3 ms·
> The question is if you could capture the energy and you had the material resources would you let it escape into the universe at 290K? If the cost of acquirin
by falcolas 9y ago
> The question is if you could capture the energy and you had the material resources would you let it escape into the universe at 290K?
If the cost of acquiring and constructing the material into a collector were greater than the benefits of collecting a mere 4% more energy, absolutely!
Plus, for an advanced civilization, if given the choice between 99% efficiency around one star and 95% efficiency around a mere 100 stars - which is more likely to be done?
To make the analogy more relevant to humans: Why - when we're technologically advanced enough and have sufficient materials - do we let so much energy escape Earth?
- tboughen 9y agoI think it depends entirely on the incentives of the civilization in question. If the primary goal was hiding your world from the Borg/Dalek/Alien bioweapon your species discovered was ravaging the galaxy, then a 99% Carnot efficient Dyson sphere seems like the ideal defensive structure.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoNo it doesn't. Anything with sufficiently advanced technology to threaten a dyson sphere wielding species would probably detect the gravitational anomaly of the missing star and go investigate there first. Taking a tiny portion of the energy from a bunch of stars seems wildly more efficient at surviving from a threat than putting all your resources into creating a system they're sure to investigate.
- sfifs 9y agoThat is similar to the plot point of one of those Star Wars prequels if I recall right