3 ms·
It's sort of criminal that they're even allowed to label bean juice as milk. Im not 100% convinced of the necessity of drinking milk or that height is particul
by empath75 9y ago
It's sort of criminal that they're even allowed to label bean juice as milk.
Im not 100% convinced of the necessity of drinking milk or that height is particularly a good proxy for health as a metric.
But vegans should be under no illusions that almond milk or soy milk is any kind of milk substitute. And if they're giving it to infants instead of breastfeeding or formula, it's borderline neglect.
I think that there a valid uses for them - soy milk is good for lower calorie lattes for example, and almond milk is delicious in oatmeal. But as a source of nutrition for growing children, they're pretty poor.
- moskie 9y ago> But vegans should be under no illusions that almond milk or soy milk is any kind of milk substitute. When it comes to feeding infants, sure, but my usage of soy milk as an adult is definitely as a substitute for milk. I use it in virtually all the places cow's milk is typically used: in my cereal, coffee, mixed with chocolate syrup, in most recipes that call for milk.... No need to get so up in arms about call things like soy milk a "milk" drink/substitute. In the vast majority of cases, it functions exactly the same.
- jonknee 9y agoIf you use tofu in place of beef it is not correct to call it "soy beef". Milk is a specific thing, no kind of milk comes from beans.
- colanderman 9y ago"Milk" has been a generic term ever since coconut milk has existed. Heck, Wiktionary even cites 14th and 15th century uses of the term "almond milk". [1] Not to mention "milk of magnesia", which isn't even a foodstuff. Just because you personally have not heard the non-dairy sense used until recently does not mean it is incorrect or should be "illegal" as the GP suggests. [1] https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/milk https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/milk
- greglindahl 9y agoHave you ever eaten in a Chinese vegetarian restaurant? They usually have fake meat of every kind, and they do call some kinds of it 'beef'.
- maxerickson 9y agoAnd if they're giving it to infants instead of breastfeeding or formula, it's borderline neglect. Nothing borderline about it. Babies still die of malnutrition in developed countries, when it happens it is often from vegan diets. I don't think that various vegetable derived products having "milk" in their names is the biggest part of the problem though.
- schoen 9y agoI don't think it's reasonable to say "often". It seems like known cases were heavily covered in the press and involved criminal prosecutions. From what I can see, it seems to have been running around one death per year in developed countries. I agree that it's clearly a life-threatening risk to give babies vegetable milk as a substitute for breastfeeding or formula.
- maxerickson 9y agoI said when it happens it is often from. The number of deaths from malnutrition in developed countries is also very low. The cases that don't have an underlying biological cause are going to come down to parental behavior and beliefs.
- schoen 9y agoI almost want to say that this is so rare as not to constitute a pattern, but on reflection I think you're right.
- racecliffer 9y agoFrom a culinary perspective, they're very similar. From a dietary perspective, adult humans don't have a dietary requirement of consuming dairy milk.
- greglindahl 9y agoAlmond milk has been called almond milk for at least a thousand years. Check out any cookbook for Catholics during Lent, or ask anyone who's into Renaissance-and-earlier-era cooking.
- ars 9y ago> And if they're giving it to infants instead of breastfeeding or formula, it's borderline neglect. ?? That's not what the article is about. They are talking about older children and comparing to cow milk, not formula.