4 ms·
Neutrino discovery–a step closer to finding charge-parity violation
- qubex 9y ago"Effect not big enough" implies a judgement about how much matter/antimatter was available to begin with... a tiny effect is entirely sufficient to produce the observable universe if one purports to begin with a truly colossal initial amount of matter/antimatter.
- nimih 9y agoSince matter-antimatter annihilation produces radiation, what prevents us from estimating the size of the effect by measuring the background radiation of the universe and comparing it to the amount of observable matter?
- qubex 9y agoI presume the volume of the Universe. We can measure average density of residual radiation but getting the total value of energy requires multiplying by volume. Much of the universe's volume may be hidden behind a cosmological horizon (basically, the idea that as the universe's rate of expansion accelerates the greater the distance from us (Hubble's constant), eventually the rate of expansion exceeds the c and thus light from that part of the universe can never reach us, making it unobservable).
- frumiousirc 9y agoAre you referring to Hartz's statement? If so the statement refers to the measured effect in the experiment not the consequence of CP symmetry violation on the makeup of the universe. He means that if the CP phase angle is far enough away from zero or pi (his "luck") so that it will modify the amount of electron neutrino appearance beyond what is expected given the theta13 measurement from Daya Bay strongly enough that this deviation will be statistically significant. His claim is that, with this luck, even by 2026 the significance of the deviation will be only 3 sigma. This is level is conventionally not enough to claim discovery of non-zero CP phase. Around that same time, DUNE will have begun operations. That experiment is expected to reach the 5 sigma discovery level.
- gorhill 9y ago> implies that matter—including galaxies, stars, and even humans—should have been annihilated by the equal amounts of anti-matter. That is an odd sentence: "Even humans" after enumerating "galaxies, stars".
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoStupid question: Is neutrino oscillation deterministically sequential? That is, does an electron neutrino always turn into a muon neutrino, which then always turns into a tau neutrino, which then always turns into an electron neutrino (or the reverse order)? Or does an electron neutrino sometimes turn into a muon neutrino, and sometimes into a tau neutrino? If it's sequential, and if the antineutrino sequences in the opposite order, this effect could be explained just by the distance of the beam run being a fraction of the oscillation distance such that it's hard to get anti electron neutrinos, because at that distance, you're getting anti tau neutrinos instead.
- frumiousirc 9y agoA neutrino is born in a weak eigen state (e,mu,tau) and propagates as a mass eigen state (m1,m2,m3). The two bases are related by a rotation matrix of three angles and three phases of which one, the CP violation phase, can in principle be measured with long baseline neutrino experiments. The oscillation happens because each mass state propagates at a different frequency. So while a numu starts out with some fraction of m1, m2 and m3 states, it soon becomes a different mixture which is neither nue, numu nor nutau. Instead, when the neutrino interacts, it does so with some admixture probability of doing so in the form of each possible flavor.
- qubex 9y agoSo it's basically a Markov Chain kind of process, but on continuum of time rather than in discrete steps?
- frumiousirc 9y agoI guess you could couch the concept in this way but I have not ran across this approach to do calculations. In vacuum the oscillation probability (ie, the vector holding probability amplitude saying how much of "e-ness", "mu-ness" and "tau-ness" the neutrino has over time) is analytic and almost trivial to apply. In the presence of matter, forward elastic interactions with electrons in the matter can "pop" or "reset" the neutrino back to a nue weak eigenstate. This is the so-called "matter effect". If the density is constant one can rewrite the oscillation probability formula into a form that is the same as the vacuum one. So, again, easy to calculate. When going through variable matter densities one must, to be proper, solve a differential equation. Computationally, this is done by stepping the equation, eg with Runge-Kutta. Happily for us humans doing experiments at home, if the matter in question is the Earth then the fact that its matter density is close to uniform in bands (crust, mantle, core) one can do a step-wise constant density approximation that's pretty close to a full solution and much faster.