3 ms·
> for five consecutive hours ... as the grid was oversupplied owing to high wind generation during off-peak hours of low demand. This is exactly the problem th
by TheSpiceIsLife 9y ago
> for five consecutive hours ... as the grid was oversupplied owing to high wind generation during off-peak hours of low demand.
This is exactly the problem the detractors have with grid connected wind and solar.
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 9y agoOversupply is only a temporary problem. When long distance transmission lines to other countries have been built, energy can be transferred across the continent to where demand or available storage is.
- Symbiote 9y agoEurope already has that, though you could argue for more. Map: https://www.entsoe.eu/map/Pages/default.aspx https://www.entsoe.eu/map/Pages/default.aspx
- tromp 9y agoTime to install some slightly obsolete bitcoin miners...
- weaksauce 9y agoSo then pump water up a hill during times of excess and then use that stored energy to spin turbine generators during times of need. just because it's supplying "too much" energy at one time doesn't mean it's not something that could be used effectively with the right infrastructure.
- conjecTech 9y agoIdeas like this unfortunately end up not being very economical because of the fixed costs of the infrastructure needed and the relatively low duty cycle of use.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoThere are no new good places for hydroelectricity that everyone can agree on. Pumped hydro storage is best married to existing damns.
- skookumchuck 9y ago> everyone can agree on People don't even agree which direction the sun comes up.
- rpearl 9y agoI have two qualms about this claim: The first is purely economical. Does this not simply indicate that there is insufficient supply of electricity storage (ie batteries)? The second is... wow, if excess supply of energy is a reason there are detractors to wind and solar, then maybe treating electricity as a market is totally misaligned with perpetuating sustainable human activity. Maybe we shouldn't do that.
- nine_k 9y agoThe oversupply of electricity is not the cause of "detracing" solar and wind. It's its undersupply on a winless overcast evening. What we need is cheap (per GJ stored) longer-term electricity storage.
- imron 9y agoTesla Gigafactory to the rescue!
- paulddraper 9y agoIt's not the too much power; it's the erratic distribution of it. What do you do when it is too low? Too high? The obvious answer is energy storage, which is on of the problems to be solved.
- rayiner 9y agoIt's not the market that creates that problem for wind and solar--it's physics. Excess electricity supply has to closely match demand or bad things happen to the grid, market or no market.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoI don't think it goes far enough, I don't have any incentive as an individual to change my consumption patterns. If my price was continuously variable I would almost certainly change my behaviour to lower my energy costs.
- mtgx 9y agoSounds like someone needs to have better planning and buy a few extra batteries.
- ghouse 9y agoAnd hopefully to be ideologically consistent, these detractors have the same problem with coal and nuclear where it's more expensive for them to shut down and restart than it is for them to keep running and pay the negative price.
- zkms 9y agoOversupply is easy to burn up -- as long as there's robust and quick mechanisms for signalling when oversupply is going on. There's plenty of loads that can be quickly spun up -- transferring workload from one datacentre to another is possible, as is running refrigeration systems to generate ice (or some other phase-change material) that can be used up during peak demand. Anything remaining can be taken care of by bespoke energy storage systems, like batteries or pumped-storage.
- Teever 9y agoHell you could start using all that surplus energy to turn atmospheric CO2 and N into urea and use that for fertilizer.