3 ms·
I suspect in context that's not a fair question, because students are probably be expecting a technical definition of no solution - maybe imaginary roots, maybe
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
I suspect in context that's not a fair question, because students are probably be expecting a technical definition of no solution - maybe imaginary roots, maybe something else - instead of a much simpler inconsistent statement.
Those two answers live in different conceptual categories, and most math lessons and problems live exclusively in one category and not the other.
This is related to Force Concepts because physics-as-math is taught as a series of algebra problems with a rather distant relationship to lived experience rather than the other way around.
Teaching physics as experience is harder than it looks. When I learned physics the course really tried to emphasise experience, but it did it in a stylised and abstract way with canned "experiments" using special equipment. This actually made it feel more distant and uninvolving, not less.
I suspect to do a better job you have to get out the classroom. E.g. introduce force, momentum, and acceleration to kids on bikes and skateboards, not with wooden trolleys on ramps.
- yequalsx 9y agoIt's a fair question in that a student's inability to give an example of an equation that has no solution indicates that we aren't really teaching students what an equation is/means. If one can't instantly give an example of an equation with no solution then they don't really understand what an equation is. Which means something is wrong with our teaching.