4 ms·
> In March, it was revealed that the company had been “greyballing” law enforcement, hiding vehicles from them in an effort to fox attempts to catch drivers in
by paulddraper 9y ago
> In March, it was revealed that the company had been “greyballing” law enforcement, hiding vehicles from them in an effort to fox attempts to catch drivers in cities where the app is banned.
Is that wrong? If there's a police car set up on 6th, can I avoid it and go on 7th? Or does that mean I'm a criminal with something to hide?
- randomanybody 9y agoMaybe not strictly against the law, but if I'm riding in your car and you are purposely ducking cops, I'm going to feel a bit suspicious.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoYes, it's wrong. If Uber is banned in a city, that means it's against the law. Dodging cops while you're doing something against the law... yeah, that's wrong. It's wrong to be doing the thing that against the law, and you're proving that you know it by dodging the cops. But you may argue that the Uber service is fine; the law itself is wrong. And that's a reasonable argument. (Not necessarily right, but at least reasonable.) But the correct way to respond is with civil disobedience - deliberately disobey the law, and accept the consequences, trying to win either in court of law or in the court of public opinion. You can't do that if you dodge the consequences. Don't dodge bad laws. Either obey them (even while you're working to change them), or publicly disobey them. Dodging the cops is not the answer.
- throwaway35775 9y agoI don't think the company makes any secret of operating in any city. As far as I know they are quite public and let elected officials know they are going to operate in their city. This means that the city can quite trivially subpoena the company once it starts operating. The drivers are just trying to earn a living. So basically the company was practicing civil disobedience, but was kind enough not to try and keep individual drivers just trying to make a living out of it.
- qq66 9y agoIf you're not breaking the law, then avoiding police is perfectly legal. If you are breaking the law, avoiding police, depending on how you do it, can be an additional violation of the law, and can be a criminal addition to a civil infraction.
- SilasX 9y agoNAL, but my understanding is that it's legal to avoid police, or kick them off your service, but it's not legal to lie to someone you specifically believe to be a police officer in order to hinder their investigation. My biker bar analogy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14270214 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14270214
- foxyv 9y agoAvoiding the police is perfectly okay. The thing that is illegal is that Uber is facilitating the operation of illegal taxi cabs. In this case, Uber's avoidance of police demonstrates a sort of 'mens rea' a mindful violation of the law.