4 ms·
I would like to know more about the person who thought they should 'steer' the elevator by pressing the button which could lead it to the person's floor for pic
by gojomo 16y ago
I would like to know more about the person who thought they should 'steer' the elevator by pressing the button which could lead it to the person's floor for pickup, and the specifics of the lobby where they were.
How old were they?
Why had they never observed, or been instructed by adults about, typical elevator operation?
Had they never seen an elevator, but had played video games? Was the display of the elevator's current floor close enough to the buttons, or perhaps stylized enough, to suggest it could or should be directly controlled like a video game character?
(Perhaps JGC was performing an experiment with a young child or recent immigrant?)
I think the traditional design was probably optimal at the time it was designed. As others have noted, a single call button adds unnecessary stops -- and at the worst times, when the elevator and lobby are most busy.
Many times there is no indicator of where a elevator car is. Or, in different buildings, variable numbers of cars, unrelated to the standard up/down buttons. So anyone with experience with a few different elevators will find interpreting from their location, rather than the elevator cars, the more consistent approach.
Apparently the state-of-the-art is to have buttons for every floor to be outside the car, in the lobby. Each person declares their destination with a press; as cars arrive they display or announce where they'll stop so the right people can board. But elevators are an old technology; so many buttons and such optimal grouping/scheduling were impractical when the current conventions arose.
- jgrahamc 16y agoLate 30s. Very educated British woman. Didn't ask why they didn't know this.
- gojomo 16y agoWow. With those demographics, I might have wondered if some sort of medically-triggered confusion had beset her. I would have expected such a person to have ridden elevators hundreds of times. Though I suppose if spent most of your life in a rural area, and only rode elevators occasionally with strangers, you might continue with such an initial misunderstanding indefinitely.
- petercooper 16y agoI share your confusion, but I think someone should have a rough idea of how an elevator works even after a few uses. That said.. I would have expected such a person to have ridden elevators hundreds of times. If she didn't travel much internationally, it's very easy to avoid or not come across elevators in the United Kingdom especially outside of London. I use an elevator perhaps a couple of times a month, nearly always in multistory car parks (which women, in particular, are often not keen to use in the UK, thanks to scare stories back in the 80s).
- ugh 16y ago“I would have expected such a person to have ridden elevators hundreds of times.“ If you don’t know which button you should press is it likely that you will figure it out on your own? Elevator behavior always seems very random to me, to the point where I think that it doesn’t really matter which button I press. I suppose that in the end, pressing the right button is more effective, but probably unnoticeably so.
- gojomo 16y agoMy reasoning is: the first time most people will encounter an elevator is as a child, with a parent or teacher, and the proper use will have been explained then. Failing that, they will often encounter elevators with other people present -- and observe what they tend to do. Hopefully, as either a child or adult, the novelty to the experience will cause them to pay close attention to figure out a new thing. Failing that, they will reason it out or experiment on their own. They are aided in the 'right' conclusion by several factors. First, many elevators don't show where the car or cars are, so there's no chance you'd have to guide them to your floor -- you don't have the information to do so. Requesting a desired direction from your current position is the only sensible interpretation. If you encounter a mix of elevators, some with car indicators and some without, but all with the exact same up/down buttons, you would have to strain to believe that you must consult an indicator that is not always present before choosing the right button. Second, at least in buildings (as opposed to car parks), most elevator trips begin on a ground floor that may only have an up button. No matter how vivid the car-level indicator, or how closely positioned to the button, it's hard to interpret that single up button as a command to move the elevator up from its current level (as opposed to calling it for an up trip). Finally, if you have the 'wrong' model in your head, and encounter elevators more than a handful of times, there will be a lot of hints that your presses have been counterproductive. Empty and full elevators going the wrong direction will stop on your floor, and then the call-light on the button you pressed will go off. Only sometimes (when there's not a pending call past you) will pressing the alternate button then reverse the elevator. Altogether, that's why I think this person must have had only a handful of experiences with elevators, or some very uniquely impaired (and possibly even recently damaged) way of learning about the world. Perhaps it's a dyslexia-like difficulty understanding causal sequences of events or modeling non-human systems. (I'd hope it was offset with talents in other areas, such as artistry or empathy.)
- URSpider94 16y agoApparently the state-of-the-art is to have buttons for every floor to be outside the car, in the lobby. Each person declares their destination with a press; as cars arrive they display or announce where they'll stop so the right people can board. But elevators are an old technology; so many buttons and such optimal grouping/scheduling were impractical when the current conventions arose. I've been in an office building in New York that uses this system, it's supposedly very efficient in both time and energy, as it should be. BUT, they have had to station an attendant in the lobby to basically operate the system for visitors, since it's just too obtuse for the average elevator passenger.
- ivenkys 16y ago"Apparently the state-of-the-art is to have buttons for every floor to be outside the car, in the lobby." - Not sure if this is state-of-the-art but i used such a system in Singapore 10-12 years ago and it works very well. The only flaw is the lone-ranger problem who has to go to a floor no one else has to. In peak hours, such a person may/will have to wait for a much longer-than-usual amount of time.
- ahoyhere 16y agoAgreed. There are many ways to improve an elevator in objective and perceptual ways... and what the author proposes is definitely not one of them.