3 ms·
So, for that additional 4% efficiency, the radius must be increased by 25x; making the total surface area somewhere around 650x bigger? An exponential increase
by falcolas 9y ago
So, for that additional 4% efficiency, the radius must be increased by 25x; making the total surface area somewhere around 650x bigger?
An exponential increase in size is not "a relatively small increase in resources and time." It goes from "something that could be built with all the mass in the solar system" to "something that requires the mass from an additional couple of hundred solar systems to construct".
I'm also curious about whether a Dyson sphere which would roughly equal Neptune's orbit would have sufficient sunlight at any given point to sustain life (at least, life as we know it).
I'm not a member of an alien civilization with the technology to create a Dyson sphere, but as a lowly human engineer, the costs don't seem worth the benefits, especially without some other form of energy to supplement the 650x increase in energy needs.
- danieltillett 9y agoYou don't need to make a single sphere (swarm more likely). If you arrange the shells in layers the outer layers can efficiently capture the long wavelength radiation using relatively little matter. The question is if you could capture the energy and you had the material resources would you let it escape into the universe at 290K?
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoOr do something else with the 625x more resources you need? I'd probably let the 4% escape and do something nice with the 625x more resources.
- danieltillett 9y agoYou don't need 625x the material resources to capture the last 4%. Think multiple shells with the outermost shell being 1 atom thick.
- falcolas 9y agoWhat atoms - when arranged in a single-atom-thickness structure - could collect, transform, and transfer radiant energy back towards the inner shells, while also remaining rigid enough to not deform under the pressure of that radiant energy (not to mention the energy emitted by other stellar phenomena)? For better or worse, we have to assume the alien civilizations have the same physics that we do, otherwise the civilization simply has to build their 1au sphere out of artificially created unobtainium to achieve 99% efficiency.
- hellcow 9y agoThe Three Body Problem (sci-fi book) had a similar puzzle in it--i.e. how can something as small as an atom have such a profound effect on our civilization? I won't spoil it, but it's well worth reading.
- danieltillett 9y agoCarbon. The outer shell does not need to be a single structure. A swam of micro satellites orbiting at 25 AU with 1 atom thick carbon antenna collectors (think black snowflake) would on average be not much more than 1 atom thick and would collect 99% of the energy emitted by the star or inner shell(s). This is all rather beyond what my post was about which is that only inefficient Dyson spheres can be detected in the infrared and that any civilisation capable of building a 95% efficient sphere is able to build one that is 99%.
- falcolas 9y ago> The question is if you could capture the energy and you had the material resources would you let it escape into the universe at 290K? If the cost of acquiring and constructing the material into a collector were greater than the benefits of collecting a mere 4% more energy, absolutely! Plus, for an advanced civilization, if given the choice between 99% efficiency around one star and 95% efficiency around a mere 100 stars - which is more likely to be done? To make the analogy more relevant to humans: Why - when we're technologically advanced enough and have sufficient materials - do we let so much energy escape Earth?
- tboughen 9y agoI think it depends entirely on the incentives of the civilization in question. If the primary goal was hiding your world from the Borg/Dalek/Alien bioweapon your species discovered was ravaging the galaxy, then a 99% Carnot efficient Dyson sphere seems like the ideal defensive structure.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoNo it doesn't. Anything with sufficiently advanced technology to threaten a dyson sphere wielding species would probably detect the gravitational anomaly of the missing star and go investigate there first. Taking a tiny portion of the energy from a bunch of stars seems wildly more efficient at surviving from a threat than putting all your resources into creating a system they're sure to investigate.
- sfifs 9y agoThat is similar to the plot point of one of those Star Wars prequels if I recall right
- skrebbel 9y ago> I'm not a member of an alien civilization Entirely off topic, but I love how IANAL style disclaimers found their way to astrophysics discussions. IANAMOAAC anyone? I like it. (Note: I really like it, this is not snarky sarcasm)
- falcolas 9y agoHeh - well, when we're discussing hypothetical super-advanced aliens with technology and capability to create Dyson spheres, it seems sufficiently outside the scope of my knowledge to justify the disclaimer. ;)
- DennisP 9y agoI'm not sure whether to be relieved or disappointed that a member of a super-advanced alien civilization is not actually posting on HN. I guess neither, since if you actually are an alien, you would probably make the same denial :)
- zepto 9y agoSpeaking as an alien, we don't have a concept of 'cost' the way humans do. We long ago overcame biological limitations on our lifespans. Since then, the two things they matter to us are not dying by accident, and not getting bored. As you can imagine these can come into conflict on occasion. But building oversized Dyson spheres is fun and not particularly dangerous m.
- WJW 9y agoAren't there long stretches of time where the nanoreplicators just do their thing and all you can do is watch and/or get another cup of space coffee? (somewhat like the computer program compiling processes on earth) Or are you guys capable of slowing your perception of time so it seems to go really fast?
- Razengan 9y agoWe have created sub-universes with different laws of physics etc. When we get bored, we inject ourselves into the viewpoints of entities in those universes, after temporarily wiping memories of our true selves so we can re-exist as lesser, mortal beings. I believe the closest equivalent human term is VR MMORPG.
- undersuit 9y agoOlder Americans would probably call it a "Quantum Leap".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zepto 9y agoThe reproductive cycle for quasi-immortal beings is necessarily quite time consuming.
- Razengan 9y ago> the costs don't seem worth the benefits, especially without some other form of energy to supplement the 650x increase in energy needs. That's assuming the larger surface area is undesired, and the extra space won't be utilized for something else, like habitation, or storage.
- rukittenme 9y ago> I'm not a member of an alien civilization with the technology to create a Dyson sphere, but as a lowly human engineer, the costs don't seem worth the benefits Unless they're hiding from something ... something terrible. Coming to a silver screen near you.
- ElectronCharge 9y agoThank you, I was going to make the same point. Another point worth considering is that if the biology of the aliens were Earthlike, it would be nice to have the "native" intensity of sunlight (or close to it) available everywhere on the inside of the sphere. Even if the biology were oriented to 4x less insolation, that would only be a 2x increase in sphere radius. I think the "efficiency" concern is a bit silly also, since advanced alien civilizations will have advanced, high-density power sources available as needed. The only rationale I can see for very high efficiencies would be the desire to hide...and that might be a valid concern.