4 ms·
How would the ToS apply to me if I never read them? If I write a script that downloads a page then I just downloaded it, never viewed it. If you put something
by alkonaut 9y ago
How would the ToS apply to me if I never read them? If I write a script that downloads a page then I just downloaded it, never viewed it.
If you put something on a http endpoint then I can download it. The terms of use of the material just regulates what I can do with it (republish it) but I can't possibly be forbidden to download it.
Anyone with a web server is of course free to just block my attempt to download their page, via a user-agent filer or any other method.
Edit: IANAL so I have zero idea how law is actually applied around the world. My view is just that "how on earth would it be possible to enforce a contract I never saw?".
My view of course also says that I'm free to download the data at
http://secret.somecompany.com:8081/secrets/data.bin http://secret.somecompany.com:8081/secrets/data.bin
Because they exposed it at a public http endpoint. I'm not so sure everyone (including somecompany) would agree with that. I think it's still perfectly reasonable that I'm allowed to do that - and that the restrictions that may apply to material I reach that way is only related to how I use it. Them posting it publicly on the internet (even if it's not linked) is the same as them having it on a billboard. I very much doubt that's how law works though.
- SimplyUnknown 9y agoIANAL, but it came up in a computing science/internet law course and in the Netherlands the current jurisprudence is that if you use (and continue to use) a service you are reasonably expected to read, understand, and adhere to the rules and conditions set by the service. In this case it thus doesn't whether or not you even saw the contract. You are bound by the ToS because it can be expected of you to search for it during continued use of the service.
- radmuzom 9y agoWhat happens if the TOS state that you are not allowed to use an ad-blocker while viewing their website? (Honest question)
- phn 9y agoDisclaimer: Pure conjecture. I'd say the TOS have to apply to the "service" you're consuming and not the website itself. Otherwise, what happens if you use just a text based browser? Or any other means not foreseen by the TOS? An ad-blocker would be just the same, it's something that your browser does.
- manigandham 9y agoIntent matters. Ad blockers are not the same as text based browsers.
- SimplyUnknown 9y agoThere is another side of ToS in the Netherlands that I haven't mentioned: The ToS has to be reasonable. There is a blacklist which cannot appear in a ToS under any circumstance because it is unreasonable to ask from users. For example, it is illegal for a company to require users to agree that when they buy goods from their shop they cannot return it whatsoever. There is also a gray list: these are conditions that companies may ask users to agree to if and only if they can prove it is reasonable condition. Notice that this a reverse of the burden of proof: normally a user has to prove that some terms in the ToS are unreasonable which is hard. Now the company has to prove that their terms are reasonable, which is also hard but better for the user. For example, it is illegal for companies to document the religious beliefs of a person BUT if this is a service for certain religious community (e.g. a forum for a church) then the term that they have to disclose their religious belief is reasonable (given that they don't share this information with anyone, of course). As for the ads, I don't know. It might be unreasonable to have users agree to subject themselves to third-party ads in order to use the service. But again, I am not a laywer.
- celticninja 9y agoHowever if a ToS attempts to remove enshrined rights or includes terms that are particularly onerous then this can invalidate the section or sometimes all of the ToS.
- JohnStrange 9y agoI think this differs from country to country then, because I'm pretty sure that in e.g. Germany a contract is not valid or enforcable without prior explicit agreement from both parties. In Germany most ToS and EULAs are void anyway, because they are not presented to the user or buyer before the purchase or start of the transaction. Also, if ToS contain a serious error, the whole ToS is invalid. However, in other countries such as the US contract law is totally different, so this does not generalize at all. Also, IANAL.
- whostolemyhat 9y agoWell, if you go to another country and you don't know the laws, you will still get arrested if you break the law.
- alkonaut 9y agoSure. That's the starting point in that case. The question is whether it can be seen as the starting assumption of someone making a http request that it's a "service" for which I'm assumed to find, read and follow the terms of? I'm guessing that varies and is decided by legal precedent only once it becomes an issue.
- vizeroth 9y agoMost countries apply intellectual property law to anything published on the internet. In other words, when it comes to something you pull down via http, you should assume that, if you attempt to republish it in any form, someone out there might decide that it's worth their time to use the court system to destroy you, so you should take the time to read the ToS.
- alkonaut 9y agoYes - Like I said I think it's perfectly find that the material I download from the internet has terms and laws associated with it. That is, what I do with what I download is subject to laws as soon as I e.g. try to publish it. But my point is this: what service have I used, and what terms can I be assumed to have agreed to if I do this > wget $random_url > /dev/null That's what web scraping is. What I do with the scraped material is something completely different.
- leobueno 9y agoIn that case, you are bound to these terms of service: https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2616 https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2616
- whiskers08xmt 9y agoThere was a case in Denmark, where a large real-estate agency, was forced to pay damages, caused by keeping a large real-estate listings website, from scraping their listings.
- jpalomaki 9y agoIf you publish the information, you might be breaking copyright rules. In some jurisdictions a collection of non-copyrighted items (like some catalog) might be protected by law.
- alkonaut 9y agoIf one wants to separate the question of scraping from the question of publishing something scraped (Which are entirely different things) then the thought experiment should be e.g. that you scrape a catalog and your page only displays "right now there are 10224 articles in the IKEA catalog" or "right now 1234 bikes are for sale on craigslist". That material has been reduced to a number - which certainly can't be considered protected as a material.
- garff 9y agoHej.. kan du lede mig til information omkring denne sag?
- DougWebb 9y agoMy view of course also says that I'm free to download the data at http://secret.somecompany.com:8081/secrets/data.bin http://secret.somecompany.com:8081/secrets/data.bin Because they exposed it at a public http endpoint. That's a poor example, because they most likely did not intend for that information to be publicly available, and just did a poor job securing it. Real-world analogy: if you happen to find someone's house with an unlocked front door, that does not give you permission to go looking around inside. It doesn't matter that you don't steal anything, and it doesn't matter that nobody knows you were there. You're still not allowed in and by going in you're breaking the law. If your example was for content that's retrieved as the default web page for a public DNS entry, or a page that's reachable by following links from the website's default page (including urls in meta, link, and script tags), then I think you're on solid standing as far as being allowed to retrieve the content. At that point, copyright laws and ToS govern what you're allowed to do with the content, with the safe assumption being that you're allowed to view it, but not republish it (except for fair-use excerpts.)
- alkonaut 9y agoI agree - I suppose it matters mostly how I find it. If I could be shown to have been poking around (walking up to every door to find an unlocked one) then certainly I have some dubious intent. The question is of course in what situations I should have known I stumbled across something they didn't intend for me to see. Googles scraper certainly walks up to every door, and then publishes what it finds. If you accidentally publish something and then google index it, and someone reaches it via google, it's hard to say it wasn't public.
- DougWebb 9y agoNo, that's not how Google's scraper works. They only follow publicly-exposed links, and they check your robots.txt file to see if they should ignore any links they might have come across that you intended to be private. If you accidentally put a link on your public website to content you didn't want public, and Google indexes it, then someone else fetches it, yeah, that's your fault for exposing it. It's also your responsibility for telling Google to remove it from their index. But if someone is poking around to see if urls are valid (eg: the /.ssh/id_rsa requests my website gets) that's breaking and entering, even though I'd be negligent for leaving my keys on the webserver like that.
- samstave 9y agoThis is why I've always had a bit of a trigger when I see signs that say, in a publicly accessible place, "No Photography!, as I, personally, am of the opinion that, if I have been able to freely and legally walk to a spot where I can see something with my eyes, I should be free to photograph or record it. It is My experience after-all, and it should not be infringed on me experiencing seeing something that is legal to see.
- paulcole 9y agoIt's kind of shocking that you can't "see" any difference between a picture and looking with your eyes. Also disappointing that you're (perhaps willfully) ignoring the many reasons why photography is banned/strongly discouraged in some public places.
- samstave 9y agoOh I can see it - I just don't agree with you or those that would sag that they should not be able to photograph such things... That's all - I just don't agree with you