7 ms·
The contest between gravity and quantum physics takes a new turn (2015)
- pg_is_a_butt 9y agono
- dogma1138 9y agoCan we stop ignoring the fact that Quantum gravity exists and works for the most part. The parts where it doesn't work are extremes like black holes where GR also breaks apart.
- vecter 9y agoWhere's the evidence for your statement? This is what Wikipedia says: > Currently, there is still no complete and consistent quantum theory of gravity, and the candidate models still need to overcome major formal and conceptual problems. They also face the common problem that, as yet, there is no way to put quantum gravity predictions to experimental tests, although there is hope for this to change as future data from cosmological observations and particle physics experiments becomes available. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_gravity#Candidate_theories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_gravity#Candidate_theo...
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoIt very likely exists, somewhere out there in the grand scheme of things, but so far we don't know squat about it. > The parts where it doesn't work are extremes like black holes where GR also breaks apart. Wrong. That scenario is exactly the kind that quantum gravity is supposed to illuminate. Of course, we can't be 100% sure about that yet.
- H4CK3RM4N 9y ago> Just as a pixel is the smallest unit of an image on your screen and a photon is the smallest unit of light, he argues, so there might be an unbreakable smallest unit of distance: a quantum of space. I thought that that role was fuffiled with the Planck Length. I've seen it used in conjunction with the speed of light to calculate a theoretical "refresh rate" of the universe, was that based on a flawed assumption?
- krohling 9y agoWas just wondering the same. I suspect the Planck Length is a lower bound on the hypothetically smallest unit of distance, however in practice perhaps it's larger. The difference between this experimental resolution (10^-18m) and the Planck Length (10^-35m) is absolutely enormous though, so a negative result would still be very inconclusive and highly likely.
- Retra 9y agoIf there's a smallest unit of distance, shouldn't there be a shortest wavelength? And thus a smallest difference in wavelength and maximum energy? And a smallest energy change? And thus there must be a minimally different relative velocity, to preserve discretization of relativistic energies and momenta? And a thousand other things we also have no evidence for?
- lnanek2 9y ago> And a smallest energy change? > And a thousand other things we also have no evidence for? It's called quantum physics because it was proven that there is a small amount of energy which is basically the indivisible unit of energy. So yes, that exists, and has been proven. It is the whole point of quantum physics, quantum referring to an amount and the smallest packet being a "quanta of light": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum
- ars 9y ago> that there is a small amount of energy which is basically the indivisible unit of energy What? No. Quantum physics means that things happen in "bundles", usually small ones. But it does not define any particular size to those bundles. They could be big, they could be small. > "quanta of light": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum You misunderstand your link. A quantum is the smallest unit of energy in that particular interaction. In other interactions the quantum could have a different magnitude.
- deleted 9y ago
- vorg 9y ago> What if the universe were entirely empty except for two astronauts. One of them is spinning, the other is stationary. The spinning one feels dizzy, doing cartwheels in space. But which one of the two is spinning? From either astronaut’s perspective, the other is the one spinning. Without any external reference, Einstein argued, there is no way to say which one is correct There is a 50% chance each is spinning, and we'll know which is correct when an external reference "observes" them. The fact that there's no external reference is what makes this situation be "quantum". If the conscious astronauts are conceptually incapable of being 50% "feeling dizzy", then that would mean conscious beings also require the external reference in order to exist.
- phs2501 9y agoWouldn't the spinning one see the other "orbiting" rather than spinning? If gravity is not strong enough to cause that orbit and there's no thrust evident that could explain the delta-V causing the orbit, couldn't you then conclude that you're spinning without an external reference?
- styrophone 9y agoI think this thought experiment assumes the astronaut is spinning around an axis orthogonal to their belly. From the cartwheeling astronaut's perspective, the other one is also cartwheeling in their own plane.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoBut if you tuck in your knees and the other guy spins differently, that's a sign you're the one spinning, no?
- styrophone 9y agoYeah, the choice of a non-inertial reference frame for this example is a little confusing to me too. I also haven't been able to find an independent mention of the spinning astronaut experiment.
- suprgeek 9y agoNo it will not. Elements from both theories will be used to formulate the structure/theory/paradigm that will then subsume both of them.
- platz 9y ago> Beneath its layers of conceptual complexity, the holometer is technologically little more than a laser beam, a half-reflective mirror to split the laser into two perpendicular beams, and two other mirrors to bounce those beams back along a pair of 40-meter-long tunnels. > For the scale of chunkiness that Hogan hopes to find, he needs to measure distances to an accuracy of 10-18 meters, about 100 million times smaller than a hydrogen atom, and collect data at a rate of about 100 million readings per second. How is this different from LIGO in any way?
- 6nf 9y agoIt's the same thing but the Holometer is intended to be more sensitive than LIGO.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]