9 ms·
It’s all too easy for headlines about climbing to lean on clichés about the climbers themselves—that these people are daredevils, thrill seekers, adrenaline jun
by kbenson 9y ago
It’s all too easy for headlines about climbing to lean on clichés about the climbers themselves—that these people are daredevils, thrill seekers, adrenaline junkies. But to most climbers, nothing is quicker to trigger the gag reflex. Climbing is an intimate relationship with our world’s most dramatic landscapes, not a self-boasting fight against them. I don’t claim to understand the inner workings of Alex’s mind, but I know one thing for certain: Alex climbs to live, not to cheat death.
Can someone help me understand this? How is doing something without safety equipment that you can do with with safety equipment climbing to live, but not about cheating death? What is the point of foregoing safety if not to somehow eke something out of the increased danger, whether it be adrenaline, or a period of increased focus, or fame?
If it's not about someone being addicted to adrenaline or looking for fame, then I just don't understand it. At all. As in it's so foreign to me that I can't even begin to understand it.
- hourislate 9y agoI would like Alex to get tested for toxoplasmosis. It would explain a lot.
- eicossa 9y agoIs the link between risky behaviour and a toxoplasmosis infection that well established ?
- hourislate 9y agoApparently so. I watch Joe Rogans interview with Robert Sapolsky which I might add was fascinating and he spoke about this at length and how people with toxo are more likely to take risks and or live dangerously. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=obmt_PkIfBE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=obmt_PkIfBE
- Radim 9y agoFor what it's worth, Joe Rogan interviewed Alex Honnold himself, a few years back: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OusYaNWBy08 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OusYaNWBy08 In a typical Rogan style, it's a pretty relaxed and "real" chat, about girls, shitting your pants, purpose etc. Gives a little more insight into how top athletes like Alex think and approach their craft.
- goldenkey 9y agoMost people have it but it can either be dormant or actively turning ones' brain into swiss cheese. Unless he's never gotten an MRI of his brain, I would doubt his brain is swiss
- cjonas 9y agoyou could say the same thing about top-roping vs lead climbing (placing protection from the ground up). Yes, top-roping is much safer, but the experience & sense of achievement is just not the same. Free-soloing (climbing without ropes) is the purest form of climbing. Not stopping to place protection, not having to bring up your partner, not having to haul a bag... It's just you on the wall. It takes most climber multiple days of painstaking climbing to summit Freerider. Alex did it in 4 hours. Beyond all else it's just a unbelievable feat of human ability. If you really want to understand just how impressive this was: 1: climb something (even if it's just 40 feet in a climbing gym) 2: Go to Yosemite and stand at the base of El Cap
- kbenson 9y ago> If you really want to understand just how impressive this was: I have no doubt it's impressive. I'm impressed. I'm not trying to diminish that in any way. > you could say the same thing about top-roping vs lead climbing (placing protection from the ground up). Yes, top-roping is much safer, but the experience & sense of achievement is just not the same. My question is why is the sense of achievement not the same. Is it because of the danger, or because it's inherently harder when you abstract danger from the situation? > Free-soloing (climbing without ropes) is the purest form of climbing. ... not having to bring up your partner, not having to haul a bag That's the closest I've seen to a an actual differentiation. Here's the question: If you could Free-solo the same wall but with without (or greatly reduced) danger? That is, hypothetically assume there's tracks installed vertically in the wall, and a robot that you are attached to ascends with you, so if you fall the robot keeps you from falling far and getting hurt. Does that somehow dampen the feeling of achievement when completed? If the answer is yes, then I fail to see how it's not about cheating death in some part. Which is fine! Just own that shit. I'm not making a value judgement about people doing this, I'm just trying to understand that statement. Either it is about cheating death to some degree and the author is not being truthful to someone (us or himself) for whatever reason, or it isn't about cheating death and I don't understand it at all, so I'm asking for clarification. Either I understand it, even if I don't practice it, or I don't understand it, in which case I want to. It sounds like it's about cheating death (even if just to get to some desired state easier).
- rukuu001 9y agoI think there's some nuance to to live here. There's the banal meaning, which is the opposite of dead. Another meaning, which I think the article meant, is to explore the outer limits of your ability and ambition during your incredibly brief period of existence in the universe. That's living. :) Edit: formatting.
- jjaredsimpson 9y agoYou have to embrace the ambiguity in natural languages. Life and death can be simply considered opposites. In this mode of thinking any risky behavior is trading in death at the peril of life. However you can also imagine a justification along these lines: There are certain things we humans can do which give us access to unique highly desirable mental states. Some of these are familiar things like falling in love or having children. These are risks but usually perceived as having obvious upsides. There are also other behaviors like drug use or underground fight clubs which also give access to unique mental states but are usually perceived as too risky to encourage. It's easy to put judge free soloing climbing as something like drug use or bareknuckle boxing. But try to imagine that when done correctly and carefully that it could be something much like having a child or working on a math proof for years.
- kbenson 9y ago> There are certain things we humans can do which give us access to unique highly desirable mental states. Sure. If cheating death is the path to that state for some people, that's understandable, and not really something new. I'm not judging him, this isn't some roundabout way to say people shouldn't free-solo. I'm literally trying to figure out if there's something else to it I'm missing, because the way it's stated makes it sound like there's something other than risk that's inherently different about free-soloing. People are responding as if I said I don't understand why someone would do a risky behavior. I understand the high from cheating death. I don't understand doing something as risky as this if you aren't necessarily looking for that high, as the statement implied to me. The alternative as I see it is that the author is reluctant to admit, or in denial about, some of the real reasons to free-solo. I didn't want to assume that without first checking my own assumptions.
- artursapek 9y agoPerhaps there's an athletic nuance as well - a roped-in climber can rest at any point during the climb by just hanging there, whereas a free-soloer can only rest at certain ledges along the way that naturally let him do that. It takes crazy stamina and self-discipline. Overall I agree with you that most of the feat seems to be about the risk, but there may be more to it (I'm not a climber).
- snowwrestler 9y agoEveryone lives their life in the face of impending death. Yet we usually judge the quality of our lives by what we accomplish, not the mere postponement of the inevitable. Climbers climb for the enjoyment of the experience, and to get to the top--not just to show that they can avoid falling. Alex is a rare elite climber, so he reaches for rare elite experiences and accomplishments.
- Bakary 9y agoLooks like he's not the dead-at-25-buried-at-75 type!
- skookumchuck 9y agoBy cheating death, one becomes famous. The article and this thread is proof of that. Being famous supplies many advantages and privileges.
- scottcha 9y agoI think the main thing you need to realize is that is climbing with ropes there is a lot of overhead involved to do it safely. I'd say about 1/8th of the time is climbing the other 7/8 is spent with the logistics of the rope management, partner management and placing protection in the rock. With free soloing you can focus entirely on the climbing and not on the logistics. I honestly think its more about this focus and flow and less about the cheating death.
- theparanoid 9y agoI free solo'ed small stuff, mostly 5.6/5.7. It's a rush, the desire will always be there.
- samstave 9y agoWhat's the rating of free solo El Capitan?
- Bartweiss 9y ago5.13a, as Honnold did it. There's a route without the dihedral that drops it down to 5.12d, but the rock isn't considered trustworthy anymore.
- basseq 9y agoFor anyone else who has no idea what these 5.x[a-d] numbers mean: http://outdoorswithdave.com/climbing/climbing-ratings http://outdoorswithdave.com/climbing/climbing-ratings
- collinmanderson 9y agoahh, 5.13 > 5.6. Thanks.
- luca_ing 9y agoI agree. This is why I prefer bouldering these days.
- sriku 9y agoTo "live" in this sense is, perhaps, to "flow" in the Mihaly sense. You can't flow if you're dead, but the flow you seek is not a panicked fleeing from death. Not too different from deciding to run a startup - small probability of success, certainty of exhaustion, possible alienation from family, etc. SV provides ropes for when you fail. Doesn't happen everywhere.
- js2 9y agoThe closest analog I can think of is Phillipe Petit's tightrope walk across the twin towers. Petit has similarly said that: “I am not a death-wish person,” he said to me. “I want to live very old. It is true that death is part of the frame—that it frames such activities as bullfighting and tightrope walking. My world is a dangerous world, sure, but I am very safe in knowing my limits. I am not playing with words when I say I don’t take risks. The danger becomes so narrow that it is a novel companion with whom you travel. It is not an enemy.” I know this isn't an answer, but if you've never seen the documentary about Petit, "Man on Wire", perhaps it would help to understand the mindset.
- jaggi1 9y ago> Climbing is an intimate relationship with our world’s most dramatic landscapes, not a self-boasting fight against them. For the same reason why many would spent hours catching fish over a lazy weekend when much better fish is available for $5 in super-market. For the same reason why someone would spend 5 hours trying to solve an interesting algorithms problem when one can easily find a solution on internet. I am not a climber. I have fear of heights but I can understand it.
- metachris 9y agoMany climbers have a fear of hights. Climbing can be a way to get comfortable with it.
- xernobyl 9y agoI climb and I'm afraid of heights, when I'm not climbing. I can't get near a ledge without an harness without feeling slightly dizy.
- paulmd 9y agoI'm a pilot and I'm terrified of heights. I get vertigo even thinking about looking over the edge of a cliff. I would also really like to try skydiving one of these years. I think that a better way to express it for many people is we're not afraid of heights, we're afraid of falling and dying. Removing the falling aspect "cures" the phobia.
- adjkant 9y agoAs a climber who is also scared of heights, I like to describe it as "a rational fear of heights". If I'm actually safe, I'm fine with it. It's the thought that a single slip, mental or physical = death. Even with a waist-high barrier, I'm still not going to look over the edge for fear of leaning too far. Give me a glass room hanging over the grand canyon that's stable and I'll be happy to go inside, lie face down on the floor, etc.
- hluska 9y agoI have a couple of things that might help you a bit: 1. Alex Honnold's brain is atypical. His amygdala simply does not respond to stimuli the way that it does in most people. To learn more, read this (excellent) article: http://nautil.us/issue/39/sport/the-strange-brain-of-the-worlds-greatest-solo-climber http://nautil.us/issue/39/sport/the-strange-brain-of-the-wor... 2. While I am (at best) a mediocre climber, the section you quoted rings true to me, particularly this section - "Climbing is an intimate relationship with our world’s most dramatic landscapes, not a self-boasting fight against them." There is something incredibly natural and sensual about climbing on rock that I can't describe without sounding like I'm talking about sex. And...that's traditionally where people tell me to give them my keys because I've had too much to drink. :) 3. Climbing is a deeply meditative activity, particularly when you get into a place where each movement flows into the next. When I am there, my mind shuts down and it is just a rock and me doing the most natural thing that I have ever found (see #2). That flow is deeply beautiful, but when you climb with ropes, you have to be in near constant contact with your belay partner. When I am with my regular belay partner, it interrupts that flow. When I am with a new belay partner, I never get close to it. I suspect that if my amygdala worked like his, I would free solo simply to avoid having to communicate with a belay partner.
- tvelichkov 9y agoI think I understand you, its like having a sex with or w/o a condom ;)
- vanderZwan 9y agoI think more like with or without the neighbours knocking on the walls telling you to keep it down
- idlewords 9y agoIt's like having sex without falling three thousand feet to your death.
- 9y ago
- msteffen 9y agoWhen you're free soloing, you climb much faster and with much less equipment. With safety equipment, climbing El Cap takes 2-4 days, and you have to pull up several bags of equipment behind you with pulleys. Without any safety equipment (i.e. free soloing) climbing El Cap takes a few hours and you just bring your body and some chalk. Plus it's just a cool thing to do (at least IMO). It's like, the dude is so good at climbing he doesn't need ropes.
- jjeaff 9y agoI find it funny that you mention that climbing el cap free soloing, "just takes a few hours" as if it wasn't just recently free soloed for the very first time in known history by one of the most skilled climbers of all time. It takes hannold 4 hours. It will likely never be tried successfully by anyone else.
- aaron695 9y agoIf you wore a helmet 24 hours a day you'd be living a safer life. Most people don't, because we want to live life not be scared of it. He's the same as the rest of us just on a different level. I find it kinda easy to understand even if it's not my thing.
- qume 9y agoDoes free diving vs scuba diving make sense to you? Basically different sports, rather than being about safety
- qume 9y agoDoes free diving vs scuba diving make sense to you? Basically different sports, rather than being about safety
- Angostura 9y agoI'm not a climber, but I imagine that there could be two things going on here: 1. The sheer pleasure of doing something unaided - people enjoy doing crosswords without referring to computer screen that will tell them all 7 letter words ending in g-something-t. 2. The pleasure of feeling yourself as part of nature. The walk in the woods wearing shorts and a T-shirt, rather than racing through it on a motorcycle.
- ObeyTheGuts 9y agoYe dude...climb with 10 kg of ropes n shit is nothing like freeeeeeeeeeee soloing!!! Thats so stupid of u, just go take a helicopter to da top....fucking piece of shit retard!
- bbctol 9y agoIt's about not being encumbered by all the extra material. People can feel more fulfilled by just experiencing themselves and the mountain, not themselves, the mountain, and a whole mess of carabiners and leveraged ropes. Honnold's no thrill-seeker, he just prefers doing things alone.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JoeDaDude 9y agoI'll let Charles Lindberg's words about his first parachute jump attempt an answer. Having been both a skydiver and a rock climber, I can say his thoughts are spot on. "When I decided that I too must pass through the experience of a parachute jump, life rose to a higher level, to a sort of exhilarated calmness... The thought left me a feeling of anticipation mixed with dread, of confidence restrained by caution, of courage salted through with fear. It was that quality that led me into aviation in the first place — it was a love of the air and sky and flying, the lure of adventure, the appreciation of beauty. It lay beyond the descriptive words of man — where immortality is touched through danger, where life meets death on equal plane; where man is more than man, and existence both supreme and valueless at the same instant." [1] [1] "The Spirit of St Louis", C. Lindberg, 1954. Quote was lightly edited for brevity.
- Bartweiss 9y agoOne fact that might help - setting safety gear generally consumes a significant portion of a climber's time and effort. It doesn't show in top-roped gym climbing, but going up El Cap means putting a great deal of work into hauling and placing safety gear. Free soloing versus geared climbing is almost comparable to free diving versus scuba. It's less safe, but removes so much overhead that it's a qualitatively different experience. Honnold's free solos in Yosemite are frequently world speed records - often by a factor of 2 or more. He's climbing with a directness and lack of complication that's really hard to attain any other way.
- Bartweiss 9y agoAnother thought - this is specifically about Honnold. Caldwell isn't just making a pretty-sounding claim, he's drawing a distinction between Honnold and other free soloists who were much more attuned to death, who seemed to be free soloing precisely for the adrenaline rush of survival. (Dean Potter is the classic example.) So I think this is a claim that Honnold is soloing for the purity and experience of the thing, specifically as compared to some other soloists who are more focused on adrenaline and risk.
- yayitswei 9y agoBy that logic, would you call doing a startup cheating poverty?
- pavement 9y agoIt's about perspective. One definition or opinion does not necessarily invalidate the other. Each is an expression of a point of view. You say safety equipment. Others might say encumbrance, or unnatural performance enhancer, or laziness cheat. An apparatus that enables a lessening of difficulty, which eases the challenge. When the goal is to engage a challenge, anything that renders the effort less challenging is a dilution of the very challenge as a whole. Of course one must use safety equipment to examine the possibility of a raw attempt. But one builds on the experience, removing the unnecessary, wherever possible. Of course it's easier to climb with a helmet and ropes, because those are the things that provide for obvious leverage to control the outcome. But who ever climbed a mountain because they wanted to do an easy thing? The harder the task is, the better, in this context. The satisfaction of accomplishment is the goal, rather than the stress or all of the physiological byproducts or recognition that come as part of the package when completing the task. Trying to do something, based on an intuition that an outcome is possible, when others lack the same intuition is the goal here. This is not the same as fame. Fame is a derivative of the behavior of others, as outsiders to the activity. To trust in one's intuition, and find that it is correct, is a fundamental aspect of human existence. To divorce oneself of maximizing challenge, is to lie in bed all day as a shut in, and have your food delivered to you, in the most exaggerated sense of the comparison.