3 ms·
As much as I think the taxi system needed replaced, I'm not sure how I feel about companies breaking laws to innovate. If we go down that path are the south am
by sharemywin 9y ago
As much as I think the taxi system needed replaced, I'm not sure how I feel about companies breaking laws to innovate.
If we go down that path are the south american drug cartels just ahead of their time.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoIt really depends on the law. "You need to pay $300k for the right to get paid to drive people from point A to B" is a really terrible law.
- SilasX 9y agoThe law was more like, "You must have a medallion to operate a cab. We only issued 10k medallions (or whatever). The medallions are transferable. We're not issuing new ones." Combined with the supply of cab labor, that had the effect of, "if you want to operate a cab, you need to buy one from an owner at the current absurd market price".
- heisenbit 9y agoWhich worked as long as the prices were going up. Isn't it ironic that taxi drivers having gone in debt to buy a medallion are now financially destroyed by a company spending more than it takes in? Medallion asset bubble destroyed by Uber valuation bubble.
- shostack 9y agoIs Lyft breaking the law? They operate in Chicago, so in theory would be a viable alternative to Uber.
- brianwawok 9y agoThey did when they launched, they would do airport pickups despite a law against that.
- wayn3 9y agolaws that are obvious bullshit need to be broken
- stephenr 9y agoRequiring background checks on people driving taxis (yes, ubers are taxis. You're not ride sharing, they weren't just going that way and gave you a ride) is a bullshit law that needs to be broken? Having predictable pricing so you don't end up paying 5x more when there is a major event on (aka price gouging) is a bullshit law that needs to be broken?
- wayn3 9y agoif taxi protectionism led to better drivers, id agree. but it does not. taxi drivers are mega sketchy, to the point where id be very worried if my gf or future children had to deal with them. beyond their sketchyness, they act entitled to a point that is just not respectable. apparently, you think their pricing is regulated, which its not. whats regulated is their pay per time. to jack prices up, they take bullshit routes, which not only wastes my money but my time on top of that. if surge pricing guarantees that i will get a ride (at a higher price) then im all about that. sure, it incites peasant rage when other people have to not compete for rides becuase theyre priced out of it. big deal. uber and travis may be a shitstack, but theyre a shitstack thats vastly less shitstack-y than the taxi industry. edit: this is actually about background checks? well then, how many uber drivers have rape-murdered passenger so far? how many taxi drivers did? the price gouging bit is entirely retarded. surge pricing happens to control the demand. when i need a ride and cant get one because the comic con happens and a million teenage weebs need a ride, i like having the option of getting one guaranteed - at a higher rate.
- stephenr 9y agoSo yet again, America tries its own specific brand of something, yet again with minimal meaningful regulation, watch it turn to shit when the "market" acts on profit goals alone, and then claim it's a terrible idea that can never work. This brings us to: health care, banking, mobile phone networks, electoral systems, and now taxis. Meanwhile the civilised world has regulated taxi systems that work, where you know what you'll pay, regardless of what's going on, and you don't have a company with a penchant for being shit lords knowing every trip you make, and doing shit like charging you more because your phone battery is low. > surge pricing happens to control the demand. Are you delusional? Increased wait times would be sufficient for that, and would make sense: yes we can take you but there is a queue. Those who don't want to wait will find alternatives, and the demand reduces. > when i need a ride and cant get one because the comic con happens and a million teenage weebs need a ride, i like having the option of getting one guaranteed - at a higher rate. But it isn't just "an option" it's the only option. Edit: clarified