4 ms·
Part of the appeal of good wine for me is the social aspect of discovery, and I don't think I'd want to trade that in for a technical one. I don't want a perfec
by simonsarris 9y ago
Part of the appeal of good wine for me is the social aspect of discovery, and I don't think I'd want to trade that in for a technical one. I don't want a perfect wine so much as I want to drink a sincere recommendation from a friend or family member, and hopefully have that same wine again with them, and have something to talk about. In fact when I'm with certain people, even bad wine is fondly remembered. "What was that chalk we were drinking last month... I crave it when I think of you."*
The funny thing about all this is that his big data quest for more good wine was launched because of the same reason I enjoy wine: It was his brother-in-law's recommendation that found him his favorite, not crunching the #cassis #vanilla #persistentfinish numbers. And he's doing this to find bottles similar to the one from a beloved family member, most of which are far more expensive (eyeballing the graph), but if I were him, I don't know if I could ever find a better bottle than "my brother-in-law's wine." Isn't sentimentality worth more than the data, especially when working with the most fickle data-set of all?
Also, come on, don't make a post like this and not give us the list!
* (We were drinking Troublemaker, a Paso Robles blend, which I swear is 50% syrah and 50% limestone.)
- gingerlime 9y agoYou have to start somewhere, but I'd love to be able to get wine recommendations based on my personal favourites + some heuristics that come up with something less obvious or that I wouldn't pick otherwise. I don't care so much about his list, but being able to use the same engine he did with my own starting point would be great. On a side note, I wonder how the recommendations are influenced by the audience. i.e. wine.com is presumably used by US customers, so perhaps it could explain why French wines are described in certain ways compared to California. But you might get the opposite if you look at a European website.
- ghostDancer 9y agoI always ask friends and sellers for similar wines , the recommendations are usually good and sometimes with surprises (bad and good).