3 ms·
Denial becomes a lot less plausible when you consider that Comey did not end the investigation, and was fired for it. But no, being vague in your implications
by mcphage 9y ago
Denial becomes a lot less plausible when you consider that Comey did not end the investigation, and was fired for it.
But no, being vague in your implications is not a get-out-of-jail-free card. Laws are evaluated by humans who are adept at seeing through bullshit, not computers.
- ethbro 9y agoAware of the complexities, but Clinton wasn't impeached by the Senate despite giving a knowingly false statement. While being vague is not a get out of jail free card, it's demonstrably easier to defend a vague statement than a concrete one.
- mcphage 9y ago> it's demonstrably easier to defend a vague statement than a concrete one It is, I agree. However, when the speaker—in this case Trump—behaves as if the coyly hinted at meaning was correct, then there's no room left to hide behind "oh but that's not what I meant". In Trump's statement was a strongly implied—yet unstated—threat: If you don't drop this investigation, then you'll lose your job. And what happened? When it became clear that Comey wasn't dropping the investigation, he lost his job. Trump has no wiggle room in claiming an alternate meaning, because the clearly implied meaning was what he did.