12 ms·
It's funny how the vast majority of capitalist corporations consider capitalism as a sacrosanct principle, yet when you look at how they operate it's basically
by ryandrake 9y ago
It's funny how the vast majority of capitalist corporations consider capitalism as a sacrosanct principle, yet when you look at how they operate it's basically Soviet-style central planning. The senior executive [nomenklatura] who, often, are treated More Equal Than Others, centrally plan who works on what and what resources they are allocated: a bureaucratic elite picking and choosing how the wealth of the company is redistributed and used among teams, as opposed to letting a market decide which projects live and die. As Ronald Coase pointed out, companies tend to be "islands of central planning in a sea of market relationships."
Another parallel to the Soviets: Things like good-ol-boy networks and elite school alumni [membership in The Party] are largely what drives promotion within the higher ranks.
- aqsalose 9y agoSome leftists critical of the USSR described the Soviet system as "state capitalism": the state is the only capitalist in the system.
- adekok 9y agoWhich largely parallels one of my recent comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14513718 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14513718 Downvoted for no apparent reason... In short, managers often don't pay attention to how the products are created. They instead rely on checklists to "prove" that processes were followed. Nothing beats "feet on the ground". If you know what's going on, you know how to manage it. If you're managing based on summaries of summaries of summaries... it will go badly. See Jim Sinegal for a real-world example of this success story: https://www.usnews.com/news/best-leaders/articles/2009/10/22/jim-sinegal-costco-ceo-focuses-on-employees https://www.usnews.com/news/best-leaders/articles/2009/10/22...
- macspoofing 9y agoYou don't know what you're talking about. >Nothing beats "feet on the ground". Except if you're managing a huge global supply chain.
- adekok 9y agoThe career of Jim Sinegal largely proves you wrong. As does the career of Tim Cook. Before he was CEO, he was managing Apple's global supply chain. Which involved a lot of on-site visits. Try to explain how both of these people could have been just as successful while locked in a cubicle, and digesting reports from underlings. If you believe that, I have a bridge in Brooklyn to sell you. Cheap. Just read the remote reports, and spend the money without ever visiting the bridge.
- wmf 9y agoIt's probably worth noting that centrally-planned corporations receive feedback from the market in the form of sales but the USSR's central planners didn't really have any equivalent.
- coddingtonbear 9y agoThis might be surprising to you, but consumers still used currency to buy goods, and both surpluses and shortages were tracked. It isn't exactly the same as market feedback, but it did serve the same function.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIt may have served the same function, but it didn't do it as well. And if GE, say, messes us on jet engines, well, there's always Rolls-Royce. If the central planners mess up, you don't have an alternative.
- kbenson 9y agoI guess the equivalent for nations could exist, but it would require free migration. USSR central planning screw up? Guess it's time to emigrate to China. Of course switching the nation you are part of is usually (but not always) more complicated than switching the product you buy.
- kodfodrasz 9y agoActually the central planners did plan backups and alternatives for everything. With all its flaws even the SU was not so flawed to let total idiots make every economic decision. Just think of Mig and Sukhoi, for a simple example. Or NPO-Saturn and Tumansky, if you prefer jet-engine manufacturers.
- kadavero 9y ago> not so flawed to let total idiots make every economic decision You might want to read up on Khruschev's corn farming plans, Gorbachev's prohibition, Mao's backyard furnaces and many more. Slightly tangent, check on Trofim Lysenko's anti-genetics antics. USSR style socialism explicitly declared ideology over science, engineering and what not. And by ideology they meant whatever The Great Leader says.
- TomMarius 9y agoThe difference is that the corporations are still participating in a free market trade, no one is forced to be a customer while communist governments don't have to worry about losing a customer.
- 0xfeba 9y agoIt can be vastly more complicated than that. What with the auto industry bailouts, sub-prime lending, subsidized minimum wage jobs, etc. Corporations will take advantage of the government in ways that are very not capitalist if it suits them.
- kuschku 9y agoThis quickly changes if some companies products become basically required, though, or if companies gain monopolies.
- maxxxxx 9y agoIt seems with the bailouts of 2008 and other subsidies we are forced to support companies if we like it or not.
- TomMarius 9y agoThat's true and a sad consequence of increasingly socialist governments.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI have been thinking the same thing. From the inside a corporation is a planned economy like East Germany. Five year plans, motivational posters and speeches, huge number of bureaucrats and a huge discrepancy between what leaders proclaim and the reality that people on the ground can see.
- MichaelMoser123 9y agoWith a corporation you can always quit but in the eastern block you couldn't do that because of armed border guards. Hayek says that central planning of an entire economy results in dictatorship, because conflicting interests have to be resolved by non economic means that involves the pressure of a secret police. i think he was right, it doesn't matter how many computers you have for solving planning problems, there always remain conflicting interests when the big father in the ministry has to decide who gets the stuff, central planing turns matters of distribution into political problems
- irixusr 9y agothe ezception that proves the rule. You could, theoretically, leave the USSR, if you paid back what society had invested in you. De facto it was very hard to leave You can quit your job. Except many of us de facto can't (H1B1, non compete clauses, etc) Leaving Yugoslavia was probably easier than being an Indian engineer on an H1B working for a company with a non compete clause. Btw, I don't think Hayek or any of the Austrians had very benign attitudes towards multinationals or large corporations: Begging for tax payer largess, ghostwriting regulations creating artificial barriers to entry, abusing immigration law to have a de facto slave. Mises and Rothbard would tut tut. And they were the hard core anti commies!
- MichaelMoser123 9y agoYugoslavia and Poland where the two socialist countries where citizens were allowed to travel to the west. Exceptions: both countries were relatively poor and didn't mind a few people leaving (also in Poland (PPR) the government used to make consessions when it faced popular pressure)
- trhway 9y agoas the saying, at least among Russian immigrants who saw USSR, goes - the bigger the corporation the more of socialism inside it. In general it just follows from the main principle of Marxism described in the Das Kapital - higher entropy of ownership distribution leads to the higher degree of socialism (as the reverse of that entropy value basically being the strength of coupling between the ownership power and the execution power). From minimum entropy of ownership distribution - one 100% owner - to publicly owned companies to government run agencies and government owned properties to socialist state where nominally all the people collectively own everything. Significant change in entropy of such distribution - when say a significant stake of a public company gets concentrated in some single hand or when the whole company goes private or when some government agency gets privatized - usually leads to significant change in degree of socialism inside the company or the agency.
- macspoofing 9y ago>higher entropy of ownership distribution leads to the higher degree of socialism That characterization doesn't fit at all. Capitalist/Market-based societies are far more decentralized, with a higher entropy ownership distribution, than Communist/Socialist ones. In Market-based systems hundreds of thousands of small, medium and large companies and millions (or hundreds of millions) of individuals do day-to-day business with each other without direct oversight or control of a central body. >where nominally all the people collectively own everything. Except that's not how collective ownership works. A society of millions of citizens can't collectively manage anything - they need to create representative institutions to do that on their behalf. The bigger the collective, the less entropy the representative institution displays. So collective ownership in practice is a very very low entropy position.
- trhway 9y agoman, you have completely mixed up ownership power with executive/management power. When everybody owns everything that is maximum possible entropy of ownership power distribution, and that results in practically minimum entropy of executive/management power distribution - the heavily centralized planning&control. By contrast, in capitalist society every piece of property, except for government owned, is owned by a set of people smaller than the whole society and their stakes aren't necessarily equal - thus such distribution has lesser entropy that the socialist one of everybody everything. Where is management and control in the capitalist society and economy being less centralized has thus higher entropy distribution than the socialist centralized.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoDidn't the CEO of Sears try the internal-capitalism approach, only to have the company basically self-implode?
- realusername 9y agoIt almost destroyed Sony as well. Having a balance sheet per department and letting them compete is the fastest way to crash a company.
- fpoling 9y agoThe scale matters and managing even not so small companies Soviet Style is quite OK. As the article point out for small number of products optimization problems are solvable in one way or another. I will not even be surprised if few rules of thumb that a good manager instinctively uses give good enough solutions in most cases that matter. But that fails as n growths.
- azernik 9y agoAn interesting example of this is the modern Israeli kibbutz. These are literal socialist collectives [1] that function as actors in the capitalist economy. And a lot of them are quite good at it! It may be hard to motivate innovation in a nation-size egalitarian society, but it seems to work quite well in an economic unit where everyone knows everyone else and you personally know, or at least recognize, everyone who benefits from your innovation. (And they know you and recognize your accomplishments, which is also a big motivator.) [1] In the ideologically pure case, which is a common case but not universal or even the majority.
- Animats 9y agoThat's a scaling issue. Communes work well up to about 100 people. Today's larger kibbutz is more like a company with worker housing. "Differential pay was introduced into the kibbutz structure; management has become increasingly professionalized; and the community and business structures have been separated"[1] [1] http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/history-and-overview-of-the-kibbutz-movement http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/history-and-overview-of-...
- azernik 9y agoHence the "ideologically pure" caveat; there is a fascinating subset of kibbutzim which make enough money to essentially function as post-scarcity economies (making things like Humvee armor add-ons for the Americans, or high-end vending machines for e.g. movie rentals). Those have been able to stay ideologically pure by being more effective players in a capitalist system [1], and once they reach that state they are able to maintain it through social forces. [1] which of course creates some serious cognitive dissonance for all involved
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- macspoofing 9y ago> yet when you look at how they operate it's basically Soviet-style central planning What are you talking about? Big Corporations will have thousands of suppliers, thousands of partnerships and millions of customers - none of whom are directly (centrally) controlled or managed. They are also far more transparent and truthful about their production numbers and costs. They are far more nimble, far more efficient, and far less corrupt.