4 ms·
Well, you're comparing against a 5 year old machine. What point does this make? It's about as meaningful as saying my smartphone has reached parity with a Cray
by andrepd 9y ago
Well, you're comparing against a 5 year old machine. What point does this make? It's about as meaningful as saying my smartphone has reached parity with a Cray supercomputer (but a 20 year old one).
- thesephist 9y agoI would say an important point of note is that a lot of people who would consider themselves power users still use Intel chips from the early 2010's. Coming from someone who's using a Sandy Bridge i7.
- qubex 9y agoLike you I'm using a quand-core 'Server' Mac Mini from 2012 with a Sandy Bridge processor. What exactly do you make of this? That we are not power users? (Not being sarcastic or anything like that, I've been thinking along these same lines for a while, but I cannot quite put my finger on it.)
- ido 9y agoThat desktop CPU performance gains have slowed.
- blackflame7000 9y agoWell the power wall has kind of set an upper bound on clock speed. (although kaby lakes can do 5GHz no problem which is pretty impressive) So until a fundamental breakthrough in heat extraction happens, were kinda left with only power efficiency and parallelism as ways to increase performance (which desktops have done). Mores law has still more or less held true thus far. I think ARM just had a long way to catch up but it will eventually hit physical barriers at some point and performance increases will slow.
- IBM 9y agoYou don't think it's a little impressive that a mobile SoC in a tablet (that is constrained by power and physical space) is matching the performance of an i7 in an iMac that has the benefits of sitting on your desk plugged into power all day, isn't constrained by size, and has significant active cooling?
- danmaz74 9y agoMobile CPUs have many constrains to adapt to, but "size" shouldn't really be one of them.
- simias 9y agoIt makes a big difference for cooling though.
- danmaz74 9y agoAs in: the bigger, the better?? :)
- blackflame7000 9y agoI'm curious why you say that. Circuit board real estate seems to be a precious commodity especially in iphones. What do you mean by size?
- danmaz74 9y agoI was answering about the CPU (or SoC)
- dzdt 9y agoHuh? Size of the system is one of the defining constraints of "mobile". I guess you are saying the chip is small enough you don't think size of the CPU will be the limiting factor for setting the size of the system? True that other components are larger, but not true that the CPU is insignificant!
- 9y ago
- spiderfarmer 9y agoWell for one it shows the progress made in 5 years time. And a lot of desktop PC's nowadays are 5 years old or even older.
- martamoreno 9y agoIt makes the point of a click-bait headline :). Try running a latest gen Intel i7 against the latest ARM chip on desktop workloads (high-end gaming, databases, compilers, video encoding, AI computation, etc.) and we will see a bit of a different picture. And while these small devices do an amazing job, one should never forget that they are also extremely optimized for efficiency. Intel Desktop CPUs have different goals and you need to take the whole picture into account at which point you will see that comparing Intel & ARM is like comparing apples and bananas.
- gutnor 9y ago> desktop workloads (high-end gaming, databases, compilers, video encoding, AI computation, etc.) and we will see a bit of a different picture. Well that still matters. A lot of desktop user even in enterprise are not doing any of that and 5 year old machine is perfectly good enough. We are talking 10's of thousands of desktop in each large company have become matched in power by the latest smartphone and tablet. So that could mean the end of the general user gravy train for Intel and AMD. That could mean your next MBP is going to cost even more than the next best tablet for a smaller but still significant enough performance difference.
- asendra 9y agoYou might prefer this one, as I find it much more relevant. http://browser.geekbench.com/v4/cpu/compare/3036382?baseline=2922710 http://browser.geekbench.com/v4/cpu/compare/3036382?baseline... That is a Core-i5 Kaby Lake Y. Same approximately TDP, both fanless. Thats the CPU in the new Kaby Lake MacBooks that Apple just upgraded too. It still loses to the A10X it seems in multicore, very similar single core performance.
- cptskippy 9y agoYou're right that it is an unfair comparison to the state-of-the-art. And a lot of people are considering upgrading their older systems not because those systems are slow or under-performing but because of other factors like portability, dying batteries, and failing hardware. I think their point is that an iPad can be a suitable replacement for a lot of people not necessarily looking for an upgrade. My mom has a behemoth of a Dell laptop from 7 or 8 years ago. It's an i7 with 8GB of RAM and if I dropped an SSD in it for her then it would hum along just fine. It has performance parity with my maxed out Yoga 2 from a couple years back. She's looking to upgrade it not due to performance but because it's heavy, the battery is dead and a replacement is $200, and she want's a 10-key. My point is that performance is no longer the driving force compelling people to upgrade.
- spronkey 9y agoWell, it is somewhat on iOS because somehow Apple's software gets extremely heavy. Wirth's law or something. The iPad 2 used to feel pretty damn speedy, now it's an absolute dog.
- cptskippy 9y agoDefinitely and I think that trend will continue as the platform matures into something approaching feature parity with a desktop operating system. Hopefully that won't actually happen. Apple and Google are putting a great deal of thought into the APIs and features they're implementing on iOS and Android with much consideration to factors such as battery use and performance. That being said, the latest versions of Google's apps have really kneecapped the Nexus 4 which I've used as my daily driver since 2012. Sadly I might just have to upgrade.
- saturdaysaint 9y agoThat reference i7 is significantly faster than the main PC of %95+ of my friends/relatives. Then again, the vast majority of people need a proper home PC for little more than the occasional word processing task, so this really is getting pretty academic until an iPad is at least interesting to musicians, video editors or hardcore gamers.
- bluedino 9y agoI think it's more impressive to compare a phone with a 20 year old Silicon Graphics workstation. The OpenGL performance obliterates it.
- cwyers 9y agoYou don't think that a battery-powered pocket computer with as much computing power as a 1997 Cray is meaningful?
- slededit 9y agoI think it's more meaningful that this iPad comparison is surprising. Back in the full throes of Moore's law this would be expected. It really shows we're in a new era of sub exponential improvement.