3 ms·
The Observer has an article about this: http://observer.com/2017/06/sexism-science-facebook-mansplaining/ http://observer.com/2017/06/sexism-science-facebook-ma
by danso 9y ago
The Observer has an article about this: http://observer.com/2017/06/sexism-science-facebook-mansplaining/ http://observer.com/2017/06/sexism-science-facebook-mansplai...
The video of the event is here: http://www.worldsciencefestival.com/programs/big-universe-bigger-questions/ http://www.worldsciencefestival.com/programs/big-universe-bi...
edit: Youtube version, at the 1:02 mark where people apparently were getting irritated: https://youtu.be/Er7qPv8jsZo?t=1h1m55s https://youtu.be/Er7qPv8jsZo?t=1h1m55s
- nailer 9y ago1:05:39 Nerds do this a lot. It's annoying AF. I've had conversations about topics like zopfli or 'HTTPS in the 90s' where I was sure I was right (and I was) but the other person was so confident and loud I genuinely wondered if I was missing something.
- accountyaccount 9y agogaslighting in a nutshell
- nervousvarun 9y ago"Nerds do this a lot." Agreed but we can be less specific here...human males do this a lot.
- iiv 9y agoWe can be even less specific: humans do this a lot.
- pxm 9y agoAnd the "let her speak please" happens just after 1:05: https://youtu.be/Er7qPv8jsZo?t=3928 https://youtu.be/Er7qPv8jsZo?t=3928
- curiousgal 9y agoA Youtube comment: He spends 0:40 asking her the first question. He continues talking when she tries to speak once. She talks for 0:30 He redirects her from her answer and tries to clarify what he wants to know for 0:55 She talks for 1:00 answering this question He begins clarifying/providing an example of what she is saying for 0:20, continuing to talk when she tries to speak once. It is during this interruption that "let her speak please" is shouted (1:05:40). It's clear that he was quite excited about the ideas and some of the ways he wanted to explain them and examples he wanted to give. It's not clear that there was no subconscious bias on his part in the way he went about it.
- evgen 9y agoContrast this to Holt's behavior for the rest of the video when interacting with the men on the panel and it is quite clear that his bias was not subconscious, but rather that he is just an asshole.
- d3ad1ysp0rk 9y agoI have not watched the full video, are you saying he was an ass to everyone, or he only acted that way to her, and thus any sexism was not subconscious but intended?
- croon 9y ago>He spends 0:40 asking her the first question. He continues talking when she tries to speak once. >She talks for 0:30 >He redirects her from her answer and tries to clarify what he wants to know for 0:55 >She talks for 1:00 answering this question > He begins clarifying/providing an example of what she is saying for 0:20, continuing to talk when she tries to speak once. It is during this interruption that "let her speak please" is shouted (1:05:40). This makes it sound like he only interrupts her twice, while my count is up to eight at this point. He's already interrupted her mid-speach three times, and she's trying to get back air time five times after 1:03:25 when he's interrupted her. And it's the same after 1:05:25 when he interrupts her yet again. > It's clear that he was quite excited about the ideas and some of the ways he wanted to explain them and examples he wanted to give. It's not clear that there was no subconscious bias on his part in the way he went about it. I honestly don't think it's nefarious, but what I do think is fairly blatant is that it's a case of speaking for the woman, which is text book sexism. If I can read more between the lines than perhaps is there, I think he believes he's doing her a favor. While clearly wrong, I think this is a/the main component of sexism. Which could also explain people (men) not seeing it as a problem because it's habitual and not stemming from ill-will.