a different take on it. That's great. Keep "average consumers" totally in the dark about the creepy ways your company is tracking their every move online, and then portray people who don't drink the koolaid as wacky conspiracy theorists and "uber technerds".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anth1988 9y agoI won't really miss any of those things when they are gone, because others will come and take their place. > if you're one of the uber technerds that thinks that Google is unabashedly evil as opposed to the people who worship at their altar?
- quadrangle 9y agoThe real issue is power. The point of splitting up companies is to reduce their concentrated power. We could alternatively reduce their power through regulations of other sorts. Surely we all want the positive things that come from the cases where concentrated power is used for good things, and we don't want the power used for not-so-good or worse things. Ideally, we figure out how to maximize the good part and minimize the bad, but sometimes we have to decide to take it all or leave it all…
- threepipeproblm 9y ago>> > The world is a better place with lots of smaller companies. >> [citation needed] https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/bigger-corporations-are-making-you-poorer https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/bigger-corporations-are-m...
- h1d 9y agoHow are gmail, maps and chrome not profitable? It's a gold mine for data mining. As long as personally identifiable data is out of public's reach, Google is free to trace part of people's life and sell anonymized data to ad targeting or whatever company let alone the gov that's interested. If you're not paying, you're selling yourself.
- strin 9y agoSure, Google can monetize from these products. But they don't seem to choose to capture those values yet, as long as "Don't be evil" credendum still holds.
- rayiner 9y agoEmail, maps, photo viewers, browsers, online storage, streaming video, and taxis all existed before they were ad supported.
- bobbington 9y agoI agree 100%. Google has done so much good for the world by creating not only the best search engine, but also the best browser, the best maps, the best free email, an amazing mobile operating system, and all of it for free. Sure they sell ads and that annoys people, but for a free product, how can you complain? These big guys do amazing things. Yes with an organization that size, there is going to be some problems at some point, but without a doubt, we are much better off for what the guys at google have done. Unfortunately on HN, people can become so cynical. Any time somebody succeeds, it seems like there are a chorus of people writing off the success as bad in some way or inauthentic. It's almost like people are jealous. Instead of trying to tear down those who succeed, and who are giving back (like google to the open source world), let's be grateful for the insane amount of good they have done.
- slice_of_life 9y ago> A lot of things Google does -- a lot of the things people actually like about Google -- are possible only because it's a huge monolith. Divorce the ad-making money machine, and say goodbye to all the services consumers like that are nowhere near as profitable: gmail, maps, photos, chrome, android, translate, youtube, drive, waze, where do you think the money for this stuff all comes from? Yes indeed. So eloquently said. You can't have one without the other. With scale comes unprecedented ability that cannot be attained any other way. I'm a huge supporter of google and what you've accomplished in such a short time. Do not feel discouraged with some of the negative feedback. Kudos to you and keep up the good work. What you're doing is truly impactful. I as well as a billion other users enjoy your products immensely.