8 ms·
Traffic Wouldn’t Jam If Drivers Behaved Like Ants (2016)
- gerbilly 9y agoThe problem is that what is most efficient for getting a car from point a to b is not what is best for society overall. There are many articles online where people on residential streets got flooded with traffic because of apps like waze.[1] In the valley we only seem good at solving single isolated problems, and we are remarkably tone deaf to the effects these 'disruptions' have on the rest of society. 1. http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/shortcut-app-waze-1.3463004 http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/shortcut-app-waze-1.346300...
- mhroth 9y ago> In the valley we only seem good at solving single isolated problems... I'd suggest that's precisely because that's how engineers are taught to solve problems (and not just in the valley). Reduce a problem to it's simplest representation (by abstracting everything else away) and solve.
- robbrown451 9y agoA good argument can be made that using the residential streets is best for "society overall." The amount it disrupts those who live in the neighborhood could very well be outweighed by a large reduction of wasted time by all those stuck in a traffic jam.
- gerbilly 9y agoI'd argue the harm to a neighbourhood street far outweighs the needs of people in cars. It creates noise, discourages kids from playing outside, basically it decreases the quality of life generally when the street you live on becomes a river of traffic. Basically, this new innovation disrupts a balance that has been achieved incrementally over time. Go into any neighbourhood and talk to people and you will find that over time they have called the city councillor spoken to each other to come to an agreement about how their street is to be used, from parking issues, to street furniture to common access to some areas such as school parking lots off hours for example. Some of these agreements are formal, others informal and unspoken, but they always exist. I don't buy your argument that waze, by optimizing for a single variable, and which ignores all of these agreements between residents can be a greater benefit 'overall.' Also, by solving the congestion problem this way, they actually divert attention away from proper solutions being implemented at the city level.
- colefichter 9y agoThis idea that local residents are more entitled to the street becomes problematic, though. I live in a high-rise condo on a busy arterial road in the city centre. Should my enjoyment of the street override the needs of suburbanites to commute to work daily? I might think so, but somehow I don't think the suggestion that we should force thousands of people onto public transit or bicycles or whatever is going to wash. So then the question becomes, why are people in certain neighbourhoods entitled to things that people in other neighbourhoods clearly are not entitled to? If others can use "my" street when they please, why can't I do the same on "their" street?
- lightedman 9y agoStreets are made for driving upon. If people don't like people driving on their streets, they should vote to get rid of them. To boot, most people in those neighborhoods SHOULD be going to work anyways, so they shouldn't notice people going up and down their streets for the most part. We haven't hit Japan's retirement-age population level problem, yet.
- cmurf 9y agoThe solution to the neighborhood problem is to make it impossible for a car to use those roads as through streets. Basically you put up a bunch of bollards, so people can still walk and bike through a neighboorhood, but cars would only use the roads to get to a specific destination in that neighborhood. There's a word for this layout, I can't think of it - with the bollards in place, it turns the neighborhood into a maze of hard right and left turns. It's totally pointless to find a work around (in a car).
- sjwalter 9y agoPortland has aggressively pursued traffic calming and these traffic shaping measures you discuss. I first thought it was brutal and everyone drive really slow. On residential streets, both sides almost always allow forstreet parking, and so the roads don't allow for two way traffic. On other roads they narrow the lanes a lot, using bollards or increasing shoulder. They realize that traffic is a social engineering problem and not a highway engineering one. Now I love it. I drive slower when it makes sense to, and I do so because it's what feels right at the slice of road I'm on, not because of the sign that says the max speed.
- samstave 9y agoAnts are physically incapable of getting into "anto-accidents" though, and they are not physically relegated to a thin, poorly maintained, and often at times, poorly planned/engineered, two dimentional ribbon that does not have their best route at heart. Cars are only like ants in that they are discrete objects moving along set paths, but similarity in capability ends there. Every car has a completely different universe of goals, objectives, plans, destinations, etc from each other and they lack the ability to communicate, inform,or teach other cars anything. Further, ants do not posses the ability to get frustrated with heavy ant traffic triggering ant-rage, they simply re-route as required. Humans driving cars can act irrationally based on nearly infinite input possibilities... Autonomous vehicles driven by AI which mimics ant movement logic can do well for traffic, but so long as a human consciousness is directing the vehicle... not going to get better any time soon.
- cmurf 9y agoYeah, the maximum momentum of an ant is less than the speed at which suddenly stopping (i.e. impact with any other object) causes damage. An ant probably doesn't even have minor injuries in its normal operation, including any impacts with other ants or objects. Also, pedestrians and cyclists and motorcyclists aren't ants. Some other metaphor would apply to them, and they can be damaged by the "ant" (a car) a lot easier. But I think the most important difference is ants are cooperative rather than competitive; ants don't get pissed, whereas primates seem to require becoming irate occasionally even for no good reason.
- VLM 9y agoStreet automobiles are essentially limited to 1 dimensional ribbon not 2D. To get 2D you need wilderness and ATVs, or a horse. Also look at their performance stats, zero to 90% of top speed is a good fraction of a minute in my commuter car whereas for an ant its about a footstep ditto turning performance. A better analogy to ant behavior than car driving would be humans wandering about a park, perhaps one of the concerts in the park series that I attend. Or maybe humans wandering about a uni campus or around a sporting event. Or a riot. Many have commented on how well ants cooperate. Well, not all species cooperate across nests and some of the more predator like ants are kinda brutal to smaller insects. Likewise humans part of the same "family" like a large military convoy seem to cooperate reasonably well.
- CommieBobDole 9y agoAnd with well-designed self-driving cars, pretty soon they will.
- alextheparrot 9y agoAssuming each self-driving company doesn't implement adversarial behavior, only cooperating with their own kind. This would both help reinforce the benefits of operating at scale and give their vehicles faster than average speeds. Interesting times ahead once we transition to self-driving more fully.
- jklein11 9y agoI would imagine if car vendors were creating cars that intentionally cut off or slow down their competitors the regulators would step in and do what they do best... regulate.
- alextheparrot 9y agoSure, but let's say it would be globally optimal to slow down and let you in. You could imagine this only being done for cars of the same brand, which is different than explicitly attacking competitors. Regulation is likely that answer, but I have my doubts that "behaving like ants" will be the default behavior.
- nyxtom 9y agoAnts also climb over each other from time to time: something a car is not recommended to do.
- coldcode 9y agoWhat if ants drove cars, would they still avoid accidents? Or is the problem different at scale?
- cmurf 9y agoYeah but we aren't ants, we're primates. And primates are either equally competitive to cooperative or perhaps slightly more so competitive. Ants don't compete, they only cooperate.
- orliesaurus 9y agoThis article reminds me of: If my grandmother had wheels she would be a bike
- devrandomguy 9y agoAnts walk. They live near their necessities, and they move the entire colony/city, as a single unit, when the local economy goes bad. They only own what they can carry: their larvae and their next meal. Their payload ratio is legendary, but within the range of a bicycle + trailer. When there is a big problem, they physically band together to solve it. We have so much to learn from the ants, but 2 ton personal vehicles, four lane city roads and a 1-2 hour daily commute, are not a part of that picture.
- lisper 9y agoIt also helps if you're light enough to be able to collide without injury.
- dismantlethesun 9y agoSo maybe we should have bumper cars that only move 25 miles per hour, and never stop except at their destination? I could actually see that working in big cities.
- devrandomguy 9y agoLet's also reduce the mass of the vehicle, to a fraction of its payload. Then, let's have the user supply the energy from their own food supply. These improvements will also improve health, safety and space/cost/energy efficiency. https://imgur.com/gallery/DAijq#qcfLWFs https://imgur.com/gallery/DAijq#qcfLWFs Plastic safety bumper plates around the front seems like a good idea for this build. It might save a dog's life.
- moneytide1 9y ago"They only own what they can carry" Individual households in tightly packed neighborhoods EACH have garages full of items they only use a few times a year. Some may share, but communal living is hardly there. Then we need more jobs and more factories to replicate more of those same random items (ladders, wasp spray, yard tools, etc) so that they be stored away and not shared. Then there is more traffic for people to get to work where they participate in production that goes largely unused. The system has enabled far too much excess, and it's a collective educational issue.
- Evolved 9y agoThe problem isn't training people to behave like ants for efficiency reasons. That shouldn't be difficult. The problem is people not planning ahead which translates to slamming on the brakes to make a lane change to exit, not speeding up quickly enough to merge smoothly with traffic which translates to the braking shockwave effect on the cars behind them, and finally, people's self-serving attitudes that translate to cutting other people off/weaving in and out of lanes/not letting others merge/etc. TL;DR - This has been rehashed over and over but the same results are these: Ants do what is best for the colony. People do what is best for themselves.
- daxfohl 9y agoSure, but what is an ant going to do with the time it saves by cutting in line?
- mrfusion 9y agoAt some point all the cars physically don't fit on the road. (Especially keeping safe distances between them) At that point no behavior would eliminate traffic.
- pif 9y agoYes, in the example of ants and citronella, slower is better if you care about overall suffering. But faster is much better if you care about your suffering AND if you happen to quit the room before the jamming starts.
- Animats 9y agoAnts aren't big enough that inertia matters and have zero turning radius.
- nxsynonym 9y agoThe issue isn't that humans don't behave like ants. The issue is that we have an aversion to public/shared transportation and promote commuting as a given. Personal car culture needs to die for traffic to be reduced. For that to happen we need better transportation options for rural areas or more remote-work opportunities.
- bluGill 9y agoSounds good in theory, but there are limits to transit. You need a fairly high population density, and shared destinations. I have never worked in an office where the bus schedule allowed taking it - if I got the first by in and the last bus out I would have worked 7:45 - not a full 8 hour day before you consider a long lunch which is nice at times. Other offices the nearest bus stop was 3 miles away (along a route that was not walker friendly) Sure if you live in an apartment and work downtown public transit works great. However engineering companies tend to not be downtown because rent is so high.
- roughcoat 9y agoWhy do you assume people embrace "personal car culture" just because there's a lack of public transportation? People like having their own vehicles. It's freedom and independence. Even if I lived right on a bus line, and my workplace was on that same line, I would still drive or ride a motorcycle to work (or bike, if it was close enough I suppose). I got well over being on the bus's schedule by my senior year of high school and I have no interest in going back to that. I do absolutely agree we need more remote work options but that's up to employers, and they don't seem to like the idea much in general, so... not holding my breath.
- nxsynonym 9y ago> It's freedom and independence This is why I assume people embrace it. Is it really freedom and independence when 90% of your time spent in the car is in traffic to get to work and home? Freedom to me is not wasting 5-10 hours a week on getting to work, unpaid. Even if that means sacrificing my 'freedom' to drive around the countryside on weekends.
- mcrad 9y agoAnts drive manual transmissions and humans are getting cars that do more of the thinking for them(?)
- moneytide1 9y agoIf everyone started driving the moment they saw the light turn green, the collective traffic would move forward like a train. Granted, there needs to be a buffer zone between each car. But that zone often gets diminished because everyone wants to drive until they have to stop behind someone, rather than driving while looking ahead at the traffic sequence. The tortoise/hare metaphor is relevant here: sometimes slowing down without braking within a couple hundred yards of an intersection can get you through quicker (and use less energy). The idea is to avoid complete stops (sometimes inevitable). But there are attitudes in mental software that must be modified. "I'm in a hurry and I have to get there RIGHT NOW." "Everyone is in MY way." Individualism can be an inefficiency of the collective, and that will be a tough lesson to teach.
- roughcoat 9y ago'But there are attitudes in mental software that must be modified. "I'm in a hurry and I have to get there RIGHT NOW." "Everyone is in MY way." Individualism can be an inefficiency of the collective, and that will be a tough lesson to teach.' Indeed, all you need to do is rewrite human nature.
- undersuit 9y ago>If everyone started driving the moment they saw the light turn green, the collective traffic would move forward like a train. Yes and we would all have to maintain the same following distance all the time. I know there are some people that do like to follow me at the same distance regardless of whether I'm stopped or I'm going 65mph, but I am going to change my follow distance of cars in front of me depending on my driving speed. You can't have a seamless flow of traffic and a safe speed dependent following distances.
- kbutler 9y agoAnts only know about problems at the location that previous ants encountered them. That is, they can't look ahead to problems, and can only report when coming back over a path. A good example of this is the ant colony in a Polish nuclear bunker - the ants consistently fall into a ventilation pipe, because there's no pheromone warning signal of the dangerous fall. https://arstechnica.com/science/2016/09/bizarre-ant-colony-discovered-in-an-abandoned-polish-nuclear-weapons-bunker/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2016/09/bizarre-ant-colony-d... And as a side-effect, there's an ant colony with no queen, no larvae, no males, but a continual supply of adult workers.
- megamindbrian 9y agoSorry, when I drive I can only look out for myself.
- gmiller123456 9y ago"Behaved Like Ants". You mean walked everywhere? traveled at speeds that make collisions irrelevant? Without regard for trespassing? And be so immune to terrain barriers as to be able walk upside down? Ants really just have more choices for paths than they need.