4 ms·
I think it depends entirely on your goal. If you are trying to understand the political repercussions of something, then I agree the rhetoric is what is import
by slg 9y ago
I think it depends entirely on your goal. If you are trying to understand the political repercussions of something, then I agree the rhetoric is what is important. However I think that is one of the biggest problems with the current political climate. We are always focusing on the political aftermath of these decisions and not the decisions themselves. If the goal is to actually understand the views of the general population then the more details and the less buzzwords the better.
An "Obamacare: repeal or keep?" poll question might help some politicians stay in office, but why should I care about that? It is the "Do you think it is fair that people with preexisting conditions pay higher insurance premiums?" poll questions that would actually lead to a law that is a better representation of the beliefs of the American people.
- throwawayjava 9y agoI agree with you about what should matter most. I'm just not convinced that it does matter most. > ...but why should I care about that? "Elections have consequences" and all that. > It is the "Do you think it is fair that people with preexisting conditions pay higher insurance premiums?" poll questions that would actually lead to a law that is a better representation of the beliefs of the American people. Maybe. But if identity politics are important enough to take priority over policy opinions, then knowing what policies people prefer doesn't really tell you anything. Which, I agree, is very unfortunate!
- slg 9y ago>"Elections have consequences" and all that. Except they don't. The person who occupies the 3rd Congressional seat in Georgia has no impact on my life. I shouldn't care about it and the media should spend less time focusing on it. What matters are the actual actions of Congress. Asking about "Obamacare" is a question about politics. Asking about "preexisting conditions" is a question about what actions Congress should take. >But if identity politics are important enough to take priority over policy opinions, then knowing what policies people prefer doesn't really tell you anything. It isn't identity politics. It is marketing. If a particular policy is popular when it is described but unpopular by name, the only thing it means is that the message about that policy has not been properly communicated.
- warkdarrior 9y agoHow's this for actionable polling? "Do you support Congress passing a law mandating you to pay for other people's preexisting conditions?"
- deong 9y agoThe basic problem is that people are not educated, sophisticated -- whatever term we choose, they don't possess enough of it to have any sort of nuanced understanding of an issue. Politicians simply noted that fact and use it to their advantage. You ask, "Do you think it's fair that people with preexisting conditions pay higher insurance premiums?", and I'll just ask, "Do you think it's fair that people should be forced to pay for the health care of others?" As long as I can ask the question to get the answer I want, polling is worthless for driving policy. What we'll end up with is the notion that Americans want free healthcare, free college, the best military, every veteran to have a $60k a year pension, and to save the planet, while they also want to pay no taxes and suffer no inconvenience to their daily lives. Good luck making that into policy.
- moduspol 9y ago> It is the "Do you think it is fair that people with preexisting conditions pay higher insurance premiums?" poll questions that would actually lead to a law that is a better representation of the beliefs of the American people. Even this is incredibly leading. It presumes that: * All preexisting conditions are equivalent, despite the fact that some are truly out of the person's control and others are the direct result of one's known actions * A lack of fairness implies it should be corrected * That correction should be done by legislation * That legislation should be at the federal level * The things that would need to be done as part of insuring people with preexisting conditions aren't relevant The "belief" of the American people that "it's not fair" is pointless. It can only be resolved with policy, and if that policy is disliked, it's intellectually dishonest to hide behind individual portions of the bill being popular out of context.
- saghm 9y ago"Nobody knew healthcare could be this complicated"
- slg 9y agoI'm not going to quibble over the exact wording I chose for my off the cuff example, but I will concede I could have phrased it better. >It can only be resolved with policy, and if that policy is disliked, it's intellectually dishonest to hide behind individual portions of the bill being popular out of context. But that is exactly my point. It isn't the policy that is disliked, it is the name. Many individual portions of the policy are liked. Those portions have to be paired with less favorable portions in order to create a functional law. Overall that collection of policies is generally liked. However if you throw the "Obamacare" label on it the popularity of the bill decreases compared to the same policies labeled as "The Affordable Care Act". The label is enough to cloud the the public's true feelings on the policy. Knowing the clouded opinions might help someone get elected but it isn't going to help them write a new healthcare bill that represents the will of the people.
- moduspol 9y ago> But that is exactly my point. It isn't the policy that is disliked, it is the name. It is the policy that is disliked. If you ask them how much they like higher premiums, they will tell you. You can't just ask about the positive goals and pretend that means they like it. The policy is the entire package, and it includes both. > However if you throw the "Obamacare" label on it the popularity of the bill decreases compared to the same policies labeled as "The Affordable Care Act". The label is enough to cloud the the public's true feelings on the policy. Obamacare is not a derogatory name. It's what it was called all throughout the debate and afterward by the news media and politicians. That some people react less negatively to a name that's less well-known and less widely-used doesn't justify what you're claiming. > Knowing the clouded opinions might help someone get elected but it isn't going to help them write a new healthcare bill that represents the will of the people. These aren't clouded opinions. They're reactions to actual liberal policy in action, and they're not positive. We don't need more affirming of things we already know. What is needed is some retrospection on what happens when tens of thousands of pages of legislation is passed because people like a few bullet points of it when taken out of context.
- bryondowd 9y agoIn a direct democracy, maybe this would matter, but we have a republic. Politicians aren't machines that would collate the beliefs of the American people and act accordingly if only they had the information. They are individuals with their own agendas and incentives. So, the only way to get a law passed is to prove that passing it will result in positive outcomes for enough politicians to get a passing vote, which unfortunately tends to boil down to how voters react to the sound bite version of the issue, because not enough voters to matter will actually be thinking about a fully informed (or even marginally informed) version of the issue when it comes to voting day. So, yeah, while there are some uses for polls to find out what the beliefs of the American people actually are, they are mostly academic, not practical. National elections are popularity contests and tribal pissing contests more than anything. Or maybe I'm just in a cynical mood.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]