3 ms·
My Dad used to say soil is overrated. Once nitrogen fertilizer was invented, soil largely quit mattering. He got the best yields on eroded clay hillsides. See,
by JoeAltmaier 9y ago
My Dad used to say soil is overrated. Once nitrogen fertilizer was invented, soil largely quit mattering. He got the best yields on eroded clay hillsides. See, they were well-drained which matters more than all the 'soil structure' talk.
Could be that Iowa soil is so good already that our eroded clay hillsides are better than other states' best soil. I guess. But I'm thinking no.
- freehunter 9y agoDirt itself is overrated, sure. Soil has a little different connotation. It's not the sand or clay or any kind of dirt in particular, but rather the nutrients that are in it. If you have great soil, you won't need to add those nutrients. If you don't have great soil, you need to add them in. If you have fertilizer, you don't need good soil. But it's better to have good soil and not need fertilizer. For one, good soil doesn't leak into waterways and destroy fish habitats the way nitrogen fertilizers do.
- bluGill 9y agogood soil creates nitrogen on its own that leaks into waterways and destroys fish habitats. The first settlers in Iowa (European - I don't know about the natives before them) learned the hard way that water in Iowa is high enough in nitrates to kill babies.
- existencebox 9y agoThe worrying issue for me largely isn't nutrient based, it's that widespread erosion is cyclic, and no matter how "well drained" it is, there's very little you can grow in sand. Additionally, dust storms have well known health consequences when they get large/common enough. I'm not a meteorologist, so I can't speak to the likelihood of something on this scale, but there's still a strong cultural memory back to the 1930s to keep a handle on runaway erosion.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoIowa (my part anyway?) has a hundred feet of clay before reaching rock. We've lost, reportedly, inches of topsoil in the last century. Maybe we have a millennia or two before that's a problem.