4 ms·
Why do I have a feeling that some disclosure law is not going to suddenly make people not be greedy? It's one of those laws that make it look like you did some
by ars 9y ago
Why do I have a feeling that some disclosure law is not going to suddenly make people not be greedy?
It's one of those laws that make it look like you did something, while doing nothing.
The new government is right to get rid of it - it's pointless and will help nobody.
Now if you made a law that made commissions completely illegal (in finance, insurance, and other similar areas) - that would do something.
- zaidf 9y agoThe point of a law is two folds: (1) to act as a deterrent (2) when violated and the violator is caught, to have an avenue to prosecute them (and provide some form of justice.) Even if you're completely right (I don't believe you are) and the law doesn't deter ANYONE from committing the crime, its second purpose still has value. Laws against homicide, robbery etc. haven't resulted in 0 homicides and robbery; and yet, they have been used to prosecute people who have committed those crimes. If those laws didn't exist, murder and robbery would not be against the law. We can argue all day if the law has done much to deter those things but it's a fact that the law helps in delivering justice. Without the law, it would be legal to murder someone and face zero legal consequences.
- ars 9y agoThat would be true if law would actually be used to prosecute anyone. But it won't. The criteria are nebulous "must pick the best product". The advisor will just say "I believed this one was the best". How are you going to prove that? On top of that, victims don't typically even know if the advisor was wrong! So they'll never even take him to court. Plus it's a civil matter, meaning it costs the clients lots of money to bring a case. It will not have the effect you describe. Are there are requirements for review of advisors? That their advice goes to some panel for review? That the panel would have the power to actually arrest them if they disagree? It does not. It's a pointless law.
- MarkMc 9y agoHow do you feel about a similar law for real estate agents? That is, the agent must act in the interest of the seller and cannot accept money from a buyer. Or a law that says lawyers must act in the interest of their clients?
- ars 9y ago> How do you feel about a similar law for real estate agents? Totally useless. Real estate agents only have the sellers interests in mind because the higher the selling price, the more they make. Real estate is probably the poster child for pointlessness of these laws. > Or a law that says lawyers must act in the interest of their clients? This one seems to work fine. The interests of the lawyer are aligned with the clients anyway, so no law is necessary in the first place.
- MarkMc 9y ago> Real estate agents only have the sellers interests in mind because the higher the selling price, the more they make. Hmmm...is that always true? What if the seller is asking $1 million for a house, then I approach the agent and say, "My offer is $850,000. If the buyer accepts this offer I will give you, the agent, $50,000". Wouldn't that be a problem?
- concede_pluto 9y agoThis. If a 5% lower price makes a sale 10% faster or more likely, that's what a full-time real estate agent wants to recommend.
- ars 9y agoThat's the hope. In practice there are many more complications. For example: Negotiations - you would expect your buyers agent to negotiate with the seller for the best (i.e. lowest) price. They'll never do it unless you make them. It's not all roses on the seller side either: The sellers agent is highly motivated to sell fast (i.e. less work for them). Like you said, 5% lower, 10% faster. So the sellers agent will tell the seller to list at a lower price than they should, to get a faster sale. This is not to the benefit of a seller who has time to wait for a good offer. So, like I said earlier: Real Estate is the poster child for why these laws are worthless. Just get rid of commissions, and switch to fee-for-service (possibly paid after sale). Each time they show the house they get a fixed fee, things like that.