4 ms·
The Japanese were ready and willing to surrender before the bombs dropped - and they knew the war was lost as soon as the Soviet Union betrayed its neutrality t
by vkou 9y ago
The Japanese were ready and willing to surrender before the bombs dropped - and they knew the war was lost as soon as the Soviet Union betrayed its neutrality treaty.
What they were not ready for, was an unconditional surrender. (And, in the end, they surrendered conditionally! The entire sticking point turned out to be moot.)
Truman and his advisers have deliberately pushed a false dichotomy of "Drop the bomb - and then drop a second bomb", versus "Invade the Home Islands." [1]
The reality was that there was a third option available to the US - a conditional Japanese surrender. It chose to commit a war crime for political, not humanitarian reasons - and it never seriously entertained the alternative. Once it had the bomb - the debate was not whether it was going to use it, but where.
[1] http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2015/08/03/were-there-alternatives-to-the-atomic-bombings/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2015/08/03/were-there-alterna...
Some choice snippets:
"At the very least, waiting more than three days after Hiroshima might have been humane. Three days was barely enough time for the Japanese high command to verify that the weapon used was a nuclear bomb, much less assess its impact and make strategic sense of it. Doing so may have avoided the need for the second bombing run altogether."
"Two months before Hiroshima, scientists at the University of Chicago Metallurgical Laboratory, one of the key Manhattan Project facilities, authored a report arguing that the first use of an atomic bomb should not be on an inhabited city"
"But the initial target for the bomb, discussed in 1943 (long before it was ready) was the island of Truk (now called Chuuk), an ostensibly purely military target, the Japanese equivalent of Pearl Harbor."
"And, in fact, we do now know that the Soviet invasion may have weighed as heavily on the Japanese high command as did the atomic bombings, if not more so. So why didn’t Truman wait? The official reason given after the fact was that any delay whatsoever would be interpreted as wasting time, and American lives, once the atomic bomb was available. But it may also have been because Truman, and especially his Secretary of State, Byrnes, may have hoped that the war might have ended before the Soviets had entered."
- saiya-jin 9y agoWho cares about some conditional surrender? Japanese military were PURE, ABSOLUTE evil (there were many smaller Nankings happening all over east asia, they regarded everybody else as subhumans and treated them worse than animals). People hate nazis and for good reasons, but even if I take into account concentration camps they look like angels compared to actions of Japanese soldiers in whole east asia prior/during the war, and absolute obedience of orders issued, however immoral they were. Yeah, to me the biggest evil of WW II are Japanese, by huge, massive margins. I will respect that nation when they build memorials for millions of civilians they murdered one by one for no reason at all and apologize+compensate all countries they invaded. Just look at how they think of Koreans even now, which are more like brothers to them, but they consider them subpar humans in every aspect. If you have this kind of empire of evil, the last thing you want for them is to keep relatively intact after losing the war they started by attacking first in pretty scumbaggish way. No, you want to bring them to their knees, destroy old structures (ie emperor is god and his word is to be followed at all costs, we're not in ancient egypt and this logic had no place in 20th century). You want to somehow make sure that they won't rise in same way in 20 years, like germany did after WW I, with even worse consequences. Atomic bombs were horrible, we can discuss details about which target would be better (but small targets would probably make them surrender much later), but after all, Japan as a country brought it all upon themselves and this was, given available info the best solution, or to phrase it properly the least bad solution. I don't get this desperate sensationalist efforts of some people to undermine it. In same vein we can discuss why D-day was such a massacre and why they didn't disembark someplace less fortified and so on. Well it's easy to judge now with all info available, isn't it...
- valuearb 9y agoThe japanese were willing to surrender before the bomb, if allowed to keep all of the territories they had conquered. That's a far cry from the conditions we got or deserved.
- opo 9y ago>...The Japanese were ready and willing to surrender before the bombs dropped Some factions in the Japanese civilian government were willing to surrender with varying amounts of conditions. That doesn’t mean the “Japanese” were willing to surrender nor does it mean that these conditions would have been acceptable to the Allies. Even after 2 atomic bombs were dropped there was an attempted military coup to prevent the Emperor from surrendering. >...What they were not ready for, was an unconditional surrender. (And, in the end, they surrendered conditionally! No, they accepted the Potsdam declaration.