6 ms·
If you watch the rest of the video you will find the moderator imposes himself and cuts off the panellists and talks over them multiple times, seemingly regardl
by andrepd 9y ago
If you watch the rest of the video you will find the moderator imposes himself and cuts off the panellists and talks over them multiple times, seemingly regardless of gender. This makes me strongly inclined to believe that this incident had nothing to do with sexism, but rather with the annoyingly dominant and imposing personality of the moderator.
Maybe you think otherwise. Why would you say this incident is a "painfully frustrating reminder that women get talked over by men"? Surely you can't construe this incident to mean that when all panellists alike suffered the same treatment? What's your take?
- jshelly 9y agoLink to video? EDIT: Found it at the bottom...
- k__ 9y agoWhere?
- funnyfacts365 9y agoTFA
- suby 9y agoI read the facebook post and did not see a video link anywhere. I came to the comments to find the video. You could have actually been helpful and linked to the video. For anyone interested, the link is here. http://www.worldsciencefestival.com/programs/big-universe-bigger-questions/ http://www.worldsciencefestival.com/programs/big-universe-bi... edit: The moment happens at roughly 1 hour 7 minutes in.
- Cyphase 9y agoIt's at 1:07:41 in the video linked in the parent[1], but start at 1:03:50 to get the full context (short of watching the whole video). Also, in case someone does a Ctrl+F for "timestamp", there you go. [1] http://www.worldsciencefestival.com/programs/big-universe-bigger-questions/ http://www.worldsciencefestival.com/programs/big-universe-bi...
- ma2rten 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Er7qPv8jsZo#t=1h1m53s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Er7qPv8jsZo#t=1h1m53s
- croon 9y ago> If you watch the rest of the video you will find the moderator imposes himself and cuts off the panellists and talks over them multiple times, seemingly regardless of gender. Honest question: Did you watch the rest of the video? I did and completely disagree with your assessment.
- alttab 9y agoIf you both watched it, we could simply count the number of interruptions and see if she was interrupted statistically significantly more. There's an objective answer and opinions don't really count here.
- andrepd 9y agoTo be completely fair, it's not so simple. Opinions may differ in what constitutes an interruption, what's the threshold for considering someone tried to speak up and was cut off, about whether the attitude towards women was more forceful than towards men, etc. It's difficult to quantify these things.
- UncleMeat 9y ago"Statistically significantly" is not a magic word. It has no application when you sample the entire population (in this case, the entire video).
- smartlysmart 9y agoI watched much of the video and he does interrupt other panelists frequently. He also gives a less obtuse lead-in and allows her to speak uninterrupted at around 27 minutes. Following that, other panelists acknowledge the importance of her statements. Also, the panelist herself wrote that she thought it funny that the guy was asking and answering a question at the same time; she didn't feel she was targeted or silenced during the event. This guy just likes to dominate conversations and lacks self/social awareness. I bet he's like that all the time. Does he do it more to the woman in the video? Yeah, you might have a good argument that he does. But I've met plenty of these people in management-level meetings and they do it to everybody; it's soooo annoying. Very hard to assert yourself without making things awkward. Impossible to assert yourself when it's a woman who's overriding everyone else. The solution is usually to appoint a meeting moderator that everyone knows to be fair beforehand (obviously, this isn't always viable), but we found it shortened up our medical practice meetings quite a bit. The guy who likes to hear himself talk still goes overboard from time to time, but we have a third-party moderator who can cut him off without worrying about upsetting a supervisor.
- vertex-four 9y agoNote that behaviours which tend to have disproportionate impact on one gender over another are still sexist, and women often have difficulty interrupting in the way that the men here did.
- ebfd 9y ago>Behaviours which tend to have disproportionate impact on one gender over another This encompasses nearly every behavior we engage in- almost nothing has a 50/50 gender split. Getting into arguments with people on Hacker News, to choose an example, has a disproportionate impact on men. Is this sexist?
- turc1656 9y agoNonsense. By your statement, the reason it disproportionately impacts women is not because of some rudimentary, fundamental reason but rather because they fail to react the same way the men did and speak up. That lies 100% on the women. In fact what YOU wrote is actually sexist, since it suggests that the corrective action would be to act differently toward her, but not the men. Perhaps you might merely argue that he should not behave that way to anyone simply because of the disproportionate impact. But even if that's the case, you are still saying that women are incapable of speaking up for themselves the way the men did to gain their voice back from the moderator. How is either of those scenarios not sexist on your part?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> By your statement, the reason it disproportionately impacts women is not because of some rudimentary, fundamental reason but rather because they fail to react the same way the men did and speak up. That lies 100% on the women. No, the effects of deliberate, targeted differences in socialization by gender aren't the fault of the people experiencing adverse impacts because of the intersection of those with social structures that respond better to people socialized in the manner which is targeted at the other gender. > In fact what YOU wrote is actually sexist, since it suggests that the corrective action would be to act differently toward her, but not the men. It's not sexist to recognize that the consequences of past sexism may require corrective action that is sensitive to the gender-differentiated effects of that past sexism.