3 ms·
I read this story, too, wondering why it was here. But I kept reading anyway because I had already noticed 18 comments and I was curious to see what my fellow
by edw519 19y ago
I read this story, too, wondering why it was here. But I kept reading anyway because I had already noticed 18 comments and I was curious to see what my fellow hackers had to say about this. (I'm a hacker news addict; I value your comments as much as the original content.)
I expected my fellow hackers to condemn this bullying behavior and support the bullyee. But instead I was very surprised (more like stunned) to read some of these responses.
I empathized with the boy in the story because it could have been my story. And probably the story of many people here. Just because you're not a jock or a ladies man, then something must be wrong with you.
The attacks on this boy were unacceptable and inexcusable. I don't know the answer to this problem, but blaming the victim is NOT.
- qaexl 19y agoThe funny thing about hackers is that they have the intellectual capability to hack their own life, and rarely try. Users who merely use a computer system don't get that feeling hackers get when they are able to push into that creative realm, to shape and mold a system, often ideas that had not been anywhere. It's that experience of bringing something out of nothing, I think, is what makes coding so much fun. You get to make choices when you code. But just as you can make these choices when you code, you can do the same for your life. Why else would people flock to Hacker News? Sure, it is about Paul Graham's ideas on startups. I think, though, we flock here because we want to take control of your financial situation. What about your social life? What about that bully in high school ... or that asshole boss of your's that keeps taking advantage of you? In this civilized society, physical abuse is grounds for punishment by the community. Verbal abuse leaves a lot of room to seriously damage someone without leaving a mark. The question I have to ask is, are you going to depend on the civilization's operating system, or are you going to use the skills learned from hacking code to really understand how the social OS works? It may seem like blaming the "user", but you protect users from themselves because they don't know how to hack. I too empathize with the boy, but I also think he already has a lot of the tools he needs to get himself out.
- edw519 19y agoSome of us just need a little more time than others. What concerns me most in this case is whether so much damage has been done to cripple the boy for life. Hard for us to imagine but still easy enough to happen.
- qaexl 19y agoThere are other societies who force this issue through a rite of passage. Though that can be just as crippling. I don't have to imagine the crippling effects of this. I've met a few people whom I can see it happen. As for myself, though I've never been bullied to the extent this kid has, I have had bad life strategies that took me years to disassemble. At the same time, some of the gifts I've been given are things that'd help even with crippling damage. As cheesy as that sounds. And assuming I remember if after suffering the damage. Civilization is what lets people behave like ... people ... without going around bashing each other on the head. Yet at the same time, you cannot let the civilized abstractions separate you from your survival instincts. We are not just the identity we form with other people; we are each in these fragile sacks of water called the human body. I may try to increase the general level of civilization to ensure the safety of the people, yet just as importantly, I'll also try to pass on survival skills that I have learned. Including surviving crippling damage.
- strey 19y agoOne of my principals told us a story about a boy he know who was insulted about a physical deformity all throughout his school career. He ended up a vegetable in a mental institute.
- cstejerean 19y agoWell, I'm not sure if we need to blame the victim, but everyone needs to realize the victim is partially responsible. That doesn't mean what's happening is right or even justifiable. Heck, nobody should have to go to school afraid that they'll end up in the hospital. The school definitely needs to be sued for not ensuring the safety of the students. But people will always pick on easy targets. The lesson to be learned is that confidence and the will to fight back can go a long way in preventing these kinds of attacks in the future. Sometimes the "wait for the authorities to save me" approach doesn't work. That's why we're empowered to defend ourselves. The solution is twofold: change the environment to reduce physical violence, and change Billy to make the bullies less willing to attempt any attacks.