5 ms·
Brought to You by the Letter S
- phsr 16y agoThis is an incredibly sneaky move by an administration that railed CEOs for receiving large bonuses and salaries when they are running companies that are failing and need to be bailed out. Seems very two faced to me.
- mseebach 16y agoIf you're cynical you could argue that it's because it's harder to rail against large bonuses if there's real shareholder democracy.. A baptists/bootlegger alliance if you will.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoObama is probably doing it because it could open the door for shareholders to engage in asset stripping (selling off corporate assets and shut dow the company). Asset stripping, while good for shareholders and the economy at large, tends to be bad for unions. (A hypothetical example: consider a company with 1 billion in salable assets, but no hope for future profits based on existing business due to union costs. The best way to create shareholder value is to shut down the company and sell the corporate assets. The current CEO probably likes his job and doesn't want to be "the guy who killed BigCo". )
- chmike 16y agoIsn't there a risk to expose a company to a "white revolution" by shareholders ?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhat's a "white revolution"? Wikipedia only tells me about a group of idiots, and a program to give india a milk distribution platform.
- chmike 16y agoA revolution without spilling blood. A revolution is where the table of control gets turned.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThat's the whole point of proxy access - to make shareholder revolutions easier.
- foonly 16y agoPerhaps someone more knowledgeable can enlighten me... if the provision has already been approved, how can the White House change the wording? I thought the President wasn't able to make modifications to legislation.
- phsr 16y agoLine-item veto: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line-item_veto http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line-item_veto >The line-item vetoes are usually subject to the possibility of legislative override as are traditional vetoes
- foonly 16y agoI did remember that the '96 act was axed by the court, but I wasn't aware of the more recent versions. I suppose this story is a perfect demonstration of why this kind of thing is a bad idea
- isleyaardvark 16y agoIt's not a line-item veto. That wiki page mentions it has not become law. As far as I can tell, the bill is in committee. Both the House and Senate have to vote on the exact same bill. But both houses like to make their own changes. So each pass their own version of the bill, then meet in committee to come up with a version they both agree on, this new one goes back to both houses and they pass it. What I suspect is being claimed is that it says "shareholders" in both the House and Senate versions that already passed, and the White House is asking the committee to change that to "shareholder", otherwise Obama will veto it. Edit: This article contains a barely legible image describing the process: http://www.mcclatchydc.com/2010/03/03/89797/heres-how-reconciliation-works.html http://www.mcclatchydc.com/2010/03/03/89797/heres-how-reconc...
- eli 16y agoThat's just plain wrong. There is no federal line item veto and even if there were you couldn't use it to veto one letter.
- 16y ago
- wmeredith 16y agoYou may not agree with it, but you've got to admit that's a nice lightweight hack.
- sriram_sun 16y agoI am thinking of workarounds. What if shareholders get together and form a "holding company" with > 5% shares? The company would become the shareholder wouldn't it?
- three14 16y agoWhat are the tax consequences?
- ihodes 16y agoI don't understand why this is anyone's concern aside from the company's. If they squander money on the CEO's salary and fail because of it, that is their onus. If they succeed, then why should we intervene?
- bh42 16y agoWe all (OK, maybe just me) agree that the free market is the way to go, competition, prosperity, etc. But the free market is an ideal which is easy to game. CEOs hand picking the board, and the board then turning around and deciding on the CEOs compensation is an example of the free market being gamed. It's a bit more complicated then that, it requires the government enforced and defined legal entity that is a corporation, but it's still market inefficiency, mostly agency risk. So in a way, it is the public's concern to remove market inefficiencies.
- ihodes 16y agoBut it's not. If the company can succeed with the inefficiency, then it's not that big an inefficiency. It's a much more difficult argument to say that it is the public's concern to eliminate every inefficiency. God, imagine the employment opportunities for fixing poorly designed enterprise software... But no one is arguing that we do that. It is so easy to agree to not let an individual get rich from an inefficiency. This is not to say I don't agree that it's a terrible, idiotic practice. But it's not my decision to step in.
- sprout 16y agoThe point is you're already stepping in. There are tons of laws just like this one on the books, and the whole concept of a corporation falls apart without these laws. Throwing up your arms and saying "it's not my decision to step in" is silly. The public is already stepping in through hundreds of regulators, and it seems pretty self-evident that these regulators need a better framework. (Or we could get rid of them, but we can't really do that without getting rid of the corporations, and even then we're looking at something that probably is not really as good an idea as it might sound.)
- bh42 16y agoCould this lead to a move by big investor to gain 5% of stock just so they can nominate alternative board members? Is this realistic? I understand almost no one owns those kind of proportions today, but what would be the incentive today if everyone seeks diversification. This would create an incentive, would it not?