51 ms·
Maybe you would like to address the substance of the comment, otherwise your only argument is "you are arguing and you shouldn't".
by andrepd 9y ago
Maybe you would like to address the substance of the comment, otherwise your only argument is "you are arguing and you shouldn't".
- throwaway91111 9y agoSubstance? What does the comment bring up worth discussing? It's not clear the comment has any empathy for anyone involved but the asshole. What value could anyone gain from the comment? The game of "is it bigotry or just a terrible person" is never a fun game and leaves everyone bitter. One day it'll be nice to look at grey area and have the discussion center around what i'm looking at, rather than the fact it's grey. Finally, this particular problem—interrupting—tends to be a major issue for SV. It may not always be sexist, but i do think women experience this disproportionately. The above comment managed to avoid any recognition of this.
- andrepd 9y agoThe comment does make a point of substance. It argues that talking over other people isn't a symptom of sexism, and cites as evidence the fact than man and women alike are talked over by more confident extroverts, and thus that it is yes a problem but no not stemming from sexism. What it does not make is a point of substance with which you agree, or rather, which does not immediately stroke your pre-existing conceptions. The fact that in your mind this is immediately equated with "lack of substance" is deeply troubling, especially because I fear it's becoming an increasingly common way to think. If I may I would suggest that you consider the theses and arguments presented by others at face value and consider them logically and rationally for what they are, and to do it before you analyse them in the framework of your pre-existing beliefs.
- obstacle1 9y ago> i do think women experience this disproportionately. The above comment managed to avoid any recognition of this. Why would I recognize something that isn't an established fact, but your personal belief? That isn't reasoned debate, it's you wanting us to pander to your narcissism.