4 ms·
We're undergoing a transformative shift in the nature of jobs. I am an optimist, we will experience a lot of uncertainty in the next few years but come out the
by rmason 9y ago
We're undergoing a transformative shift in the nature of jobs. I am an optimist, we will experience a lot of uncertainty in the next few years but come out the other side with full employment.
Listened to an engaging interview Jason Calacanis had on TWIST with Ryan Carson from Treehouse. He said that our universities are graduating 400,000 programmers a year but we need over a million. He's arguing that education needs to change.
http://thisweekinstartups.com/ryan-carson-treehouse/ http://thisweekinstartups.com/ryan-carson-treehouse/
There are plenty of people right here in America that are either unemployed or under employed that can take those jobs. But it's going to be with $8000 for a developer bootcamp or if you're able to learn online for $1200 with Treehouse.
Someone has to service the robots of the future and the driverless car software. Just like Twilio allowed even average developers to create telephony apps a future company will allow smart people to knit together expert systems with API calls to a framework with something like Google's TensorFlow on the back end.
Sorry @sama but I just don't see a need for basic income, the jobs will be there but they just haven't been invented yet.
- gaius 9y agoPeople who hire engineers say there should be a surfeit of engineers. Meanwhile have you seen the bloodbaths going on at IBM and HP? This is not a field I could recommend in good faith to any young person. Go into something that can't be offshored, without the rampant ageism...
- runT1ME 9y agoWhat profession would you advise young people go into, if you are dissuading them from one of the few careers that can pay a living wage right out of the bat with almost unlimited upside potential (second only to law/medicine).
- gaius 9y agoYep, law or medicine. Maybe biotech. Don't be mislead by Silly Valley - most working programmers sit in cubicles cranking out code for the same salary as any other office worker while their managers plot and scheme day and night how to offshore their jobs.
- runT1ME 9y agoI think you're severely overestimating how much an office worker makes or you underestimate how much a decent programmer makes. Though likely both.
- delazeur 9y agoIf you only consider salaries at major companies in SF/Seattle/NYC/Chicago, or you only look at the salaries of graduates from top programs, then sure. But the average programmer, graduated from an average school and working at an average company, probably makes a salary not too different from anyone else with a STEM degree.
- caseysoftware 9y agoUnemployment among lawyers is high and increasing. Some of that may be due to the sheer numbers of new lawyers but that's kind of the point. I have two kids under three. My mindset is not to advise them towards a particular profession but to teach them how to learn, explore, fail safely, and get back up again. When they start thinking about jobs in 12+ years, hopefully they'll have a variety of skills and understanding and a willingness to experiment to find something that fits. I'm more worried about our teenager who will be considering college in the next couple years.. I suspect this transition will be painful.
- Fezzik 9y agoHaving had a mother that took a very hands-off approach to guiding me towards a career, I highly recommend giving as much guidance as you can as early as possible. Describe how difficult something like medical school is, but how you can easily expect to start earning 200k once you get a job. Talk about the legal profession (where I work) having a steep learning curve for any job, with schooling that is entirely inapplicable to practice, but you can start earning 60k-110k right off the bat and do some pretty cool stuff. If you wait too long, a kid can get listless or behind (I did) and it is then harder to figure things out. If kids are not taught the concrete realities of adult finances and vocations when young, it tends to never really stick. Obviously none of that is relevant to a 3 y/o, but I so wish my mother would have repeatedly explained some of these things when I was younger. Even teenagers understand the benefit of earning six-figures, and can it light a fire under their asses if they appreciate the value of that. And the freedom it provides. I don't think it is happenstance that all my (mostly Indian and Asian) friends whose parents pushed them to be doctors... are now great doctors, and doing financially well. While many of my (Caucasian) friends languished in their family wealth and are still listless in their mid-thirties. /end anecdotal directionless rant.
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoNo, the parent is right. Being able to evaluate choices and take reasonable decision is extremely more important that being "guided" in life. > If kids are not taught the concrete realities of adult finances and vocations when young, it tends to never really stick citation needed.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI would say law, finance, medicine or management. These professions seem to best at protecting themselves.
- alwillis 9y agoWe already have too many lawyers for the number of law school graduates. A huge chunk of routine legal work is going to be automated, similarly to how millions of people use TurboTax for their taxes. There's a reason why so many banks are investing in blockchain technology: they'll be able to eliminate many thousands of humans currently involved in clearing and settlement in financial institutions.
- randomdata 9y agoAll of them! The focus should be on career flexibility, not pigeonholing oneself into a single career that can lose viability in an instant. There is a saying: Don't put all of your eggs in one basket. It is especially pertinent when it comes to jobs. Things can change very quickly, as many people have learned over the years. When there is a concerted effort to push people towards a certain career, as we are seeing with software engineers right now, one should be especially leery about the future. But at the same time one may as well capitalize on these careers while they are viable. Flexibility allows that and readys one to move into the next big thing when the shift comes.
- Applejinx 9y agoBeware 'almost unlimited upside potential'. So has the lottery. I abandoned my small business that had made a quarter of a million dollars over the years (gross) to convert it to Patreon: decimated my income, but made it way more stable and predictable. If I wanted to advise young people in such a way that they'd be secure, I'd tell them to (a) go into trades and (b) study some of the entrepreneurial types but apply it to marketing their merits as a tradesman, not as an 'inventor' or 'programmer'. Some of Guy Kawasaki's stuff is quite good that way, generally useful. Anything with 'upside potential' is balanced by a very real risk of getting gruesomely hosed through pursuing that bait. It seems like 'being a human' is one of those 'upside potential' things, and on the whole we're set up to fail.
- gaius 9y agogo into trades Absolutely. A plumber is never going to see business dry up, if you'll forgive the pun. "Unlimited upside potential" is another thing said by people who want to hire engineers for less than they're worth...
- Applejinx 9y agoNot quite true: when we're all living in modular robot houses that aren't human-maintainable, the plumber's got no purpose anymore. But for the time being, he's got a very large installed base of stuff to maintain, and he's going to be as secure as he wants to be (if he knows enough of the entrepreneurial thing to manage a personal business and his reputation).
- bsder 9y ago> He said that our universities are graduating 400,000 programmers a year but we need over a million. He's arguing that education needs to change. The lack of salary rise disagrees with this.
- chishaku 9y ago> we will experience a lot of uncertainty in the next few years but come out the other side with full employment. You've hardly given an argument to support these hand wavy claims. Yes, _some_ people will have jobs servicing "the robots of the future and the driverless car software" but that hardly means full employment. > Sorry @sama but I just don't see a need for basic income, the jobs will be there but they just haven't been invented yet. The jobs will be there, the climate mess will be fixed and structural economic imbalances will all be corrected. The future sounds awesome. (Don't get me wrong. I'm an optimist but this kind of miracle thinking that avoids acknowledging the issues raised by GP is kind of disturbing.)
- jjoonathan 9y ago> Ryan Carson from Treehouse. He said that our universities are graduating 400,000 programmers a year but we need over a million. He sells programming education. That's a self-serving claim if ever there was one. > Sorry @sama but I just don't see a need for basic income, the jobs will be there but they just haven't been invented yet. There will come a day when faith won't be enough to sell people on this idea. I tremble to think of how bad things will have to get before then, and how many ugly, poorly thought out, desperate "solutions" we will go through before finding something workable.
- seanp2k2 9y agoThe uncertainty of the future causes me quite a bit of moral dilemma around if it's "right" to create new humans who will exist in that uncertain future. It's been thought over forever, but still: do you "save them" and never have children, or does the future need them despite how they might suffer (and continue the cycle of suffering, potentially for many generations)?
- s73ver 9y agoI disagree entirely. Yes, someone has to service the robots. But it will be significantly fewer people doing that than were doing the job that the robots took over. Bootcamps/Treehouse can be a thing, but while you do that bootcamp, you still have a mortgage to pay, a family to feed and clothe, etc. Where's that money gonna come from? Basic income is going to be required in the future. Otherwise we're going to be in an Hunger Games dystopian future.
- Applejinx 9y agoYep. Think of it this way: in order to have a functioning consumption economy in any sense, people have to have an economic vote. It becomes their 'job' to select which things thrive within the market-based system. This has its own problems, but the ideology isn't really as dependent upon each person serving a necessary role inside the 'production of goods' system as you think. It's as if power was generated only by exercise bicycles hooked to dynamos, and then solar was invented. Or if transportation was powered only by humans and animals such as horses, and then the internal combustion engine was invented. We literally don't even have as many horses living in the world as we used to: no need for 'em. And those that do live, live under generally better conditions, because their labor is worthless and they're valued for other reasons (and in smaller numbers). The future might look more like that. Steady attrition of humans, and improved conditions… but as pets and exotic animals, not as beasts of labor.
- Applejinx 9y agoAdded thought: the downside of this is obvious. In that robot future, why would we have to give a crap what HUMANS thought of goods and services? Things might evolve to suit what the robots and AIs like, in which case human input is about as useful as asking horses about highways. "This sucks, it makes my hooves hurt!" um, it's kinda not meant for you, Dobbin…
- seanp2k2 9y agoSomeone also has to design, program, update, coordinate, and negotiate things around the robots. I admit that I haven't built out a map of a person + support services vs a robot, but I don't think it's suddenly an order of magnitude less jobs, it's just that the jobs will be different. There are some societal standards which are hard to change, such as the preference of some to have a human cashier ring them up at the grocery store. I personally prefer the scanner tables, since I can do it quickly and there's typically less of a line, but at e.g. Safeway and Home Depot, half the time they're out of order. Target doesn't always have them and Whole Foods doesn't have them (in ones I've been to). Self-checkouts have been in stores for at least 15 years ( http://articles.latimes.com/2003/nov/15/business/fi-scanner15 http://articles.latimes.com/2003/nov/15/business/fi-scanner1... ), yet there aren't replacing many cashiers, and the trend I've noticed lately is away from them. My point is that it's fun to think about, but I think we're many decades away from having to worry about robots replacing a majority of minimum-wage jobs, and it might not even be worth it to automate some of these things until minimum wage is much higher. Another example I can think of is a table busser at a restaurant. It'd be hard to make a robot who could operate as smoothly in tight quarters as a human, not spilling stuff everywhere and making lots of noise. You'd basically need design a restaurant around automation, not the other way 'round. You could also just design a counter-service restaurant where people take their own dishes to a tub, which is a lot less involved than maintaining a fleet of dish bots. Diners might also scoff at (or be amazed by, or both) robots cleaning stuff around them while eating. Industrial robots I've seen aren't very pretty or clean. Do you think that the Knightscope bots clean and wax their own exteriors? At that point, do you pay someone to clean the robots or just have them clean the tables? Or clean the robot with another robot-washing robot. This might work in Star Wars, but even there, Chewie and Han did the wrenching; R2 just helped them diagnose it. Again, my point is that I doubt there will be less stuff to do in the future, just hopefully higher-value stuff. If you look at history and as other commenters have mentioned, e.g. the move from subsistence farming to increasingly more automation, workers go from picking vegetables to other hopefully more desirable jobs (maybe driving a fork lift to load the boxes of produce into trucks).