3 ms·
Planck units are what you get if you set the gravitational constant, the Coulomb constant, the speed of light, Boltzmann's constant, and the reduced Planck cons
by jcranmer 9y ago
Planck units are what you get if you set the gravitational constant, the Coulomb constant, the speed of light, Boltzmann's constant, and the reduced Planck constant all to 1, resulting in the elimination of constants in equations like Newton's law of gravitation. The argument was that using such units eliminated anthropic bias.
Well, the immediate problem with such arguments is that it's not clear that those values are the right ones to set to 1. The original discussion started before Einstein developed general relativity, where 4piG crops up more than G itself. Likewise, it arguably makes more sense to set permittivity of free space, not Coulomb's constant, to 1, which eliminates the constants in Maxwell's equations. On the other hand, using the charge of ⅓ that of an electron would mean every particle (so far as we know) has integer charge. Planck charge (under any of the values mentioned above) is not any comfortable multiple of that charge.
Effectively, arguing that Planck units hold any physical significance amounts to modern-day numerology for the most part, just as much as when some physicists tried to argue numerological principles for the fine structure constant being exactly 1/137.