3 ms·
Slightly OT, but explain to me again why this is legal: > "We often seek patents for technology we never implement, and patents should not be taken as an indic
by xg15 9y ago
Slightly OT, but explain to me again why this is legal:
> "We often seek patents for technology we never implement, and patents should not be taken as an indication of future plans,” said a Facebook spokesperson.
So can I just apply for a patent for that impossibly strong rope needed for space elevators and if anything should ever figure out how to build it, I can sue them?
(Though in this particular case, yes please, Facebook, by all means please get the patent and don't build it and make sure no one else can build it either)
- gregman1 9y ago«please, Facebook, by all means please get the patent and don't build it» wow
- kbart 9y ago"We often seek patents for technology we never implement, and patents should not be taken as an indication of future plans” So, basically, WhatsApp story all over again(0)? 0. "No, dear EC, we won't and can't link WhatsApp and Facebook accounts". Few years later: "Oops".
- hdjddjtjtj55 9y agoAssuming that's a real quote: Of course they "can't".... at the time they said that. They "won't" given that they "can't". They needed to engineer a mechanism to do so. From a purely literal perspective they were honest.
- sjg007 9y agoWell you might not get the patent because you'd have to describe how to build it and then it would be apparent you could not so you would not get the patent.
- xg15 9y agoBut by that logic, woudn't Facebook have to reveal, in detail, the analysis pipeline they plan (or actually don't plan) to use to detect your emotions and link them to the content shown? They didn't do that, did they? (The example is kind of absurd as that technology is pretty horrible, but reports about pre-emptive patents seem to crop up with some regularity)
- sjg007 9y agoIt has to be doable. A sentiment analysis pipeline is doable and has been done in other contexts. The patent has to describe to someone skilled in the state of the art how to build the thing you want to patent. That's the whole point. You don't have to build it or sell whatever prototype you did build or use it but it has to be possible.