3 ms·
All modern browsers support JS While that's true it's not reasonable to assume the user has JS enabled. Ad-blocking plugins that also block JS are increasingly
by onion2k 9y ago
All modern browsers support JS
While that's true it's not reasonable to assume the user has JS enabled. Ad-blocking plugins that also block JS are increasingly common.
and it's no longer reasonable to expect all websites to work very well without it.
The question should be "what does work very well" actually mean?
For a closed application that requires the user to log in I don't really care. Users won't use the app if it doesn't work for them, so it's entirely up the developers to build something the users want. Talking about web applications is silly. For a public-facing website though, I would expect it to at least work without JS even if it doesn't necessarily present as good an experience as it would with JS (which is nothing new, it's just progressive enhancement). The problem is web sites that present an essentially a meaningless page (blank, no content, populated but broken, etc) to users who have JS disabled. That's where work needs to be done.
- HappyTypist 9y ago> That's where work needs to be done. Why? Instead of building for 0.5% of users that can just enable JavaScript, why shouldn't I invest the time into building a new feature, writing more unit tests, or writing an app for Windows Phone?
- onion2k 9y agoFor the same reason we build features in websites that work for blind people (aria tags everywhere), disabled people (accessible buttons), people who speak different languages (i18n), VIM users (GMail keyboard shortcuts), etc. We choose who we build for. If you want to ignore 0.5% of your users then that's your choice, but don't complain when you submit something to HN and get a page of responses saying it doesn't work.
- emodendroket 9y agoHumoring people who want to turn off JS is not really on the same level as making the page work for people with disabilities.
- emodendroket 9y ago> While that's true it's not reasonable to assume the user has JS enabled. Ad-blocking plugins that also block JS are increasingly common. What percentage of users do you think block JavaScript? I'd be utterly shocked if it were more than one or two percent.