10 ms·
PCIe 4.0 will be twice as fast as today's slots
- astrodust 9y agoWould be interesting if the new standard was just multiple USB-C connectors for the cards. One, two, four or eight of them depending on the bandwidth requirements.
- lightedman 9y agoThe alignment issues of multiple on-board plugs would just be a headache waiting to happen. Even with SMT components typically aligning themselves during solder flow, there's always discrepancies in manufacturing and components go ever so slightly out of whack. On the GPU side, those would probably be straight because they'd be laid flat against the board, perpendicular to the motherboard. The motherboard mountings would be the problematic ones.
- wlesieutre 9y agoYou could plug all the sockets into a large retainer (mimicking the role of a GPU) during soldering to ensure they're spaced correctly. Doesn't sound as solid as a socket though, they support some weight of the card in addition to carrying data. I'd be concerned about USB sockets getting torqued off if you looked at them wrong while installing a card, or if you took out the mounting screws without having the card properly supported.
- astrodust 9y agoUSB-style sockets could require less force to insert than a typical card, so they're less likely to break, but that's also a function of design. A plastic sleeve to guide the card into place and ensure a good fit isn't that hard a concept.
- wlesieutre 9y agoForce to insert it isn't what I'm worried about, it's snapping it off with perpendicular force. Double height GPUs are heavy and most of that's supported by hanging off the socket.
- astrodust 9y agoAny heavy-weight CPU would have 4 or 8 sockets holding it up, so that shouldn't be an issue. If all that weight was hinging on one socket an accommodation to have some kind of flange wouldn't be too hard to incorporate.
- wlesieutre 9y agoTrue, you could still run the PCB footprint out to the edge and have a support socket on the motherboard to grab it. Then we could eliminate the cost of the USB components by building contacts into the support socket that connect to pads on the PCB! I dunno, ease of inserting and removal just isn't on my list of desires for a GPU. I install one maybe every 2 years, and I don't want to worry about it falling out and smashing around inside my case if I pick up my computer or something. Whatever mounting shenanigans are necessary to lock it in place with weaker connectors feels like a solution looking for a problem. The somewhat high force of PCIe slots is a feature, not a bug.
- astrodust 9y agoThe socket compoonents would have to be manufactured as one part that's soldered down into existing holes not unlike how the slot itself is a single component.
- amluto 9y agoUSB-C is a fancy and quite complicated standard that is complicated mostly because it can negotiate varying link protocols and because it can handle being connected in two or four different orientations [1]. For PCIe slots, it's always PCIe and it's always plugged in the same direction, so USB-C wouldn't buy much. [1] USB-C to USB-C cables don't have the symmetry they appear to have. Each end can be independently upside down.
- gugagore 9y agoto clarify your [1], if I take two connected devices, unplug the cable, and plug it back in, reversing each of the two plugs, then that is a different configuration from what I started with?
- amluto 9y agoYes, if I understood it correctly when I read the spec. (To be clear, this means turning both ends upside down, not switching which end is which.) IIRC, this means that certain USB-C configurations require a captive cable because they can only tolerate reversal of one end, not both.
- jandrese 9y agoSo it took 6 years to not yet release PCIe 4 and they're saying they will have PCIe 5 out in two years? Have they fixed some problem with the development process that will make it take 1/3 of the time?
- brohee 9y ago4.0 and 5.0 are developed concurrently, 4.0 being at revision 0.9 and 5.0 being at 0.3.
- d33 9y agoWhere can I track this?
- wmf 9y agohttps://pcisig.com/ https://pcisig.com/
- ReverseCold 9y agoSSL error anyone?
- Nullabillity 9y agoWorks fine for me. But holy shit, $4k a year for the privilege of downloading a few specs? This is even more ludicrous than the USB or Bluetooth messes.
- dlgeek 9y agoUSB Mess? Download from http://www.usb.org/developers/docs/ http://www.usb.org/developers/docs/ as a zip file. Are you thinking IEEE1394/Firewire which has a significant cost?
- 9y ago
- Retr0spectrum 9y ago> Imagine what a video card could do with that. Last time I checked, even very high end cards are far from being bottlenecked by a 16x 3.0 bus.
- highd 9y agoTrue for graphics, though it would be nice for HPC. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14508928 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14508928 Though it may be that expensive high-end VR could be the luxury home theater of tomorrow, and you put 4 GPUs in a box to get 90FPS 8K seamless VR. Faster PCIe could be nice to have in that case.
- striking 9y agoMulti-GPU is kind of a meme for anything besides HPC. Graphical applications currently don't support it very well, if at all. And it means you're basically duplicating the scene across multiple GPUs, which is a lot of money burnt on VRAM. New PCIe specs will likely only affect data transfer like for storage applications, at least for the time being.
- nickpsecurity 9y agoMaybe networking, too, as some companies built switches for servers out of PCIe or one of those.
- valarauca1 9y agoMulti-GPU doesn't exist for anything other than ML or HPC. While Vulkan fully supports it. Metal and DX12 don't. The real issue for real time AR/VR/144FPS+ is knowing what you can/can't offload, what's the transfer latency, etc. this will change based on cards, generations, CPU's, library versions, Driver versions, vendors. It is a nightmare. Even SLI/XFire when you know there are identical cards, and drivers. You still see ~10-20% pref gain for 50% more resources.
- eridius 9y ago
- igravious 9y agoEngadget reporting is so … underwhelming for a site with such financial backing. The associated graphic is some random “Maximum PC Magazine via Getty Images“ thing. You mean they have nobody that can take a photo of the inside of a PC? Then the source of the article is not PCI-SIG itself but a TechReport article: https://techreport.com/news/32064/pcie-4-0-specification-finally-out-with-16-gt-s-on-tap https://techreport.com/news/32064/pcie-4-0-specification-fin... which, frankly, is much more packed with info and deets. In contrast to Engadget there's a nice info-graphic showing the evolution in bandwidth over the years _plus_ there's a table with PCI specs 1 through 5. Finally the source there is PCI-SIG itself: http://pcisig.com/ http://pcisig.com/ and from there you can root through the spec revisions: http://pcisig.com/specifications/review-zone http://pcisig.com/specifications/review-zone – being as someone else pointed out here "PCI Express Base Specification Revision 4.0, Version 0.9" and "PCI Express Base Specification Revision 5.0, Version 0.3" I mean I do like Engadget, I've been going there years, but sometimes I ask myself why I do. Their tech event live-blogs are pretty damn decent I guess but I wish their articles had more meat on them like ArsTechica or AnandTech or TechReport or …
- thoughtsimple 9y agoAnd they got the reason why manufacturers are going to move to PCIe 4 wrong. It has nothing to do with bottlenecks to video cards and everything to do with freeing up lanes. Pretty awful article.
- dingo_bat 9y ago> You mean they have nobody that can take a photo of the inside of a PC? They're probably using un-openable imacs.
- kogepathic 9y ago> Engadget reporting is so … underwhelming for a site with such financial backing. Yeah seriously. I couldn't believe this line: "Backward compatibility means that manufacturers won't have to redesign old systems, either" What does that even mean? That you can take a PCI-e 4.0 device and plug it into an older slot? Isn't that universally the case with computers, otherwise the bus would be called something else... I'm unaware of any hardware vendor that puts effort into redesigning a product they're already shipping, if not to resolve a deficiency (and even then, it'd better be important to re-spin the hardware).
- likelynew 9y agoCan someone enlighten me on what is the bottleneck for the transfer speed from hardware point. Is it the material used in the wire, or the transistors or some other thing? And, also since the transfer speed is continuously increasing, what are the improvements in the hardware over, say, last 10 years.
- jfoutz 9y agoI'm not even remotely qualified to answer. But anyway, a charge moving down a wire makes a magnetic field. Sending little packets of 0 or 1 means there's a lot of little fields forming and collapsing around the wire. Motherboards are very small, so that field may be big enough to push up against the field of the next wire. That's the bottleneck. electrons in a conductor are crazy fast (i think a big fraction of c). The problem is sending enough of them that you get a meaningful signal, but not so many they interfere with their neighbors. i'd guess the speed improvements come from much more precise timing and voltages, so you can get better guarantees about interference. if voltage is +/-10%, that field will be bigger, and interfere more. If the timings are +/-10% the field will be there when you don't want it to for the next signal. Anyway, i'm sure there are much more knowledgeable people who can give you much better insight, but i think that's the physics 101 kinda answer.
- xyzzyz 9y agoElectrons in the conductor are actually kinda slow, it's on the order of millimeters or centimeters per second. It's the electromagnetic field propagation that is fast. That is, if you have a conductor cable, and apply voltage to it, the individual electrons inside it will proceed very slowly, but they all will start moving almost at the same time along the length of the wire.
- bedros 9y agono way electrons speed is at centimeters or even millimeters per second, electrons travel at or close to speed of light.
- franciscop 9y agoIt would seem to me that 2x is not such a huge jump to warrant 6 years (compared to USB 3 => 3.1) and that it is not the bottleneck anyway. But we might be approaching the speed limits on PCIe (as in transistor size).
- shaklee3 9y agoIt is the bottleneck. This is why Nvidia invented nvlink.
- mhh__ 9y agoWould this, or current technology, be fast enough to have a (professional grade) Oscilloscope as a PCIe card? It's my understanding (I don't work around top of the line so I'm probably wrong) that even the best scopes don't have particularly amazing interfacing with regular PCs because of low data bandwidth with their interfaces.
- 21 9y agoTodays top of the line osciloscopes (in the $250k+ range) are basically a Windows computer with some custom hardware - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dx596o8t_TY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dx596o8t_TY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgbAESoFDAY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgbAESoFDAY
- phkahler 9y agoHow is this possible? I assume GT per second is transfers not bits. You can't do any kind of handshake at that rate over more than a centimeter or two. Do they allow multiple requests to be issued before the first transfer is complete? The speed of light is definitely coming in to play here as an upper limit.
- 21 9y agoIn this context, a transfer is almost the same thing as a bit. For each 8 bits of useful payload PCIe sends 10 bits of encoded payload. The GT counts the total number of sent bits, which include this 20% overhead. So actual userful bitrate is 0.8 * GT.
- shaklee3 9y agoThat's true for pcie 2. Pcie 3 is 128/130b encoding, so it's much, much more efficient.
- SolarNet 9y agoIt is bits. It's full duplex, each side has dedicated receive and transmit lanes. And for example PCIe x16 is 16 lanes. Each transfer is an encoded bit. PCIe 3.0 and 4.0 require 130 bits to encode 128 bits (PCIe 2.0 required 10 for 8). So 16 GT/s would be ~1.97 GB/s (in Bytes). The primary thing this standard is doing is stepping up the communication speed using better chips (which is why it's so easily backwards compatible).
- baobrien 9y agoPCI Express works more like Ethernet than classic PCI or a parallel bus like Wishbone. There's no per-bit (or even per-byte) handshaking between devices; they communicate with packets over a longer time span.
- chx 9y agoEh... for the everyday use PCIe 3.0 x4 is aplenty. If you wanted to help the everday user then make these new PIO slots standard https://world.taobao.com/item/535467249119.htm?spm=a312a.7700714.0.0.T1USiR https://world.taobao.com/item/535467249119.htm?spm=a312a.770... and once you have the GPU parallel to the MB, make the coolers user replaceable so that you can put a tower cooler on your GPU. What lunacy is that we have 12-16 cm edge cubes containing like a kg of metal and two-three fans in a push-pull to cool ~150W CPUs but the 250W GPU cooling system struggles for air. x4 is enough in practically all cases just don't forget to feed 75W into it... Once that's done add a few more x4 slots. Even consumer CPUs have enough lanes for it, no need to waste x16 on the GPU. TB3 is x4, U.2 is x4, everything big and useful is x4 so more of that is helpful. The only thing that needs x8 is like HPC and 40Gbps+ Ethernet both of which are clearly server land.
- colejohnson66 9y ago4 3.0 lanes may be enough for a GPU, but if you're using a 3.0 capable GPU on a 2.0 system, you'll need 8 lanes. So my guess for why GPUs have 16 lane connectors is for backwards compatibility. What motherboard manufactures could do is use open ended x4 slots. But from what I've observed, people don't seem to know that you can put an x1 card into an x4 slot
- chx 9y agoNot really. 2.0 x4 is already enough. https://www.techpowerup.com/reviews/NVIDIA/GeForce_GTX_1080_PCI_Express_Scaling/25.html https://www.techpowerup.com/reviews/NVIDIA/GeForce_GTX_1080_... PCI Express 1.1 x4 is shouting distance within 3.0 x16. 2.0 x4 and 3.0 x16 has no noticeable difference. And the future is actually less bandwidth requirement: > Performance doesn't even drop with newer DirectX 12 and Vulkan games, including titles like "DOOM," which are known to utilize virtual texturing ("mega textures," an API feature analogous to Direct3D tiled-resources). If anything, mega textures has reduced the GPU's bandwidth load on the PCI-Express bus. So: 3.0 x4 will be plenty for the foreseeable future.
- mrmondo 9y agoI'm actually more interested in any latency decreases and improvements to direct CPU/memory access that may be included in the new standard.
- tiku 9y agoPCIe 5.0 will be twice as fast as tomorrow's slots...