4 ms·
Central Planning, as reasonable as it sounds, can only play a very limited role in a free society. The goal of production is to meet demands, and one of the goa
by Koshkin 9y ago
Central Planning, as reasonable as it sounds, can only play a very limited role in a free society. The goal of production is to meet demands, and one of the goals of planning is to optimize things, but demands are easy to underestimate; the optimization then will lead to planning only for the type of production that can ensure basic survival and not much more.
The relatively high standard of living in the former socialist economies was to a large degree due to the need to compete with the capitalist economies, where standard of living, abundance and variety of products all grow naturally higher with time, rather than get "optimized" into oblivion.
- baursak 9y ago> Central Planning, as reasonable as it sounds, can only play a very limited role in a free society. USA, for example, has a lot of central planning, in the private sector alone, not even considering the public sector. Any large mega-corp is an example. Walmart has a huge centrally planned operations and supply chain. > capitalist economies, where standard of living, abundance and variety of products all grow naturally higher with time How would you explain stalled and declining standard of living in the Western capitalist economies over the past 30 years or so?
- WouterZ 9y agoThe fact that the rich take the cake and hide it through tax evasion... Pikkety self enforcing cenrralization of wealth...
- bcoates 9y agoThat's not central planning, that's just regular planning. Both Walmart's supply of resources and other producers of its goods (or near-identical substitute goods) are outside the control of its planners, forcing them to spend most of their energy dealing with the vagaries of the market instead of just making their goods, which is what socialist planning was supposed to avoid. Adding planners doesn't give you more (central planning) it gives you (less central) planning
- baursak 9y agoThe point is that companies like Walmart operate internally just like Soviet Union. The USSR was also constrained by a global capitalist market system and traded extensively with other countries, including the U.S. Further, Walmart has an enormous influence, and often outright economical control over many of its suppliers, to the point that it can make or break them. It's notorious for playing hardball in their negotiations with suppliers. Even further, there's such a thing as Walmart's brands, which place even further control over white label suppliers, and sometimes take over production on their own: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Walmart_brands https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Walmart_brands Even further, Walmart owns its trucking fleet and employs truck drivers directly.
- utexaspunk 9y ago>but demands are easy to underestimate Certainly during the USSR's time. But now you could issue every citizen a smartphone through which they could register their demand. >the optimization then will lead to planning only for the type of production that can ensure basic survival and not much more. Sorry, but I'm not seeing how this follows logically.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> But now you could issue every citizen a smartphone through which they could register their demand. Unless they are expending a limited resource to do so, the same problem remains. In capitalist market economy that resource is money [1], and it's universal and fungible, both bid for goods and services (and not just in typically "consumer" markets) and bid against with offerings of labor. If you abolish meaningful markets for some goods and services—including wage labor—you limit the scope of utility signals you get—even if, as most real world state socialist systems have done, you retain exchange of currency for “consumer” goods and services. [1] which, despite its utility, has significant issues, too. Nothing in this post is meant to endorse the optimality of capitalism, only to explain the problem of utility signalling in state socialism.
- utexaspunk 9y agoIt wasn't my intent to imply this didn't involve money. You can have central planning and still have money, no? I would not disagree that it's nigh impossible to have a functional economy without money...
- bcoates 9y agoIf you can do central planning, money becomes mostly superfluous. The whole point is that factories don't pay for their inputs, stores are stocked without borrowing to buy goods, profitability of individual firms becomes irrelevant, and the overwhelming majority of economic activity is based on supplying planned needs. You could still have money but needing money to live a normal life or being able to use money to invest or stockpile goods would represent a failure of central planning.