3 ms·
Haven't read the entire thing, though there's good stuff in there. One disagreement I have is with the use of slides. Slides should only be used for things that
by ravenstine 9y ago
Haven't read the entire thing, though there's good stuff in there. One disagreement I have is with the use of slides. Slides should only be used for things that cannot be described merely through words. Mostly graphs and code. Photos, inspirational quotes, and cat gifs should be insulting to the audience because they are distracting, convey no information, and are just an appeal to your senses. Even the second and third best public speakers don't use slides as a crutch, and really nobody should. Public speaking should be entertaining, but it's the speaking itself that should be entertaining. I would rather try be like one of the best public speakers than impress people with my mad web surfing skillz.
- arkitaip 9y agoI can here for this comment. To me, slides are like tables or diagrams in a research paper: you only use them because expressing the idea in a paragraph (i.e. speaking) would be too difficult or nonsensical. I understand that some speakers are so slide centric because it's their presentation style or they do it for shits and giggles, but most speakers seems to do it because of ignorance and inexperience.
- ravenstine 9y agoEither way, it's still a crutch. If they do it because it's their style, that's fine except it's utterly pointless and audiences should be insulted by it; at best, the slides just repeat the same information that the speaker is telling you in person, and at worst it's inane kinda funny garbage that I could have easily come across on my own time. The information and insight itself should be compelling enough to carry a talk, and if the speaker can't muster the enthusiasm to actually entertain people while being informative, said speaker really isn't providing much value at all. Admittedly, this is from my perspective and I know that slide-heavy talks amuse people. I'm going to be a pompous jackass and say that people should have a little integrity and actually care more about the information they are receiving than by merely being entertained. In a sense, I am criticizing audiences more than I am speakers because speakers wouldn't get away with these things if they weren't getting even just a couple laughs. Slides have their place, but the ideal should be that they are only used as figures would be in a research paper. Imagine how annoying it would be if most research papers had meme images between every paragraph! Funny at first, but would get super tiresome when you're trying to understand algorithm-heavy concepts.
- watwut 9y agoI like slides that "just repeat the information that was said". It makes it easier to think about previous point (because it is in front of me) and easier to catch up if I lost attention momentary. It makes it also easier to remember what was said afterwards (I can either remember speech or slide visually and having it in two forms help).
- ghaff 9y agoThere are certainly speeches/talks that don't require the use of slides at all. However, slides do often help engage an audience and keep attention focused. (Though less content is often better.) I tend to use photos plus a relatively few words personally. Presentations that are unadorned but with some minimal text also works. But there are certainly different styles. There's also a tension between presentations that can stand on their own and those that are solely in support of a live presentation. In an ideal world, most decks wouldn't be called on to function as a substitute for watching the actual presentation but that often isn't realistic.
- nunez 9y agoHeavily depends on the audience. If you're doing an internal presentation for a company, you can bet that everyone is mostly hoping for a slide deck in their inbox an hour after your talk is done. So it has to have lots of words and pictures.
- snug 9y agoI think the cat gifs can work (or other memes,) but it has to be the right speaker. If the speaker is funny then it works, but if the speaker is using it to break the ice or tension, then it does not work and it's just awkward.