3 ms·
> Just because we have a different value for pi doesn’t mean we have a different sin function. Although amalcon seems to disclaim this point of view (http://ne
by JadeNB 16y ago
> Just because we have a different value for pi doesn’t mean we have a different sin function.
Although amalcon seems to disclaim this point of view (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1450919 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1450919), I think that this is exactly what it does mean—because we are used to viewing sine as a function that takes numbers (unitless), rather than measurements (with units).
The grand(^n)parent (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1450467 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1450467) talked about trigonometric functions of cycles, with the understanding that sin(x) now means sin(x cycle) = sin(2πx radian), so that
---
(d/dx)sin(x) = (d/dx)sin(x cycle) = (d/dx)sin(2πx radian) = 2πcos(2πx radian) = 2πcos(x cycle) = 2πcos(x).
---
Note that, with this convention, sin(6.28…) does not* equal sin(6.28…)—because, as you can tell, the first 6.28… is clearly measured in cycles, and the second in radians. I'm pretty sure that this is all that amalcon was saying.