4 ms·
As an American, I remember back when the Republicans passed the "Personal Accountability Act" or some such. The gist was that credit card debt was going to be e
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
As an American, I remember back when the Republicans passed the "Personal Accountability Act" or some such. The gist was that credit card debt was going to be even harder to get out of when a person goes bankrupt. The spin? People need to be responsible. When they make debts, they have a moral obligation to pay them. Therefore, the government shouldn't help them do something immoral.
Never mind the fact that the entire business model of credit is based on assuming a risk the borrower doesn't pay. If government takes away that risk, well, it's like printing money. Which is exactly what the credit card companies are doing.
I was with the author until this point: That’s what should happen in a healthy market. Credit and debit cards aren’t a healthy market. That’s why regulation is necessary.
Whoa. Hold on a minute. Regulation is the tool of the monopolist, not his enemy. I told the story about the Republicans to make a point: the game is for special interests like PACs to write legislation that then makes their members more powerful. The best (sometimes the only) way to do this is to pretend like you're regulating or cleaning up the industry in question.
So the Congressman who's all about cleaning up the finance industry? His staff is the one writing the 2,000 page bill that nobody understands yet somehow will be a boon to the finance industry in the next five years or so. When folks figure out that the bill actually made matters worse, he'll be the guy on TV telling us that what we need is actually another bill, much better than the first one, and the cycle continues. (Just got through reading a great article on just this process from an HN link: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/print/2009/05/the-quiet-coup/7364/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/print/2009/05/the-quiet-...)
The answer, I think, is that government has a critical role in defining things. How about defining what a life insurance policy is? Make seven different levels. If you sell life insurance, you have to meet one of the levels. Or in this case creating a standardized P2P clearing process for payments? Nobody needs to force people to use it, heck, if you can standardize the way payments are made between parties such that the banks are mostly out of the picture? Visa and MasterCard just go away.
Not that this will happen. Too many connections and powerful people involved. But the point is that there is a spot between chaos and total regulation where government can and should do a lot of good. That point, in a lot of cases, is just in making definitions and forcing market players to use them. These choices are presented almost always as false dichotomies: one extreme or the other. That's because arguments sell newspapers and make people watch TV shows. It's also because in most cases politicians get more votes from the argument than from the solution (another reason why the regulatory bills that create new problems will come forth ad infinitum)
- Robin_Message 16y agoFrank Herbert says this better than I can in "Chapterhouse Dune", where the captured Bene Gesserit Lucilla is speaking to Spider Queen, head of the Honoured Matres (p 150--158.) (Actually the whole book is about law and governance.) An excerpt: "That's not what I said. We have no conventional government." "Not even a social code?" "There's no such thing as a social code to meet all necessities. A crime in one society can be a moral requirement in another society." "People always have government." ... "I knew you didn't allow a democracy!" "Why won't you believe me?" [...] "Because you'd have to permit open voting, juries and judges and . . ." "We call them Proctors. A sort of jury of the Whole." Now you've confused her. "And no laws . . . regulations, whatever you want to call them?" "Didn't I say we defined them separately? Regulation-past. Law-future." "You limit these . . . these Proctors, somehow!" "They can arrive at any decision they desire, the way a jury should function. The law be damned!" "That's a very disturbing idea." She's disturbed all right. Look at how dull her eyes are. "The first rule of our democracy: no laws restricting juries. Such laws are stupid. It's astonishing how stupid humans can be when acting in small, self- serving groups." --- To relate this more directly to your point; if we take the definition of regulation as past and law as future, then regulation is almost by definition a tool of the monopolist and the vested interests. However, in the case given here, the problem is a monopoly, and we have a law against monopolies, that can interpret things sensibly, and will ultimately go before a court with a jury that can suggest and enforce radical solutions. We don't need new regulation to fix the credit and debit card market -- we need to kick existing law into action.
- dantheman 16y agoI think you only need to look at the complete clusterfuck that was the Interstate Commerce Commission to see that you don't want the government defining things, setting prices, forcing standards etc.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoNever mind the fact that the entire business model of credit is based on assuming a risk the borrower doesn't pay. Nonsense. The entire business model of credit is giving you money now which you give back later. Default risk is just an unfortunate side effect of that problem. Some people were gaming the bankruptcy system, and the Personal Accountability Act tried to make that more difficult. For example, remember that NYT reporter who went bankrupt because of his spendthrift wife? Turns out she was a serial bankruptcy filer who strategically managed her debt/spending to exploit the system. http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/05/the-road-to-bankruptcy/17976/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/05/the-road... Maybe bankruptcy reform was poorly designed (if so, make that case), but it's hardly a giveaway to the credit issuers.