5 ms·
I'm skeptical that most people have sufficient information upon which to make a decision. They just like the way it sounds. Here's the definition they provide
by empath75 9y ago
I'm skeptical that most people have sufficient information upon which to make a decision. They just like the way it sounds.
Here's the definition they provided:
> “Net neutrality is the principle that internet service providers providing consumer connection to the Internet should treat all data on the internet the same, not giving specific advantages or penalties in access by user, content, website, platform, or application.”
Doesn't this seem like it makes any sort of QOS prioritization impossible? What if an ISP wanted to prioritize all real time traffic (voip, videogames, streaming video)?
- zanny 9y ago> What if an ISP wanted to prioritize all real time traffic (voip, videogames, streaming video)? Then they should increase bandwidth in their backbone or reduce latency for everyone. All that prioritizing real time traffic means is the ISP gets to judge what is important on the wire and what isn't, rather than the consumer. I don't want my ISP going anywhere near my packets.- or anyone, really - except for whoever I am sending them to. All they need to know is the destination address and the fastest way to get it there. If there were competition in ISPs, you could reasonably argue that ISP's being given sovereignty over the traffic on their lines would be acceptable. But as long as Internet service in the US is the domain of very few regional monopolies, they have too much power over the consumer to be able to mess with such critical infrastructure for their own gain.
- sushisource 9y agoI mean sure, theoretically sounds good, in practice you would not want to give up the myriad QOS instruments that are already in place. They make your internet usage feel faster with very little downside. Absolutely, the Net Neutrality rules need to be in place, but your parent commentor is right when he says it's not going to be a trivial thing to define.
- jeeceebees 9y agoWhat kind of QOS adjustments would be made impossible by assuming the above definition of net neutrality? Genuinely curious.
- drdaeman 9y agoAnalyzing the traffic to optimize the service. - With p=0.86 this UDP stream looks like a VoIP traffic and the least latency route would be over this peer. - And this TCP connection is to the YouTube video servers. No matter what, it's better not route through this peer, because for only $deityName knows why but it doesn't work well and customers complain about random buffering. - And that is BitTorrent traffic - better feed that info_hash and so the locally-running cache would prefetch the data. Okay, that's probably not possible in the US, lol, but this simple trick significatly lowered upstream utilization, making network perform better for everyone. That's how it works in a "good ISP" scenario. There's a "bad ISP" scenario though. There, NN prevents those: - This is Netflix traffic and customer'd better pay for our cable if they want 4K. Shape this down to 5Mbps. Not like that customer has any choice of ISPs in their area. - That's VoIP and and user's better burn minutes on our telephony services. Add randomized 1-5% packet drop. - That's BitTorrent and we know it's only for pirates. Block the traffic, no Debian ISOs for you buddy. So, as far as I get it, NN is unnecessary or even harmful where there's a significant competition (like, no less than 4-5 different ISPs), and may be helpful in case of mono- and duopolies.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoAll of that is a terrible idea, as you still suddenly have idiosynratic behaviour of some traffic streams, with some VoIP protocols working on some providers, stuttering on others, what have you ... just an unreliable, undebuggable mess that makes innovation essentially impossible (because now you need to upgrade/reconfigure all ISPs' routers to introduce a new VoIP protocol, say ... which in practice means that you can't). If you want to do QoS, you have to do it using a standardized mechanism (such as the qos header in IP) and let the customer control which data streams they want prioritized.
- 9y ago
- maerF0x0 9y agoI've noticed a, seemingly disingenuous, pattern of naming things within the USA approximately opposite of the effect of the bill. Affordable healthcare makes it more expensive, Net neutrality is about allowing ISPs to censor and filter etc. Why is the above the case?
- libdong 9y agoWho has claimed that net neutrality is about allowing ISPs to censor and filter? Regarding the ACA, affordable and expensive aren't necessarily opposites. You could make something more expensive (but still affordable) for those who are well off, but more affordable for those who are poor, and claim a net increase in "affordableness". Anyway, the PATRIOT act seem like a slightly better example of a disingenuous name for a bill IMO.
- TallGuyShort 9y agoOne of the reasons I don't fully support it is I don't think we've actually seen the problem it's supposed to fix happen enough, that I'm a little more concerned about what happens if video streaming and similar traffic starts saturating more of the links. In that scenario I would like the ability (even if I had to pay for some of the less necessary privileges) for my work, communications, or perhaps more time-sensitive issues to take priority over lower-value entertainment, etc.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoBut that's completely besides the point. Nothing regarding net neutrality should prevent your ISP from prioritizing specific traffic on your link if you wish that they do so. And there should not even be a problem with charging you for the additional service. The only thing they can not do is to prioritize your aggregate traffic over a different customer's aggregate traffic on their backbone, or to force prioritization on your link, or to charge differently for different traffic on your link, every bit transmitted has the same price. If you think that being able to buy prioritization on the backbone would be a good idea, think again: If they sell you a gigabit pipe, and they sell your neighbour a gigabit pipe ... how could the solution to possible saturation of the aggregate uplink be anything but that they need to increase the uplink capacity in order to fulfill their contracts? It's obviously unacceptable to charge you more in order to reduce the quality of the service of your neighbour even more, isn't it? Or to let you decide that your work is more important than their entertainment? Either they have to invest in their infrastructure so they can actually deliver the service that they sold you, or they have to cancel the contracts/decrease the bandwidth of the links (and charge less accordingly).
- TallGuyShort 9y agoNo that's exactly how every popular attempt at explaining net neutrality I've seen explains it: net neutrality prevents your ISP from making one service artificially appear slower than another. If I pay Comcast for a certain speed I already expect that speed. I've never seen anyone discuss net neutrality the way you're describing it. I would consider your definition just part of tort law.
- Yen 9y agoThat definition disallows QoS based on the ISP knowing-what's-best-for-you I don't think it would preclude an ISP offering "we'll treat your packets either as high-bandwidth high-latency, or low-bandwidth low-latency, based on tags you set". Which, I think, is preferable anyway, because the user probably has a much better idea of whether they want a little bit of data, reliably fast (voip, video games), or a lot of data, whenever it arrives (netflix, downloads, etc.). If the ISP is trying to guess, based on destination IP, port, or packet inspection, they'll often get it wrong. Especially if the destination IP is a VPN, the port is non-standard, or the packet is encrypted. I also don't think it precludes an ISP offering better throughput or latency to a directly-connected customer who pays more.
- grahamburger 9y agoAs I understand you can do QoS based on service type but not for a specific entity. You can prioritize all VoIP to get consistent latency but not prioritize Skype over other providers, for example. If your pipes are not full QoS doesn't do anything anyway, so it is better to just have enough bandwidth that you don't need QoS.