6 ms·
What strikes me as odd given the USA's reputation as the home of the self made millionaire that the taxation of employee options is so broken. Treating options
by walshemj 9y ago
What strikes me as odd given the USA's reputation as the home of the self made millionaire that the taxation of employee options is so broken.
Treating options on shares as Income when they are not is just stupid options are a high risk instrument that well be worth nothing as opposed to a higher sallery.
Why is there not a PAC made up of tech industry employees lobbying for reform of Federal and state laws and arguable tech employers should be doing this.
And I should point out that politicaly I am on the left here compared to 95% f the average HN reader.
- richardwhiuk 9y agoThe alternative is that the tax is entirely on exercise of the option.
- walshemj 9y agosurly on the liquidity event when you exercise the options with out selling you have not received any income or CGT yet. What tax CGT or Income and in the UK an approved scheme is tax fee in effect - this is to encourage employees share ownership
- URSpider94 9y agoIt IS entirely on the exercise of the option. Granting and vesting of ISO's are not taxable events. Exercise of ISO's is taxable under the AMT rules, but only if you are above the AMT threshold (admittedly, this is true for a lot of people) If you're not hitting the AMT threshold, then you only pay tax when you sell the resulting shares.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoWouldn't another alternative be for the tax to be entirely when the underlying stock is sold?
- URSpider94 9y agoIf you are arguing that grants of options shouldn't be taxed -- they are not. If you are arguing that the eventual income from ISO's shouldn't be taxed -- that would be a very odd position, since pretty much every form of income out there in the world is taxed, even illegal income. I can't think of any other income category that is un-taxed under USA tax laws, with the exception of government bonds.
- walshemj 9y agoWe are talking about capital gains and not income most companies we are talking about don't pay dividends.
- URSpider94 9y agoCapital gains are considered "taxable income" by the IRS. I'm fully aware that the profit from ISO's is from cap gains, not dividends. Source: http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/how-are-capital-gains-taxed http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/how-are-capital...
- deathanatos 9y agoExercising of options is taxed, which is what I interpreted the OP to be talking about. From the employee's perspective, it seems ridiculous: I'm exercising an option in hopes of future payout, but right now, it's worth literally $0 — I can't convert it to cash — but the government taxes it at >$0 nonetheless.
- nemo44x 9y agoOptions are not taxed until you exercise them. At that point they become an asset that contains "value" but until you exercise the option to purchase stock it is simply only the right but not the obligation to purchase stock at a particular price. When issued options you don't have to exercise them and if you don't you do not pay taxes until you decide to. Often companies offer the ability to "early exercise" options which means you buy them before they have vested and file with the IRS that you have done this. The reason you might do this is because the strike price of your options will likely be the same as "fair market value" of the stock. This means that when you buy them you do not pay any taxes since the difference is 0. If you wait and exercise your options then you pay tax on the difference between the "fair market value" and your option strike price. This is taxed as a short term capital gain. However, you now hold the equity and if you sell it 1 year or later you pay a long term capital gain which is generally advantageous. This gain is the price you sell minus the value at the time you purchased. Often, for people issued options they will exercise and sell immediately when/if the company goes public and they can sell. You keep the difference between what you sold them and what your strike is and you pay taxes on that profit. The biggest issues are when you want to leave a company but have not bought your options. These are golden handcuffs and it's a decision you need to make if you want to buy them. For a company that is looking good you can often get a loan to buy them. But now you're invested in an illiquid investment of which you can't possibly know the real value. That's a big risk with potentially a large payout.
- imh 9y ago>Options are not taxed until you exercise them. At that point they become an asset that contains "value"... The assertion that they then contain value is the contentious point. To the IRS it is defined to have value. To me, it has no more value than the option, because there's no more market for those shares than there is for the options themselves. "Fair market value" is weird when there's no market.
- nemo44x 9y agoHence why I said "value" and not value.